dslreports logo
site
spacer

spacer
 
    ISP Rolodex Intro Local ISPs Members U-Verse FiOS FiOS Soon
spc

spacer




how-to block ads



Comcast page on DSLReports
Six Month Rating

Reviews:
bullet 5720 reviews (2476 good) (1664 bad)
bullet Submit a review by email click here
bullet login for new review notification feature

Review by Waymond See Profile

  • Location: Buttzville,Warren,NJ
  • Cost: $49 per month
Good "Fast downloads, sure beats 56k"
Bad "One-way telco return"
Overall "If you want broadband in my area its your only choice."
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

The download speed is great, Im just disapointed in that its not two-way.

When I ordered the service I was told that it would become two-way within a few months after they finished upgrading all the lines. So I figured I could deal wth using the phone lines for a few more months, well close to a year later Im still using telco return.

It really wouldnt piss me off as much if there was an update every once and a while showing what they have done, if they have even started. everytime I call its the same thing, No Estimated Time of Completion.

That and the fact that im paying 40.00(plus 10.00 for not being a comcast customer) for an incomplete service, because its not ALWAYS on (which I was just reminded of because the connection dropped as I was typing this), and I still have to pay for an extra phone line.

You would think they would drop the price a little for the fact you have to pay for an extra line untill they have the two-way service complete.



member for 13.7 years, 946 visits, last login: 1.1 years ago
lodged 12.8 years ago

Comments:

Review by chasmp See Profile

  • Location: Rockville,Montgomery,MD
  • Cost: $40 per month
  • Install: about 5 days
Good "quick set up, good speeds"
Bad "can't get my email to work"
Overall "so far, s'allright"
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

After waiting 2 years for any type of broadband, I'm glad that I didn't get sucked into a slower (available) 1-year DSL committment.

Having had bad experiences with the local cable company that Comcast bought out, and in many ways not seeing any improvement, I was leary of what quality they'd be able to provide. However, I was sick of dial-up and with a month-to-month obligation, what the heck. I only had to wait for about 5 days from ordering to having a technician come to the house and set me up. He replaced the existing old coax in the house and I was up and running in very little time.

I'm one of the first in my neighborhood to have this so I haven't experienced the overcrowding of the node yet. I figure that by the time it does get crowded, RCN will be available and either the competition will force comcast@home to up/maintain their quality or I'll jump to RCN.

member for 13.7 years, 653 visits, last login: 3.9 years ago
lodged 12.8 years ago

Comments:

Review by enragedcow See Profile

  • Location: Ypsilanti,Washtenaw,MI
  • Cost: $44 per month
  • Install: about 5 days
Good "Great install time, easy configuration, AWESOME speed!"
Bad "Fairly long hold times, but what can you expect?"
Overall "Wouldn't want to be without it again!"
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

I used to use Ameritech DSL here in Ypsilanti Michigan... what a joke!!! It took FOREVER for them to install, we had countless problems. it was a nightmare! Thus, when I changed apartments, I happily bid farewell to DSL and decided to try cable.

The ordering process was rather cumbersome, I have to admit. Because of all the cable company aquisitions/mergers, trying to figure out who serviced my area was difficult to say the least! Beleive it or not, I finally got to the website I needed by FIRST going to Mediaone.net, which linked me to ATT broadband, which linked me to Comcast.com, which linked me back to Mediaone.net and FINALLY back to comcast.com.... it was nuts.

Anyways, I ordered to cable quick because after the DSL fiasco i thought it would take forever to install. I placed my order, and to my shock the operator gave me a list of times for me to choose for install, and they could have installed within 3 days!!! Anyways, I ended up scheduling for a week later, from 11-3 on saturday.

11 came, and right on the dot the installer came. Very quick, friendly, and knowledgeable. He even helped me with my router

Speed is awesome, much better than DSL. All in all, I can't complain!! Comcast broadband rocks!!!


member for 12.8 years, 31 visits, last login: 8.2 years ago
lodged 12.8 years ago

Comments:

Review by Viperhawk See Profile

  • Location: Flint,Genesee,MI
  • Cost: $40 per month
  • Install: about 5 days
Good "After about 10 months.... mostly good!"
Bad "As with every cable, slow downs during peak usage hours."
Overall "No real complaints, plus an unexpected goody (see review)."
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)



I signed up during a back to school special (no, you didn't have to be a student or even have kids.

Free installation, free modem (can be bought for a reduction in the monthly bill).

