www.broadbandreports.com
  
Search:  

 
   AllHot TopicsCable SupportTelco SupportHardware etcSecurityClubsGallery»»






how-to block ads


 
Forums » The EFF 'Test Your ISP' Project » EFF Protects the Consumer's Interests
 
Search Topic:
  Social:
topic feed
 toggle:
flat / full
normal / watch
Post a:
Post a:
If it's not bittorrent- »
« My ISP does it too...  
AuthorAll Replies


Mashimaro
Problematic

join:2003-09-25
Alexander City, AL
reply to JasonD
Re: EFF Protects the Consumer's Interests

Says the anonymous Comcast employee.


en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA
·DSL EXTREME
·DSL EXTREME


edit:
November 28th, @02:31PM

Yup... I suspect it as well.

CableCo/Telco will raise bandwidth rates IF there's low usage.
Eg. 20Mbps connection isn't an issue if there's low usage.

This works similar to an old fashioned Telco CO, where there's a fixed capacity for lets say 40% at any one time (i.e. 40% of the phones can be calling at the same time).
Typical Internet usage (browsing, video clips,downloads) support this model

Bittorrent is a chatty protocol, and many would see this as excess traffic, or consider it as 'running servers', in a method to deter the usage of p2p/Bittorrent. An old telco equivalent would think of this as having multiple people connecting to a local # and leaving the 2 connections open. Get enough of this, and capacity issues arise.

I don't justify it... if they can't support 20Mbps, then don't offer it. Offering it, then packet shaping / filtering / throttling apps at their discression is not the answer.
Why not do it the old / AOL style:
5Mbps 'Internet' (unrestricted) = $60
20Mbps 'proxied/filtered/restricted Internet want to be' $45

This will solve this issue. Sell the Internet as the what it is. Sell a proxied/ad filled/content pushed/cookie based/data mined AOL wannabe as an alternative.
--
Canada = Hollywood North
Forums » The EFF 'Test Your ISP' ProjectIf it's not bittorrent- »
« My ISP does it too...  

Most commented news this week
· [114] AOL Raises Dial-Up Prices
· [109] Time Warner Cable: Caps 'Make Your Internet Experience Better'
· [103] SMS: You're Paying $1,310 (Or More) Per Megabyte
· [88] July Fourth Open Thread
· [87] Canadian iPhone: Get Less, Pay More
· [83] Obama Addresses FISA Immunity Critics
· [81] How Much Bandwidth Do We Really Need?
· [78] Additional AT&T iPhone Pricing Details
· [75] AT&T, CT Settle Dispute Over 'Lawn Fridges'
· [71] Bono Blames ISPs For Music Industry Decline
Friday, 04-Jul
17:37:26
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
8th year online! © 1999-2008 dslreports.com.
page compression OFF