dslreports logo
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc
Search similar:


uniqs
21736

muzscman
Mr. President
Premium Member
join:2002-02-15
Florissant, MO

muzscman

Premium Member

Re: [game] Ash nazg durbatulûk, ash nazg gimbatul, ash naz

Twilight.

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008 to muzscman

Premium Member

to muzscman
Figures...

Count Zero
Premium Member
join:2007-01-18
Milton, FL

Count Zero to Rook008

Premium Member

to Rook008
just funny to see that mistake, don't know why. Anyways...

Here are my current suspects --
OD - yes he's claiming a minor role which has proven to be pro-fellowship in the past, but it may be a gimmick....

Reds -- just a feeling, probably wrong. sorry

boromir -- a traitor?
Count Zero

Count Zero to Rook008

Premium Member

to Rook008
why the sad face?

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008 to Count Zero

Premium Member

to Count Zero
I'd add TheRul right now too.
Wanted more conversation, bored.
Rook008

Rook008

Premium Member

You going to do this, Muz?

muzscman
Mr. President
Premium Member
join:2002-02-15
Florissant, MO

muzscman

Premium Member

Frodo had made it. He was in Mount Doom and the Cracks of doom were below him. Frodo held out the ring but could not release it. It had a hold over him. He was going to keep it so he could rule them all. As he held the ring in front of his face the unspeakable happened. Gollum appeared from no were to snatch the ring from Frodo's hands...as gollum danced around he did not notice the edge of the cliff. He slips off the edge and down into the burning lava below along with the ring.

With that Sauron was banished from the world and his realm ended.

The End.


Game over.

Older Dog, Sauron, has been killed.
muzscman

muzscman

Premium Member

Town:
Gandalf - Politician - Lurlyn831
You are Gandalf the white. You have come back from the dead and now possess the power to buy the vote of one person.
IM me starting on night 1 with who's vote you would like to buy for day 2.
You are not allowed any private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Frodo - Beloved Ring Bearer - Rook008
You are Frodo, the Beloved Ring Bearer. If you get lynched during any day phase, the next day phase is skipped.
If you get murdered during a night phase, the next day phase is skipped.
You are not allowed any private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Pippin - Mason - Navyet2sw
You are a Mason. Your fellow Mason is Merry(MD_2_Be).
You are allowed private communications with Merry(MD_2_Be).
You win with the Fellowship.

Merry - Mason - MD_2_Be
You are a Mason. Your fellow Mason is Pippin(Navyet2sw).
You are allowed private communications with Pippin(Navyet2sw).
You win with the Fellowship.

Sam - Doc - Robert
You are Sam. You are the Fellowships doctor.
Each night you may choose one person to protect. IM me that choice.
If you choose to protect no one or do not get your choice in on time, you will automatically protect Frodo.
You are not allowed private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Aragorn - Cop - TheRul
You are Aragorn. You make sure anyone that is involved with the Fellowship is a good and decent person.
Each night you may choose one person to investigate. IM me that choice.
You are not allowed private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Gimli - Actor - Jim
You are Gimli. You love to kill with your axe.
Seeing as you love to kill so much, you can only vote as the last vote.
You are not allowed private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Legolas - Priest - Chlen
You are Legolas. You are a lover of peace.
You may only vote if it is not the last vote on someone.
You are not allowed private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Boromir - Role Blocker - Dezbend
You are Boromir, the Fellowships Role Blocker.
Each night you may choose one person to block. IM me that choice.
You are not allowed private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Tom Bombadil - Jack of All Trades - Scotty4168
You Tom Bombadil, Jack of All Trades.
You have 4 things you can choose to do. Each of them one time.
Kill, Investigate, Protect, Block
IM me your choice at night.
You are not allowed private communications.
You win with the Fellowship.

Gollum - Lyncher - BigReds42
Your job is to Lynch Frodo (Rook008). You win if he is lynched. You do not win if he is killed during the night.
After he is lynched, you become a normal townie.
You are not allowed any private communications.
You win when Frodo is lynched.