And the 1st, 3 months were only 19.95. NOTE: When you call (if you aren't in a hurry) ask for when they will have specials running and tell them you are thinking about DSL as well ( sometimes they will give "sign up" incentives).

One unexpected goody was, as I allready had "basic Cable", the 39.95 a month price I was quoted for cable + my monthly basic fee of 11.00 something (at the time), turned out to be a total of $36 something for both services (cost as of last months bill).

Installation was as promised and took aprox. 1 hour.

Although there have been some loss of cable and 3 or 4 mail outtages (never more than a day. I sitll have to rate Comcast as a "must have" and "top value" at least in the Flint Mi. area.

Other cities may have slower speeds, it depends on number of users, or limits, but my average speed comes in at whatever the server I'm downloading from, I have hit speeds of 1000 to 42000 kbps off hours from servers like MS and Symanyec.

Tech.Supp....No problems just a couple of cable outages (their system takes a while for new outages to show up, but all problems were out side my home, not my hardware.

The only real gripe is that I have a fixed IP (have a good firewall handy



member for 12.8 years, 2 visits, last login: 12.6 years ago
lodged 12.8 years ago

Comments:

Review by Mr B See Profile

  • Location: Silver Spring,Montgomery,MD
  • Cost: $40 per month
  • Install: about 30 days
Good "A reliable, fast and trouble free service consolidated wih cable TV"
Bad "No warning for planned outages or service changes."
Overall "Well worth the time and money. Generally a positive experience."
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

My new home was prewired for cable, so the choice of Comcast@home was an easy one. I still consider myself on a test run, but the prospects look good for continuing the service. Cable internet access is in great demand around here so the wait for installation was long. My personal problem was a lack of a cable line directly to the house. It took three tries, one week each, to coordinate the outside linemen and the inside modem installer. These guys are great but since they are independent contractors, if something is not right they cut and run. Time is money.

There is usually a steady signal (with the exception of an odd 5 day outage for "upgrades"). Recent experience includes poor communication about planned outages and service changes. For example, service is periodically suspended and upload speed was suddenly capped at 128K without notification. I still can recommend Comcast@home . It seems a bit pricey but it is essential to my work and it is well coordinated with my cable TV service.

4 Stars

member for 12.9 years, 192 visits, last login: 5.2 years ago
lodged 12.9 years ago

Comments:

Review by karmann See Profile

  • Location: Knoxville,Knox,TN
  • Cost: $45 per month
  • Install: about 3 days
Good "Fast, very fast, good routing"
Bad "Comcast office & install company need to be on the same page."
Overall "Excellent service"
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

Called on Tuesday and asked about getting service. Asked about installation costs and monthly costs. Was told two incorrect pieces of information. a) The $59 install DOES NOT really include a "wall fish" ($32 more) and b) The cable modem installer does not hook up Cable TV as well (I ordered the $7 local broadcast only service to save the extra $3/month - $39.95 w/cable TV - $49.95 w/o cable TV). The latter is obviously no big deal as the Cable modem installer did hook up the Cable TV he just didn't setup the limited service. They have to come back later for that. The former however just ticks me off as I specifically asked the question and was told "Yes, the install of one inside cable drop is included in that price. Yes, WHATEVER IT TAKES. Through the ceiling, wall, floor whatever." Paraphrasing of course but you get the point.

The installer has serious punctuality issues as well. Scheduled for Thursday between 12-4. Came by at 1:40 and knocked (as in didn't ring the doorbell). The dogs didn't even hear him (and go NUTS with barking). Left note and drove off. Four phone calls later managed to get the scoop and was told he'd be by that night. Called at 5pm to say he'd be there around 7. Showed up at 8:30pm! Started thunderstorming so I agree to 8-9am Friday morning (I heard his boss tell him the time over his radio). Calls the next morning at 8:55 to say he's on his way. Shows up at 11:30am! Admits later that his boss had to come to his house to wake him up. Install done in about 2 hours. Nice enough guy just needs more caffeine or something.

I wouldn't let him touch my computer for that part of the install. I had it working in about 2 minutes from the time he hooked up the modem. He was going to all the wrong places to get it working in Win2KPro. Short call to tech support to get my default email password and I was up completely.

Gaming pings range from 45ms (Atlanta) to 110ms (Rochester NY). I'm throughly impressed and it's $3/month cheaper than my 128 ISDN. This service is awesome and so far I'd recommend it to anyone.

