 navyet2swDamned is in My Room
join:2001-12-09
Virginia Beach, VA | reply to Dezbend
Re: [game] Mafia variant - shirts #30 yup, sorry muz
unvote muz
i think we need to put some pressure on gomez to see what he has, since he has kind of avoided us so far.
--
Everything in life is mind over matter, if you don't mind it doesn't matter. |
|
 GomezExile in waitingPremium,Ex-Mod 06-11
join:2001-02-21
Atlanta, GA | reply to muzscman
said by muzscman:Navy, you should retract your vote until we can talk about this a bit more. If gomez is the killer, he can come in and end the game right now. If I was the bad guy, I would have done that already. Please reread the assumptions above.
It's impossible for navy and I to see the same hat if we're both good guys no?
Show me the flaws in the logic I have already posted.
--
It's a fact : Chicks dig Mafia players. |
|
GomezExile in waitingPremium,Ex-Mod 06-11
join:2001-02-21
Atlanta, GA | reply to navyet2sw
said by navyet2sw:yup, sorry muz unvote muz i think we need to put some pressure on gomez to see what he has, since he has kind of avoided us so far. I think You are avoiding this: »Re: [game] Mafia variant - shirts #30
I also want to hear Muz's comments.
In an effort to better understand the game, I'm going to say that the color of my hat is completely irrelevant at this point. This is about solving at with minumal information.
I'll explain that post game, as well as what I see as the fatal flaw in the game play thus far.
You could, of course save time, and admit your busted rather than waiting for Muz.
--
It's a fact : Chicks dig Mafia players. |
|
navyet2swDamned is in My Room
join:2001-12-09
Virginia Beach, VA | reply to Dezbend
I was hoping that we could hang him early.
here is the issue that i have.
Gomez, why are you sooooo sure about the sane and insane one? why does one have to be sane and one not?
you seem to be dead set that someone is not right in the head. and i don't understand why that is the issue here. I am on the same page as muz with the hat color, I am pretty sure that if yours is grey that muz will vote for you. and that is the reason that you are not willing to give up your hat color. I have posted mine without question. what color is yours?
--
Everything in life is mind over matter, if you don't mind it doesn't matter. |
|
 muzscmanMr. PresidentPremium,VIP
join:2002-02-15
Florissant, MO
kudos:3 | I'm still torn here. I could vote navy right now and game over. I could wait and see if gomez will reveal his hat color.
To answer your question Navy, Gomez is so sure because in the beginning dez said there would be one sane witness, one delusional witness and one killer....
I could very well be the delusional witness...all I know is that I am a witness. |
|
navyet2swDamned is in My Room
join:2001-12-09
Virginia Beach, VA | reply to Dezbend
ok, somewhere along the line i missed that part of it.
so current scenario
gomez sane or insane color unknown, saw white.
me killer green saw white.
muz sane or insane. according to you. wearing white, saw gray.
we are playing ring around the rosy right now. the real issue comes if you are wearing a gray hat.
which up to this point you refuse to divulge.
--
Everything in life is mind over matter, if you don't mind it doesn't matter. |
|
muzscmanMr. PresidentPremium,VIP
join:2002-02-15
Florissant, MO
kudos:3 | um dude...do you realize what you just said?? |
|
muzscmanMr. PresidentPremium,VIP
join:2002-02-15
Florissant, MO
kudos:3 | oops...and with that:
Vote: Navyet2sw |
|
|
|
| twilight... |
|
| reply to Dezbend
Navyet2sw, a mafia assassin, has been lynched by the two witnesses. His lies fell on deaf ears as he struggled to convince one of the witnesses that what they saw was inaccurate. Even though only one witness saw navyet2sw, the two gentlemen solved the logical problem and lynched the bad guy.
TOWN wins good job.
--
DSLr Mafia Member. |
|
 SarahPremium,ExMod 2002-05
join:2001-01-09
Cambridge, MA
kudos:5 | reply to muzscman
said by muzscman:um dude...do you realize what you just said?? I LOLed when I saw that posted. 
--
Killers and liars welcome |
|
muzscmanMr. PresidentPremium,VIP
join:2002-02-15
Florissant, MO
kudos:3 | said by Sarah:said by muzscman:um dude...do you realize what you just said?? I LOLed when I saw that posted. I was on the fence to vote for him anyway....gomez made a good sound argument....but that just put me over the edge...
good game dez. it was slow...i really liked this game...i'll be happy to play another if you can get two more to sign up.... |
|
| I may do another, now that we see how it plays, but I am far too busy this weekend to start one up... stay tuned
--
DSLr Mafia Member. |
|
Reviews:
 ·AT&T Yahoo
| Good game guys. Been following this game since it started.
I'm intending to play this one, but I got busy Sunday morning, then sick sunday night through Monday.
This type of game can go on forever, until the mafia slips up with his reasoning.
This particular game went slow, I think, as nobody wants to mess up and say something illogical. Because even if you're innocent, you can accidentally say the wrong things.
Good job guys. |
|
 Rook008Miles To GoPremium
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY | reply to Dezbend
Good game guys. |
|
navyet2swDamned is in My Room
join:2001-12-09
Virginia Beach, VA | reply to Dezbend
yea i saw it, it was supposed to be scenario as gomez had posted. not as I saw it, and anything after that would have only made it worse.
I didn't see the original part about the sane and insane witnesses. which i don't think helped me at all. but it was fun to try to get them to go at each other.
--
Everything in life is mind over matter, if you don't mind it doesn't matter. |
|
GomezExile in waitingPremium,Ex-Mod 06-11
join:2001-02-21
Atlanta, GA | reply to muzscman
said by muzscman:I was on the fence to vote for him anyway....gomez made a good sound argument....but that just put me over the edge... good game dez. it was slow...i really liked this game...i'll be happy to play another if you can get two more to sign up.... Sound? It was bullet proof!
If you went through every possible scenario, there was one outcome.
I think navy must have mis-understood the game. One sane, one delusinal witness, and what they saw is key.. It's not unlike a Dethy game, that it's won by logic more so that argument..
The fatal flaw was Navy's vote. By not hammer Muz, I was completely vidicated, and made that point. Had he not voted, then it would have been a game of wits, 50/50 hinged on Muzes vote.
Only reason this took long was the players seemed to have other obligations.. I can see this being a 30 minute game if everyone is available.
And, my hat was brown. As I said, worthless information in the big picture.
--
It's a fact : Chicks dig Mafia players. |
|
muzscmanMr. PresidentPremium,VIP
join:2002-02-15
Florissant, MO
kudos:3 | reply to Dezbend
next game i doubt i will come out and say what color i saw and what my hat was right away....
--
Come play mafia: »Pub Games :it's fun for the whole internet! |
|
