how-to block ads
|
|
Share Topic
 |
 |
|
|
 tshirtPremium,MVM
join:2004-07-11
Snohomish, WA
kudos:3
 ·Comcast
| reply to Karl Bode
Re: Um. It actually could work.... as a last mile OPTION, or let's say a last half mile option, it avoids tearing up the streets (and other utilities) to get from an ISP/backbone provider to the building, from there it's ( or should be) up to the building owner to wire from the meter to the point( or points in multi user dwelling/businesses) of use.
while BBoG deployment would be subsidized by the gas company (by eliminating meter reader positions  )
there is no reason for the public to finace/subsidize the provider (gas company and partners) or subsidize the building owners retrofit.
What governemnt can do is set current and long term/long term planning standards for regulation of BB providers (irregardless of delivery method) and for building owners to allow reasonably return on their investment, if they provide reasonable service, at a reasonable price. (you sign a 20 year lease and then landlord mentions the $$$$ "Fee" increase for getting the advertised "broadband availablity" from the ground to your 5th floor apt/business  ) | |
Time4aNAPPremium
join:2007-04-09
Des Plaines, IL | said by tshirt:It actually could work... Of course it can work! Any utility with established rights-of-way has hegemony in the real estate necessary to deploy any new to-the-home technology. That alone is 90% of the entire package.
Let's be realistic about this. The current utility infrastructure was made possible by the Industrial Revolution, FDR's work programs that got us out of the Great Depression, and postwar domestic growth after the two world wars. By 1970 there wasn't the will or the wealth in America to make way for new rights-of-way.
What we do have is an archeologist's treasure trove of abandoned vaults, conduits, pipelines and other buried structures that have been long-forgotten. Some day these will be the pilot guides for new excavation techniques that can reclaim these abandoned spaces. Meanwhile, natural gas companies are constantly replacing old, leaky pipelines with new ones. So as not to disrupt service for long periods of time, the new lines are often laid down right next to the old ones. And to save money, the old lines are left where they are, rather than go to the expense of removing them.
Here's the cool part: the pipes that are no longer suitable for carrying flammable gas under pressure are often still serviceable as conduit for fiberoptic cable. Since they're no longer going to be carrying a potentially dangerous gas, any leaks can be made watertight cheaply. The result, an instant fiber backbone at a minimal cost.
The last mile is the most realistic application for BiG, since it's unlikely that every street will have a suitable conduit, and it's doubtful that simply energizing a large metropolitan area with uncontrollable UWB would really work. As for reading meters, an RF system has been in use for a long time in many places. I don't see utilities, gas or others, scrapping working systems and installing new ones "to save money". Similarly, those places that still have people going to each meter will have to pay for the new meters themselves, at the same time that they're making the other major capital investment. Between that and the workers' unions, "eliminating meter reader positions" would have a high initial cost at the worst possible time, speaking financially. So no, the gas companies would be in no position to offer subsidies to anyone.
I really doubt that the gas companies are going to attempt to bring BiG to multi-tenant buildings until the technology has proven itself, and has all of the kinks and bugs worked out in single family home neighborhoods. It's important that the initial rollout is a success. Suburban subdivisions that were built all at once, with every street and house having the same physical (and therefore, hopefully the same electrical) characteristics are the obvious places to start because they face the fewest unknown variables. I also doubt that the meter, which is usually located outside for safety reasons, would be the most suitable place to put the CPE for broadband. | |
|