EDIT (8/17/01):

About 4 weeks ago my ping and bandwidth starting going to hell at around 9pm every night. During the day I ping as low as 85ms to Rochester, NY. By 9:30pm I'm pinging around 275ms. A tracert has indicated that I'm pinging about 250 to my 3rd hop in Nashville. A friend that works in their Nashville operations center has confirmed that this is an issue local to Knoxville. 3 weeks have gone by since I filed a trouble ticket with tech support. No emails, no response at all. If you have DSL or even ISDN and you're a gamer I would definitely not recommend switching to Comcast right now. Hopefully they will fix the problem but I'm not holding my breath.

EDIT (8/31/01):

To answer both your questions... I didn't want to change my overall ranking until/if I heard back from them. It hit my overall bandwidth and therefore my ping. I would sometimes get 400Kb download speeds during the day. This would drop to 25Kb during peak hours. The lowest I ever saw it go was 3.2Kb. Yes... 56K speeds. That friend in Nashville told me who to talk to and what to say here in Knoxville. I ended up calling the Head End Technician on Sharp's Ridge. He was not very happy that I tracked down his phone number but he did pass my problem along to the local repair guys. As it turns out Knoxville only had one DS3 (about 30 T1s) for all of Knoxville and Oak Ridge (5300 subscribers). They just installed a second DS3 (as of 8/30/01) that has solved my problems. Pings are back to how they were in July. I'm glad I didn't hold my breath but I'm very impressed that they spent that much cash to double their bandwidth. Let's just hope that next time they see this coming and increase it again before it becomes a problem. From what I hear not only did the ticket that I filed with @Home several weeks ago get their attention but the calls I placed to the Head End tech and local repair numbers got their attention. Overall I'm impressed. Not at all the horror stories I'd heard from friends online that had to switch back to ISDN because their cable got bad and never got fixed. Given this, I have boosted all my opinion rankings of them.

member for 14.2 years, 32 visits, last login: 5.9 years ago
updated 12.9 years ago

Comments:

Review by dpy See Profile

  • Location: Rockville,Montgomery,MD
  • Cost: $42 per month
  • Install: about 12 days
Good "Fast Service, Good Price, Cable Modem Rebate"
Bad "Some line packet loss, sometimes slow ping times"
Overall "I've had both SDSL and Cable. Let me tell you, nothing beats cable for the price"
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

I used to have SDSL with PSN and it was horrible. High ping times, packet loss, etc... That was last october. I was not able to switch ISPs because after PSN went bankrupt, Northpoint screwed up my Line and well, you can imagine the rest.

Anyway, I had been trying to get Cable (xDsl was not available for me) becuase I play LOTS of online games. I need low latency. Comcat juset became available. I called them and they said yes it was avaible. Finally, after a year of being broadband-less, I finally got it. They scheduled the installation date for the 30th. The guy came on time and quickly got down to buisness. Needless to say, my 25 year old house did not have the right cables for the job. He had to run a 150 foot cable to the reciever in my yard. They said they would come and bury in a couple of days and I'm waiting. The guy was good and generally knew what was going on. He even helped us run a new cable through the basement wall to the comp room.

So far, the sevice has been great but I occasiomally get packet loss but see, to get within 70-100% of my advertised speed.

Even if you DO have other broadband options, get cable. It's fast and cheap.

member for 13.4 years, 102 visits, last login: 6.6 years ago
lodged 12.9 years ago

Comments:

Review by john44 See Profile

  • Location: College Park,Prince Georges,MD
  • Cost: $49 per month
  • Install: about 3 days
Good "It Works"
Bad "Tech Support VERY POOR, IF you actually get to a Tech."
Overall "I would recommend Comcast,"
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

ADSL is NOT available in our exchange area.
My husband and I were pleased AND releived about the whole thing.
1500/128; Cable Install was Ok (8PM-9:30PM); dynamic,
We are ex Northpoint customers, thru IBS (which was a great IPS, we could not afford their business rates to stay with them $125+/ month. They still have $768 of our "up-front" contract money, but it's tied up in the bankruptsy court.).
We had an easy install due to previous experiences. We were well prepared for the service and trouble. Bought an RCA modem and had a Router & Hub.
The ONLY real problem was the Mail and News. Tech support supplied the server addresses (1.5 hrs, hope we don't have any real problems) and we were good to go. ALL problems after that were solved on our own, including a complete reinstall of our Network..

