Search:  

 
 
   All ForumsHot TopicsGallery






how-to block ads


 
Forums » FCC: What Broadband Problem?
Search Topic:
view: topics flat text 
Post a:

Comments on news posted 2007-07-25 15:47:51: Freshly appointed FCC Commissioner Robert McDowell writes an editorial for the Wall Street Journal (non-reg. version here), and breaks the news to us (and rural America) that the country doesn't really have a broadband problem. ..

page: 1 · 2 · 3 · 4
AuthorAll Replies


PhoenixDown
-- Wants FIOS
Premium
join:2003-06-08
Fresh Meadows, NY
clubs:
What problem... how about this one?

I live in NYC yet I'm unable to get DSL. If I want broadband, my only choice is via Time Warner Cable.
--
Mass Transit Sucks!


Karl Bode
News Guy
join:2000-03-02
Um, move out of the sticks you crazy hick! Oh, er...


TKJunkMail
Enjoy the sun
Premium
join:2002-03-03
Avalon, NJ
·Sprint Mobile Broa..
·Comcast

 Experienced commissioner McDowell makes good points

»FCC: What Broadband Problem?
Freshly appointed FCC Commissioner Michael McDowell
The "Freshly appointed" adjective is supposed to make McDowell's points sound like they are coming from an inexperienced person. In fact, he took office more than a year ago.
»www.fcc.gov/commissioners/mcdowell/
sworn in as FCC Commissioner on June 1, 2006.
»www.fcc.gov/commissioners/mcdowe···phy.html
Commissioner McDowell brings to the FCC approximately sixteen years of private sector experience in the communications industry. Immediately prior to joining the FCC, Commissioner McDowell was senior vice president and assistant general counsel for COMPTEL, an association representing competitive facilities-based telecommunications service providers, emerging VoIP providers, integrated communications companies, and their supplier partners, where he had responsibilities involving advocacy efforts before Congress, the White House and executive agencies. He has served on the North American Numbering Council (NANC) and on the board of directors of North American Numbering Plan Billing and Collection, Inc. (NBANC).

Prior to joining COMPTEL in February 1999, McDowell served as the executive vice president and general counsel of America's Carriers Telecommunications Association (ACTA), which merged with COMPTEL at that time.
As to the points in his editorial statement:
OECD methodology is flawed as he adequately demonstrates;
Gov't regulation usually causes problems(I admit this is a debatable position depending on your viewpoint);
Broadband growth will continue based on new video apps.

--
--
Internet News
My BLOG
My Web Page


newview
Ex .. Ex .. Exactly
Premium
join:2001-10-01
Parsonsburg, MD
reply to Karl Bode
Re: What problem... how about this one?

Well gollleee . . . ain't that jus' whut they said when we got 'lectricity & telerfone . . .


JSRoman
Premium
join:2005-03-10
Callahan, FL

reply to PhoenixDown
said by PhoenixDown See Profile :

I live in NYC yet I'm unable to get DSL. If I want broadband, my only choice is via Time Warner Cable.
You at least have an option. Be glad you are not in Western Massachussetts,West Virginia,Maine or New Hampshire. I'm sure they are more no broadband areas but those are the ones that come to mind right away.
--
»www.seabee.navy.mil


Karl Bode
News Guy
join:2000-03-02
reply to TKJunkMail
Re: Experienced commissioner McDowell makes good points

rah rah rah

nasadude

join:2001-10-05
Rockville, MD
·Comcast

what stupid arguments

Europe also suffers from a dearth of robust competition from cable modem and fiber. Cable penetration is only about 21% of households. In the U.S., cable is available to 94% of all households. Also, the U.S. is home to the world’s fastest fiber-to-home market, with a 99% annual growth rate in subscribers compared with a relatively anemic 13% growth rate in Europe.

also highly misleading.

the U.S. is the only place on the planet, I think, where there are more cable broadband connections than DSL - you can thank our wonderful incumbent telcos for sitting on their @sses for several years for that particular statistic. That statistic tells you nothing at all about the state of competition. Also in Europe, they have been able to get video over ADSL+ or VDSL for a while now - that's why some people don't get it over cable.

Fiber growth rate; hmmm, let's see: if FIOS goes from 100,000 customers to 200,000 customers, that's a 100% growth rate if fiber in Japan goes from 1 million customers to 1.1 million customers, it's only a 10% growth rate - but how about that, they both add the same number of customers!

isn't lying with statistics fun!

I had hopes for McDowell, but it looks like he's just another big business douchebag (please note I didn't call him a republican douchebag, because, hey who knows, maybe he just hates consumers)

Ahrenl

join:2004-10-26
North Andover, MA
reply to JSRoman
Re: What problem... how about this one?

Southern NH has FIOS, just for the record.

Ahrenl

join:2004-10-26
North Andover, MA
reply to TKJunkMail
Re: Experienced commissioner McDowell makes good points

Every statistical analysis has error. I've yet to see a better methodology than the OECD's for US broadband. Do you suppose we just take the word of those who have the most to lose if it's less than true?

sm2016a

join:2004-03-02
Belleville, IL
·VoipYourLife


1 edit
reply to nasadude
Re: what stupid arguments

The statistics can be very misleading if you do not take the time to see what they mean. The growth rates really don't mean as much as everyone thinks as nasadude has pointed out. The U.S. will continue to lag behind other countries in means of broadband due to people like McDowell.

