Search:  

 
 
   All ForumsHot TopicsGallery






how-to block ads


 
Forums » Pirate Bay To Buy Sealand » Great...
Search Topic:
Share Topic:
RSS topic:
toggle:
flat / full
normal / watch
Post a:
Post a:
« It might happen yet  
AuthorAll Replies


Snickerdo
Premium
join:2001-02-28
Niagara Falls, ON

reply to RadioDoc
Re: Great...

said by RadioDoc See Profile :

Bates and co. have been left alone by the UK mostly because they aren't worth the trouble and aren't bothering anyone but that could change...he's getting old and is no longer in residence, and they had a significant fire on the platform last summer. His kid is in charge of whatever it is they have out there.
One thing that also must be remembered is that the Germans actually sent an ambassador there sometime in the late 80s/early 90s to secure citizens that Bates was holding on the fort as prisoners for treason. Some experts claim that by sending a representative to Sealand - and not to the UK - to negotiate with Bates, the Germans may have legitimized Sealand's claim as a nation, if not officially then in a de-facto manner.

The Law of the Sea treaty, which extended territorial waters, also makes note of platforms, oil rigs, etc that platforms AFTER the signing of the treaty can not be recognized as sovereign entities. It does not say that existing platforms are included if no claim is made to them. Frankly, the only way anything like this would be settled is in some international forum. Me thinks that both the British and the Germans may have unintentionally legitimized Bates' claim.
--
Bigot - Someone that has won an argument with a Liberal.
Yes, I CanChat. Can You? www.fiberal.ca

emptywig
Huh? What?
Premium
join:2002-08-05
Pasadena, TX

I don't think anyone has unintentionally legitimized anything. If the Chancellor of Germany herself showed up, no one anywhere recognizes a bunch of people living on an old gun platform as an independent nation. The whole idea is a bunch of tomfoolery and humbug that has been given too much weight.

No reasonable, thinking person can honestly believe that any nation anywhere would let a handful of people set up just twelve miles away from shore and declare themselves outside the laws of that nation. There is a difference between indulging the fantasies of a few half-cracked eccentrics, and actually allowing them independence and sovereignty.

Sealand is just a silly fort for grownups. Mom and Dad don't come out there, but they could if they wanted to, and if they tell you to come in and wash up for dinner, you sure as hell better do so.

wig
--
Sometimes a paradox is just a paradox


Snickerdo
Premium
join:2001-02-28
Niagara Falls, ON

said by emptywig See Profile :

I don't think anyone has unintentionally legitimized anything. If the Chancellor of Germany herself showed up, no one anywhere recognizes a bunch of people living on an old gun platform as an independent nation. The whole idea is a bunch of tomfoolery and humbug that has been given too much weight.
Perhaps you should learn a bit about interntional law before making such claims:

said by »en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealand#Legal_status :
In international law, the two most common schools of thought for the creation of statehood are the constitutive and declarative theories. The constitutive theory was the standard 19th-century model of statehood, and the declaratory theory was developed in the 20th century to address shortcomings of the constitutive theory. In the constitutive theory, a state exists exclusively via recognition by other states. The theory splits on whether this recognition requires "diplomatic recognition" or merely "recognition of existence". It is clear that no other state grants Sealand diplomatic recognition, but it has been argued by Bates that negotiations carried out by Germany constituted "recognition of existence". In the declarative theory of statehood, an entity becomes a state as soon as it meets the minimal criteria for statehood, such as those defined by the Montevideo Convention. This asserts that a defined territory, permanent population, government and the capacity to enter into relationships with other sovereign states are the only foundation requirements for a sovereign state. None of these requirements necessarily has to conform to a certain size or standard, but their general characteristics should be taken into account.