DSL Reports was our next stop! LOVE YOU GUYS!!!!

As a matter of fact DSL Reports was our main source of research for all our information on availablity, reliability and trouble shooting, (BEFORE and after) . All the reveiws and DSL Reports recommendations guided us. Thanks to all.

It's been almost 2 months and am still jet cruising the Internet, Email and News.

Scooter
Scooter@scootersdesk.com
College Park, MD USA

member for 13.8 years, 212 visits, last login: 6.3 years ago
lodged 12.9 years ago

Comments:

Review by mcnels1 See Profile

  • Location: Philadelphia,Philadelphia,PA
  • Cost: $49 per month
  • Install: about 12 days
Good "Quick install (especially compared to DSL)"
Bad "I can't access the support web site from work"
Overall "I hope I don't get bitten by another bankruptcy"
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

I used to have DSL access, but my original ISP went bankrupt (taking my installation fee which was supposed to be rebated), I switched ISPs, and then Northpoint (my CLEC) went bankrupt, leaving me without any service. Given the financial status of the other CLECs and that my ILEC is Verizon, I went without highspeed access for 5 months. Comcast finally started offering cable modem access to my neighborhood in July. There is a $9.95 intro rate for 3 months and then the service jumps to $39/month. I also pay $5/month to rent the cable modem and $5/month because I don't have cable TV.

Since I run a LAN behind a Linux firewall, I checked the Comcast and @Home web sites for technical information on compatibility, but of course they don't give any that I could find. Of course they only officially support Windows and Mac. The Linux cable modem howto gave enough info on service from @Home to lead me to believe that it would work, so I signed up.

Compared to DSL the intial wait time to install was very nice (12 days versus 6 weeks), and it took only one visit from the tech instead of two for DSL. I had the tech connect the cable modem (a 3Com shark fin; nice to know I have a discontinued product) to one of my internal Win98 machines, and then I switched it over to my firewall that evening. My IP address is dynamic, but fortunately it resolves against my hostname and not my MAC address, so I didn't have to swap NIC cards to get dhcpcd working on my firewall.

Uploaded speed (128) sucks compared to my old Northpoint SDSL (416/416), but then again download is better. So far I haven't seen better than 800 down. I guess I won't be hosting my own web site anymore (regardless of the fact that they don't allow it anyway).

I used the @Home support site to sign up for a second e-mail address for my wife. She didn't like the username I picked for her, so I tried to change it by accessing the support site from work, but I don't seem to be able to. So I'm guessing that you can only get there from inside the home.com domain. Not exactly optimal if I ever have a service interruption :-(.

I found out one thing that is kind of cool: apparently all cable UBRs (and don't ask me what UBR stands for; it is the computer/router one hop away) are NTP servers. So now I can easily have accurate time on my machines.

Having had service interruptions with DSL twice due to companies going bankrupt, I was thrilled to read about Excite@Home's financial problems yesterday. I just hope that Comcast has their act together if an ISP switch is required.

member for 12.9 years, 23 visits, last login: 7.5 years ago
lodged 12.9 years ago

Comments:

Review by Jessica7 See Profile

  • Location: Arlington,Arlington,VA
  • Cost: $39 per month
  • Install: about 45 days
Good "Rocket fast (2500KBS up and 750KBS down) and inexpensive"
Bad "Gets slow on weekends and no static ip"
Overall "Great unless all your neighbors have it too--then it gets slow."
Pre Sales information:
Install Co-ordination:
Connection Reliability:
Tech Support:
Services:
Value for money:
(ratings match consensus)

I ordered the standard cable modem internet access through Comcast@Home. I live in a new building, and although they told me that it was available, it was 3 weeks after the install before they could establish a connection. They said the problems connecting were a result of problems that they were having with the node, and once they got the problems fixed the service was flawless...UNTIL...3 or 4 months later when more people moved in and more people (presumably) signed up for the service. Now on evenings and weekends there is a noticable degradation in performance. This past weekend my speed dropped to 8KBS!!! Ack! I think their pipe to my building must be really jammed. I'm switching to DSL so that I can get a static IP (Comcast only provides dynamic addressing), but I think my switch may be just in time considering how quickly the service is slowing down. To be fair, the past couple of weekend and evening slow downs could be coincidental, but I doubt it.

member for 12.9 years, 2 visits, last login: 12.8 years ago
lodged 12.9 years ago

Comments: