republican-creole
Search:  

 
 
   All ForumsHot TopicsGallery






how-to block ads


 
Forums » DD-WRT on the v5 WRT54G
Search Topic:
view: topics flat text 
Post a:

Comments on news posted 2006-04-05 09:12:26: The latest (v5) version of the popular Linksys WRT54G hasn't met user expectations. ..

AuthorAll Replies


Nate425
Premium
join:2005-02-03
Charlottesville, VA
clubs:
Nice!

That's awesome they can do that, now those routers can actually do something...but hopefully Linksys won't come down on them with lawsuits and what not.


jgkolt
Premium
join:2004-02-21
Lakewood, OH
clubs:
b router

now if only we could do this on the older bef11s4 router.


adisor19

join:2004-10-11
·Velcom
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Radioactif
·Videotron
·Look Communications

reply to Nate425
Re: Nice!

This router is still useless for the money Linksys charges for it. I say, go search for a WRT54GS rev 1 to rev 2.1 or at worse 3.0 and enjoy 8meg of flash space instead of 2 and 32 meg of ram instead of 8 !

You mind find some still in stores somewhere or just look on ebay instead

Adi


Nate425
Premium
join:2005-02-03
Charlottesville, VA
clubs:
Agreed...it's still a piece of junk, but at least those that are stuck with it can actually do something with it.

vannyx
Premium
join:2003-07-07
Bronx, NY

reply to adisor19
I have rev 2 using DDRT firmware. If i didnt need the static DHCP i would go back to the linksys firmware, i constantly have to restart the router 2 times a day because for some reason my internet connection chokes up and gets really slow most of the time. I use BT and Usenet and before with the linksys firmware it worked fine. But now after a few hours my connection gets really bad with this firmware.

radarman

join:2005-06-01
Odenton, MD

I doubt you would have better luck with the original firmware. Even the best linky's only had 32MB of RAM - and when you are using protocols like BitTorrent, where you are making connections to many different machines quickly, it doesn't take long before the connection table gets full.

It would help if EITHER firmware would do a better job of garbage collection, but alas - they both wait too long to clean up their ARP tables. The end result is that the machines bog down when you start connecting to a large number of unique hosts rapidly. The same thing will happen if you surf a lot of different sites in a short period of time as well, though it takes a lot longer - since you are presumably reading the web site, adding a delay. Note, if you can kill the ad servers with adblock, or a ad-blocking proxy, you can cut way down on the number of unique connections. Some websites will link to as many as a dozen ad servers or more.

Unfortunately, BT is a true "broadband" application, and most consumer routers have a hard time keeping up. My old (retired) Netgear router used to suffer the same problem as the Linksys routers. Eventually, they would run out of memory and slow way down (though the RT314 never did crash out on me)

This is one reason why I built a FreeBSD based router with 256MB of RAM. That machine has sat quietly in a closet routing non-stop for over 4 years now. Only power outages lasting more than 2 hours disturb its up-time - and its throughput hasn't decreased noticeably in all that time.

Asmodeus

join:2004-05-26
Spring Valley, CA

said by radarman See Profile :

I doubt you would have better luck with the original firmware. Even the best linky's only had 32MB of RAM - and when you are using protocols like BitTorrent, where you are making connections to many different machines quickly, it doesn't take long before the connection table gets full.

It would help if EITHER firmware would do a better job of garbage collection, but alas - they both wait too long to clean up their ARP tables. The end result is that the machines bog down when you start connecting to a large number of unique hosts rapidly. The same thing will happen if you surf a lot of different sites in a short period of time as well, though it takes a lot longer - since you are presumably reading the web site, adding a delay. Note, if you can kill the ad servers with adblock, or a ad-blocking proxy, you can cut way down on the number of unique connections. Some websites will link to as many as a dozen ad servers or more.

Unfortunately, BT is a true "broadband" application, and most consumer routers have a hard time keeping up. My old (retired) Netgear router used to suffer the same problem as the Linksys routers. Eventually, they would run out of memory and slow way down (though the RT314 never did crash out on me)

This is one reason why I built a FreeBSD based router with 256MB of RAM. That machine has sat quietly in a closet routing non-stop for over 4 years now. Only power outages lasting more than 2 hours disturb its up-time - and its throughput hasn't decreased noticeably in all that time.
maybe if someone found a way to hack more ram into the wrt54gs, then the issue of connection tables due to bt'ing would go away... i wonder what the total addressable memory of the gs really is...


guhuna
R.I.P Mike
Premium
join:2001-03-31
Brentwood, CA
...

What about the WRT55AG?
Seems that every other router out there has a hacked firmware for it but this one.
--
My Mother and Father once told me I was crazy!


peter_m
Premium
join:2005-07-13
Canada, QC
reply to vannyx
Re: Nice!

I'm guessing because it's a rev.2, you've had the WRT54G for a while. Have you tried a more recent version of the Linksys or DD-WRT firmware?

BillOSX33

join:2006-04-03
Chicago, IL
What?

Linksisinfo?


Sandman5
Premium
join:2002-07-10
Brookline, MO
clubs:

said by BillOSX33 See Profile :

Linksisinfo?
Hehe, I didn't even notice that 'til you pointed it out.
--
Rule #62: Don't take yourself so damn seriously!

dzr

join:2004-10-12


2 edits
reply to vannyx
Re: Nice!

said by vannyx See Profile :

I have a v2... i constantly have to restart the router 2 times a day because for some reason my internet connection chokes up and gets really slow most of the time.
If you're using P2P, that's a FAQ. Here is a link to useful suggestions, from the WIKI:

»wrt-wiki.bsr-clan.de/index.php?t···Slowdown

Any more followup, post to the proper fora.
They are also close to releasing v23 SP1. SP1 has alot of fixes over the original v23... and you may even have installed v22 on your box. You can try a beta now.


dvd536
as Mr. Pink as they come
Premium
join:2001-04-27
Phoenix, AZ
reply to Nate425
Thats nice. though that doesn't change the fact that these routers are neutered with half the physical ram of the older models.
--
You can never be too rich, too thin or have too much Bandwidth


netddos
Life Goes On..

join:2001-08-28
Fullerton, CA
openwrt is my only choice

doesn't matter to me..

openwrt all the way..

linux is the answer and nothing else..
--
"Life is not fair - get used to it" --Bill Gates 1996


bigunk
Gort, Klattu Birada Nikto

join:2001-02-10
Santa Clarita, CA
WRT54GL

What about the WRT54GL? Isn't that supposed to have gone back to open source capability? More memory, runs on Linux, and is wide open. Any thoughts?
--
Televideo ergo sum.....I watch TV, therefore I am.

dzr

join:2004-10-12

said by bigunk See Profile :

What about the WRT54GL? Isn't that supposed to have gone back to open source capability? More memory, runs on Linux, and is wide open. Any thoughts?
It's only available online and it seems to come and go... with rumors back and forth whether it is or isn't going to be discontinued. It is also more expensive without all the deals that the plain WRT54G has...


phoneboy2

@shawcable.net

reply to vannyx
Re: Nice!

Dude,

You will thank me for this advice. The default max # of ports is set too low for P2P. I had the exact same problem. Increase the max # of ports setting to 4096 and change the expiry time to 900s. It works INCREDIBLY well after you do that. Best firmware I have EVER used with that router doing a LOT of p2p. Best firmware period IMHO!!
Forums » DD-WRT on the v5 WRT54G


Friday, 27-Nov 14:45:17 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 10 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.republican-creole
page compression OFF