Kdt @twtelecom.net |
Kdt
Anon
2011-Jun-7 6:53 pm
conceptually impressiveI have to say it doesn't sound like the world's worst idea. It is Comcast though, which isn't so great. But the concept -- ISP and security merged together -- ain't half bad. |
|
|
Preferred seems small Window/Door Sensors (4) Motion Detector (1) Wireless Keypad (1)
Keychain Remote (1) Touch Screen (1)
what does more cost $0.50 /m $2 /m $5 /m for each sensor? web site has stuff on it like Fire Monitoring (equipment not included)
Home Automation (Lights & Thermostat equipment not included)
Video Monitoring (equipment purchased separately)
|
|
tshirt Premium Member join:2004-07-11 Snohomish, WA |
tshirt
Premium Member
2011-Jun-7 7:05 pm
Price seems normal If you have or have looked into a home security service you'd see the pricing is pretty typical. It' is a smart bet for comcast, one more way to utilize the wire and generate a little more revenue (realise the fees all/mostly go to the security servce, with comcast claiming a small portion of the monthly fee for the wire (which previously would have been paid to the telco) plus some fee for the promotion/marketing aspect. I't a good deal for cable users too, even if they don't use the security service, the more revenue streams CC can establish the less likely any one service is to "HAVE TO HAVE" a major increase to pay for plant improvments. |
|
|
are you forced to rent a Emat as well or some other link?
Do you need to buy comcast phone as well or just HSI? Is basic TV needed as well? |
|
|
One ConcernSo my only concern would be for someone with triple play... Let's say you're not home and someone unscrews the cable line coming into the house... Does Comcast send out the police? How long would a truck roll take? They could attempt to call your home phone but obviously that number isn't going to be functional. Seems like there could be a lot of false positives if the infrastructure isn't working properly. (How many times do people have intermittent issues due to the weather?) |
|
N3OGHYo Soy Col. "Bat" Guano Premium Member join:2003-11-11 Philly burbs |
N3OGH
Premium Member
2011-Jun-7 9:02 pm
Comcast, trust us!I would just as soon hand over my ACH RTN & account numbers to the billing geniuses at Sirius XM before I trusted any Telcom provider with my home security.
The idea that a monitored alarm offers any sort of enhanced security for the average person is kinda specious reasoning. It's more the yard sign that keeps burglars away.
Your best bet is a good hardened safe for the truly irreplaceable stuff, good insurance for the stuff you leave out, and some sort of personal defense in the event of home invasion.
I have my personal preferences on the third item. Sig & Sauer, Colt (hey, it's all the Japanese you need to know!) and something to master your bushes, should your bush need to be mastered.... |
|
|
AK47 Draco AK47 RoMak3 Dragunov SVD 7.62x54 SKS Ruger P89 TTC 7.62x25
A few others, hopefully soon a Goryunov. |
|
|
to bman212121
Re: One ConcernCellular and Battery Backup Included |
|
pinjas join:2011-01-31 River Falls, WI |
to N3OGH
Re: Comcast, trust us!I couldn't have said it better myself. |
|
|
to bman212121
Re: One Concernsaid by bman212121:So my only concern would be for someone with triple play... Let's say you're not home and someone unscrews the cable line coming into the house... Does Comcast send out the police? How long would a truck roll take? They could attempt to call your home phone but obviously that number isn't going to be functional. Seems like there could be a lot of false positives if the infrastructure isn't working properly. (How many times do people have intermittent issues due to the weather?) The system has a cellular backup that handles alarms. This is available all of the time in case your cable service has an interruption. Thanks Chris Comcast |
|
NickD Premium Member join:2000-11-17 Princeton Junction, NJ
1 recommendation |
NickD to Kdt
Premium Member
2011-Jun-8 7:27 am
to Kdt
Re: conceptually impressiveIf the burglar alarm goes off I'd rather have the police show up than a Comcast tech, just saying |
|
|
Sounds good but...does Comcast's Home Security monitoring count towards your bandwidth usage? |
|
tshirt Premium Member join:2004-07-11 Snohomish, WA |
tshirt
Premium Member
2011-Jun-8 10:48 am
I'm guessing it does not, that it uses a dedicated channel like phone service does. (it might even just use one of the "phonelines") |
|
|
Wondering
Anon
2011-Jun-8 3:31 pm
MonitoringI just wonder if Comcast will keep statics of your alarm output? When turning on and off the system and other alarm output reports?
Who's watching who?
Will Comcast staff or others have access to the information?
Troublesome?????????????????
Cable tv does have limits. |
|
|
to ctg1701a
Re: One ConcernAh okay. Thanks! |
|
|
to tshirt
Re: Sounds good but...I was kidding. I am sure it doesn't....I was just taking a jab at Comcast and their caps. |
|