said by MDReferee :

I thought about that and it was totally unintentional... I had intended to have htmlartist just chalking moons to make you all think there was also a star cult, but I got caught up in the flavor text early on (and you caught me) so I did something on the fly to add back in the uncertainty and inadvertently blew cow's cover. In the end, it didn't matter because that night was when he attempted to recruit jehu.

said by 42246015 :

That's a good point. We need to be looking at the people that have been lurking and not participating. Historically, the mafia and especially the serialkiller/werewolf roles have always been very, very quiet.

Now if we base a list of who's a bad guy and who's a townie on their participation, the list would look like this, if my research is correct:

Townie:
Jehu
AmeritecTech
hesher
htmlartist
muzcsman
lollercakes
azntechnology
lurlyn
cow
older dog

Bad guy (mafia/SK/werewolf/cult/etc):
Yock
Marijuana
kewlkarim
Sharingan77
Mastr Blastr
TeatherWind
Obliteration
Chlen
Jagermeister

Now this list is probably not in the least bit accurate, so don't take it as such. I'm just basing this off of people that have been active in the thread, and people that have posted long posts, etc, versus people that have not been very active in the thread and have posted very short posts or no post at all. And this is just a quick list of people I have come up with off the top of my head based on what I remember, I haven't actually gone through, calculated how many times someone has posted, etc.

So basically this list is just for fun. But still something to consider.

said by yock :

I want lollercakes to be the traitor every time I'm not mafia.

said by kewlkarim :

i'm really happy with the results...even tho some people might say that they didn't vote for me coz i was new
but it was very fun, thanks

said by Obliteration :

Nobody ever listens to Obliteration, especially at the end. AmeritecTech's claim to frame him should have had the remaining townies up in arms and lynching him.

said by muzscman :

holy crap...good job. i mean fantastic job guys.

i say we let game 10 finish up then we can start two smaller games. this 23 person game lasted waaaay to long.

said by Obliteration :

The amount of people is fine. People who don't participate need to be mod killed faster and make it role revealed. They tend to go much faster and be a lot more interesting as in my opinion they require more skill since these keep the town in the dark the whole game about how many are against them.

Frankly, I think a 50 person game would be interesting but it would never reach that point since I doubt that many people want to play.

The reason these go so slow is because they are closed mainly. Meaning nobody knows what roles they have or don't.

said by AmeritecTech :

Not necessarily. If you had been going after someone else, I would have killed you to frame that person, in which case lynching that person would have been bad for the town.

Your case against me was not great. It consisted mostly of "he seems like a townie, therefore he is mafia". That said, you're one of the few people that we killed because you were considered a threat.

Your mafia blocking was a non-issue because we had you role-blocked.

But anyway, I think you played the game really well, and you kept implicating our members. I had to hold them back from killing you several times because of the consequences it would have had in implicating us. Well done!

said by Obliteration :

Lurlyn was asking you for advice after all right after like 10 townies deaths.