I know this is picky but.... -

Author	All Replies
MJRudzik join:2002-01-13 Independence, MO	I know this is picky but.... I have no problem with any ISP saying what is and is not allowed on a connection they effectively lease to a customer as long as they state that upfront and don't use a questionable means to do so. In Comcast's case they need to be forthcoming and own this traffic shaping. Even with this admission they are still exposing to the light of day. They also need to stop the particular method by which they are doing it. IMO forging packets is dishonest and should be trated like any other forgery. However simply being sure that a given protocol is throttled to a given percentage of network bandwidth is fine.
MJRudzik join:2002-01-13 Independence, MO	to forum · permalink · 2007-10-22 12:05:17 ·
axus join:2001-06-18 Washington, DC Reviews: ·Verizon Online DSL	You can tell by their methods that this is something they don't want people to know about. It's negligence if they buy this thing and put it on their network not knowing how it works. When people tell them and they deny it, that's just lying. They're hoping people will blame the "unreliable" nature of the internet, when they are the ones contributing to it.
	to forum · permalink · 2007-10-22 13:11:33 ·

Comcast Traffic Shaping Impacts Gnutella, Lotus Notes? > I know this is picky but....