Criticisms of our definition of “broadband” being too lax are already irrelevant as over 50 million subscribers are in the 1.5 to 3.0 megabits-per-second “fast lane.”

I do not consider 1.5 to 3.0 fast lane broadband. Fast lane would be 5.0+ in my opinion and that is being considerate since 5.0 is not technically a fast lane broadband speed.

tpac_man

join:2007-02-27
Riverbank, CA
DITTO!

new2fios

join:2006-07-20
Camillus, NY
reply to nasadude
What's wrong with there being more cable than DSL connections? Cable is equal to or superior to DSL. And Fios has well over a million customers.

kaila

join:2000-10-11
Lincolnshire, IL
clubs:

reply to nasadude
said by nasadude See Profile :

.....the U.S. is the only place on the planet, I think, where there are more cable broadband connections than DSL - you can thank our wonderful incumbent telcos for sitting on their @sses for several years for that particular statistic.....
It's more than just incumbent's sitting on their butts. In my case, AT&T can make no business case for bringing DSL to the relatively well off community where I live, right in the middle of Chicago suburbia. There has been cable broadband here for so long that Comcast has built up too much market share for them to enter. Although we've been told if Sprint's WiMax has even modest success here when they roll out next year, AT&T will be forced to finally offer DSL.

sm2016a

join:2004-03-02
Belleville, IL
·VoipYourLife

reply to new2fios
I don't think he was saying there is anything wrong with it. He was pointing out that it is due to the teleco's being lazy about deploying broadband unlike the cable co's were. Hence why there are more cable than dsl connections. If the teleco's would have been more proactive the broadband availability could be higher and there could be more competition.

axus

join:2001-06-18
Washington, DC
·Verizon Online DSL

can have more competition without gov regulation

It's crazy if they can't admit there is a problem... I'm not saying its a life-threatening problem but we used to not have telephones or electricity everywhere either.

FCC should be enabling competition with its efforts, first they need to identify places where competition isn't (rural areas and apartment buildings) and support new methods to reach them (700Mhz spectrum would have been nice, municipal broadband efforts, even powerline broadband).

FCC should not regulate things like prices or what services can or can't be offered, they are supposed to take care of interference concerns and compatibility... I think network neutrality is an interference and compatibility concern however.

Eric Martin

join:2005-06-19
66308
Wall Street Journal , Forbes, Businessweek.

Are all sellouts to rich corporates.

Your not going to find objective journalism in their rags.

All of them are again network neutrality. They side with TimeWarner and Cox.

bmn
? ? ?
Premium,ExMod 2003-06
join:2001-03-15
hiatus

reply to TKJunkMail
Re: Experienced commissioner McDowell makes good points

said by TKJunkMail See Profile :

The "Freshly appointed" adjective is supposed to make McDowell's points sound like they are coming from an inexperienced person. In fact, he took office more than a year ago.
One year of experience still isn't all that much...

OECD methodology is flawed as he adequately demonstrates;
Michael McDowell has a statistics degree or has statistics/research design training ? Okay, so where is his study analyzing the problems ? I want numbers... Something that I can plug into all the stats formulas I learned and see if he really is right.
--
Prove it...
Save the Internet Time (NTP) service, use the pool.

qworster

join:2001-11-25
Los Angeles, CA
·DSL EXTREME
·Brand X Internet
·RoadRunner Cable
·Vonage


1 edit
He's kidding - Right?

He sounds like a Bush mouthpiece (which essentially he is), telling us to TRUST the FCC, because they CARE about us the consumer...and everything will be all right.

Let me clue you into something....

The FCC is run by the Executive Branch (President Bush). It is one of THE MOST corrupt branches of Government-and under Bush, this corruption has increased a dozen fold!

Big companies have GREAT access to the FCC-especially the big cable and phone companies. They get whatever they WANT from the FCC. Big law firms also have almost unfettered access to the decision makers at the FCC-in fact, MOST FCC staffers JOIN these law firms after they leave the FCC (payback!).

If the Chairman of the FCC told me that the sun rises in the east, I'd be standing at the Santa Monica pier early in the morning looking west for the sunrise.

THAT's how bad it is at the FCC these days.....


TKJunkMail
Enjoy the sun
Premium
join:2002-03-03
Avalon, NJ
·Sprint Mobile Broa..
·Comcast

reply to bmn
Re: Experienced commissioner McDowell makes good points

said by bmn See Profile :

said by TKJunkMail See Profile :

The "Freshly appointed" adjective is supposed to make McDowell's points sound like they are coming from an inexperienced person. In fact, he took office more than a year ago.
One year of experience still isn't all that much...

At least 16 yrs experience in telecom. »www.fcc.gov/commissioners/mcdowe···phy.html
--
--
Internet News
My BLOG
My Web Page


TScheisskopf
World News Trust

join:2005-02-13
Belvidere, NJ
reply to Karl Bode
You forgot "siss boom bah". I hate it when that happens.

Oh, and while I was reading the "worthy's" bio, the phrase "industry shill" kept running through my head. Why is that?
Forums » FCC: What Broadband Problem?page: 1 · 2 · 3 · 4


Sunday, 29-Nov 02:04:34 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 10 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.
page compression OFF