Search:  

 
 
   All ForumsHot TopicsGallery






how-to block ads


 
Forums » White Spaces Coalition Re-Tests Spectrum-Seeking Device » No way
Share Topic:
RSS topic:
toggle:
flat / full
normal / watch
Post a:
Post a:
MaroonGuru

join:2003-09-03
Oconomowoc, WI

Re: No..

said by qworster See Profile :

It can use an omnidirectional antenna and a VERY narrow bandwidth radio centered on the middle of the TV channels it's scanning. Since the UHF DTV channels are sequentially allotted and exactly 6 mHz apart, this kind of radio is EASY to build! Remember, all it has to do is SENSE a carrier signal-and a 250,000 watt - 1 megawatt signal from atop a tower 500 feet or higher at that!

If a 25 year old Radio Shack scanner can do this-with low powered 2 way radio signals no less, then why can't a white space device?

Also remember, both FM and TV channels (stations) are allotted by the FCC to broadcast to specific markets. TV stations are only afforded protection within clearly defined service contours.

The fact that you might be able to pick them past these contours is irrelevant!

Disclaimer: I am a broadcast engineer with over 30 years experience. I understand REAL WORLD interference, as opposed to LAWYERSPEAK interference, which is usually shown to the FCC and/or Congress by the NAB along with a sizable cash payment!
First: Don't look at the "center" of the channel. ATSC broadcasts using 8VSB not COFDM, so the carrier is off-center. The device ought to look there. No more Audio carrier to hone in on anymore either.

Second: Although the broadcasters are licensed for coverage areas, and are afforded some measure of protection within them, it is in the public interest that reception is possible outside the defined contours. I for one enjoy receiving DTV stations from the two markets I straddle. It is entirely possible that one of these nifty white space devices could end up nearby and obliterate my reception of one or more channels.

If you are a broadcast engineer, you might recall the old maxim, that "Proximity beats Power." I recall a local low band VHF station got messed up pretty badly by a guy with an amplifier hooked to his VCR output and interfering with a sizeable chunk of nearby homes. This was in a town about 20 miles away and the affected viewers who were behind a hill. Something a white space device (WSD) could easily duplicate. FYI, I used to go through that town, and the residents have their antennas on tall roof mounted masts. So, a living room based WSD would not see the same signals as the TVs do.

I understand that the WSD could provide a multitude of benefits if used correctly, but I can see lots of possible problems. Probably the biggest from the collective brains of the internet. How long did it take between the introduction of 802.11b and people finding ways to increase the range and power. Remember, the FCC required special non-standard connectors in the beginning to avoid people boosting effective radiated power by changing antennas. The unhackable/secure iPhone didn't last long. Can we really expect us geeks to not find a way to get more out of a WSD? Even if you lock it as tight as say HD-DVD or BluRay?

And as a disclaimer, I am not only a broadcast engineer, I am also an attorney. A fun combo indeed.
Forums » White Spaces Coalition Re-Tests Spectrum-Seeking Device


Wednesday, 02-Dec 18:02:00 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 10 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.
page compression OFF
Most commented news this week
· [160] Comcast Releasing Promised Usage Meter
· [90] Graduate Student Unveils Sprint's GPS Sharing With Feds
· [78] Latest Consumer Reports Survey Not Kind To AT&T
· [70] Baltimore To Ban Lazy Cable Installs
· [62] Broadband Killed The Game Console
· [54] Rogers Unveils The ISP Dream Model
· [46] ACTA: Global Three Strikes
· [41] Rural Carriers Quickly Embracing Fiber
· [38] Charter Exits Chapter 11
· [33] AT&T Top Lobbyist Cicconi Has His Feelings Hurt
Most people now reading
· MS admits Windows Updates principally created to annoy [Security]
· IMG 1.7 (IMG Updates and Discussion) [Verizon FIOS TV]
· UBB round 2 at the CRTC [Canadian Broadband]
· Am I the only one that loves to work in IT? [No, I Will Not Fix Your #@$!! Computer]
· [Scam] Cruise line mail? [Spam, Scam and Phishbusters]
· Quality/longevity of 15A 120V receptacles [Home Repair & Improvement]
· Heating - my dad gave me this advice... [Home Repair & Improvement]
· A little freaky, not sure if its legit. [Spam, Scam and Phishbusters]
· HOW-TO: QoS and Tomato (fixes "choppy voice") [MagicJack]
· [Equipment] Tomato with VOIP warning [VOIP Tech Chat]