Blackened
Your Freedom Fries Are Stale
join:2003-09-29
| reply to nixen
Re: Privacy issues and deployment chief concerns
said by nixen  :While generally not in favor of data mining, one has to look at things rationally. If the fee structure is such that the network would be operated at a loss, there has to be some form of recovery mechanism to make operating the network financially tenable. If that means data mining, then that's the price you pay for your subsidized usage. To repeat, I don't know San Fran's budget, but ideally if something like this is going to be provided, it should be expected to operate at a loss. This is where government services can be provided with some return investment, without a collection of personal information. It's been shown, from banks to credit unions, how shoddy companies are at keeping personal information secret. They lost my trust ages ago.
I think about it this way. Financial aid for my schooling doesn't require a return investment -- not everything does. It's based off of taxes. However, colleges do raise tuitions (or require more funding) to pay for their wiring of students. Difference? Just in size. Likewise, if San Fran. can't find a way to trim something less important off of the budget for a necessary service like this, then they should raise taxes, find other city-owned possibilities, or nix the plan until they can figure something reasonable out. A government handing over personal data to corporations, on the other hand, is not an option. Just like handing my FAFSA information over to Earthlink or Google is not an option.
Another thing to add onto that is service related to Google. Google has enough trouble getting Mountain View correctly wired. The service (read: signal strength) is crummy, despite there being so many access points. In many areas you practically have to be standing on the sidewalk next to the access point just to get their service. Defeating for people in their houses, parked in their car, or at a shop. |
Time4aNAP
Premium
join:2007-04-09
Des Plaines, IL
| said by Blackened :A government handing over personal data to corporations...is not an option. I hate to break it to you this way, but you're too late to the party, and you're out of options. There's even a database somewhere that keeps track of how often you flush the toilet, and it's for sale to anyone with enough money. |