On December 6, 2005, The Times claimed that the British government and courts had finally admitted that Sealand "is outside British national territory [...] and not part of the United Kingdom"; however The Times did not elaborate and there has been no confirmation by other sources.
While there is certainly debate on this matter, simply writing it off as non-existent is foolish, as there are a number of arguments and situations that legitimize Mr. Bates' claim.
--
Bigot - Someone that has won an argument with a Liberal.
Yes, I CanChat. Can You? www.fiberal.ca

emptywig
Huh? What?
Premium
join:2002-08-05
Pasadena, TX

Unless you're an international lawyer, don't be patronizing. We've all read the Wikipedia article,too.

Sealand has no diplomatic relations with anyone. Anywhere. Anyhow. Its in British waters (12 miles). There is no dispute. What you quoted from Wikipedia proves nothing, establishes nothing different. In practice, and in any other way you care to think about it, Sealand is in British waters. Full stop.

wig
--
Sometimes a paradox is just a paradox


Snickerdo
Premium
join:2001-02-28
Niagara Falls, ON

said by emptywig See Profile :

Unless you're an international lawyer, don't be patronizing. We've all read the Wikipedia article,too.
Sealand has no diplomatic relations with anyone. Anywhere. Anyhow. Its in British waters (12 miles). There is no dispute. What you quoted from Wikipedia proves nothing, establishes nothing different. In practice, and in any other way you care to think about it, Sealand is in British waters. Full stop.
So let me get this right, I'm patronizing and have no right to post an opinion on the matter because I'm not a lawyer who specializes in International Law? You might want to actually stop being so arrogant and actually live up to the same standard that you apply to others, or am I missing the fact that you, in fact, have an LLD focusing on International Law and have more understanding on this matter than just being some talking head yapper mouth posting on an Internet forum with nothing more than an opinion? If you are an LLD, credentials, perhaps? Or, just maybe, you should hold others to the same standard you put on yourself and stop being a jackass?
--
Bigot - Someone that has won an argument with a Liberal.
Yes, I CanChat. Can You? www.fiberal.ca

emptywig
Huh? What?
Premium
join:2002-08-05
Pasadena, TX
Oh please. I'm right. End of story.

Good day.

wig
--
Sometimes a paradox is just a paradox


Snickerdo
Premium
join:2001-02-28
Niagara Falls, ON

said by emptywig See Profile :

Oh please. I'm right. End of story.
Good day.
wig
Hah oh my, what a child you are. Going to stamp your feet and ask for your bottle? There many other actual experts (you know - people who do more than post in a forum like this) who would disagree with you on this issue. If you can't handle debating an issue without taking your ball and going home, just don't bother coming out to play.
--
Bigot - Someone that has won an argument with a Liberal.
Yes, I CanChat. Can You? www.fiberal.ca
Forums » Pirate Bay To Buy Sealand« It might happen yet  


Saturday, 28-Nov 19:07:49 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 10 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.republican-creole
page compression OFF
Most commented news this week
· [122] Time Warner Cable Fires Broadside At Broadcasters
· [112] New AT&T Ad Campaign Hits Back At Verizon
· [96] Apple Joins AT&T Verizon Snark Fest
· [87] New Bill Takes Aim At Higher Verizon ETFs
· [80] TiVo Sees Record Customer Losses
· [70] Verizon CEO: Hulu Will Be Dead Soon
· [69] In-Flight Internet Headed For Bumpy Landing?
· [66] Weekend Open Thread
· [62] Thanksgiving Open Thread
· [40] EFF Wages War On Fine Print
Most people now reading
· 3.x Feral Druid - Bear Tanking Guide [World of Warcraft]
· [Newsgroups] Newzleech down? [Filesharing Software]
· Windows 7 boot manager editing questions [Microsoft Help]
· 'The antivirus industry sucks' [Security]
· [How to] Install Asterisk on an Asus WL-520GU router [VOIP Tech Chat]
· [ Classes] Druid tanking: rotation and glyphs [World of Warcraft]
· Using AirMax to provide triple play services? [Wireless Service Providers]
· Why not just turn off the ignition? [Automotive]
· Gizmo5 has added a Google Voice section in its members area. [VOIP Tech Chat]
· how to use the 2nd line with phone hooked to the 1st line? [VOIP Tech Chat]