Mafia:
Sauron - God Father - Older Dog
You are the all seeing, all knowing Sauron.
You are the Leader of everything bad and are trying to kill the fellowship before it can destroy the ring.
You win with the Bad Guys.
You may communicate with your Bad Guys here:

Saruman - Role Blocker - sansri88
You are Saruman the White. You used to be the leader of the Wizards until that nasty Gandalf came and replaced you and drove you out.
Each night you may choose one person to block.
You win with the Bad Guys.
You may communicate with your fellow Bad Guys here:

Wormtongue - Mafia Framer - Sarah
You are Wormtongue. Bad guy extraordinaire!
Each night you may frame one person. If that person is investigated, the person investigating them will show them as guilty.
This role is best played if you can convince the cop to investigate the person you plan on framing.
You win with the Bad Guys.
You may communicate with your fellow Bad Guys here:

TheRul
Why Not You?
Premium Member
join:2007-09-18
Monterey, CA

TheRul to muzscman

Premium Member

to muzscman
WhooHoo, Now I rule you all as the true and Just KING!!! MWAA HAA HAA.
Don't worry rook there are some more games coming up.

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008

Premium Member

Yeah, that game seemed to go by kind of quick at the end there. I wanted to see if Dezbend would get killed

Count Zero
Premium Member
join:2007-01-18
Milton, FL

Count Zero

Premium Member

LOL. GG all! Hope everyone enjoyed playing.

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008

Premium Member

Good game Muz. Thanks for running the show.

Sarah

join:2001-01-09
New York, NY

Sarah to Count Zero

to Count Zero
said by Count Zero:

LOL. GG all! Hope everyone enjoyed playing.
It's not really fun when you're on the losing side of a breaking strategy. I thought that was clear by now

1. Mass roleclaim
2. Investigate/lynch all non-fellowship members
3. Town wins 100% of the time

Congrats on not figuring out a way to lose a fixed game...

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008 to muzscman

Premium Member

to muzscman
Anyone remember a game where the Mafia Framer was successful? I can't remember one. That would be fun to see.
Rook008

Rook008 to Sarah

Premium Member

to Sarah
I wouldn't call it fixed. You guys could have challenged a Claim and then fought it out. And later on jumped on anyone that believed the false claim. Or Claimed a lesser Character. At the very least it would have given the Mafia a better chance of making people distrust the Claims.
older dog
Premium Member
join:2005-06-09

older dog to Sarah

Premium Member

to Sarah
I do thank Muzz as always for running an interesting game.

But I do agree with Sarah, we may not have responded as well as possible, but all the major characters were good guys with few names which would not draw suspicion left.

Once the role claims started we new we were screwed, I guess we were the Ginny pigs this time.

BigReds42
Premium Member
join:2004-07-14
Bellaire, OH

BigReds42

Premium Member

Thanks muz for the game... like I said... I was REALLY hoping fdor th game to last longer as I was looking forward to it alot... not your fault... but as I argued... the mass nameclaim screwed EVERYTHING up.

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008 to older dog

Premium Member

to older dog
I guess you could see it that way. But look at my "Probable Town" list:

Rook008
Navyet2sw
MD_2_Be

I was sure about the first one.

BigReds42
Premium Member
join:2004-07-14
Bellaire, OH

BigReds42 to Rook008

Premium Member

to Rook008
said by Rook008:

I wouldn't call it fixed. You guys could have challenged a Claim and then fought it out. And later on jumped on anyone that believed the false claim. Or Claimed a lesser Character. At the very least it would have given the Mafia a better chance of making people distrust the Claims.
I agree with ya Rook... but with a cop AND a JOAT.... they were pretty much screwed as soon as the names started rolling out.

Sarah

join:2001-01-09
New York, NY

1 recommendation

Sarah to Rook008

to Rook008
said by Rook008:

I wouldn't call it fixed. You guys could have challenged a Claim and then fought it out. And later on jumped on anyone that believed the false claim. Or Claimed a lesser Character. At the very least it would have given the Mafia a better chance of making people distrust the Claims.
There was no way for us to know which roles were going to be claimed until after all the townies had claimed theirs, and by then it was "hey, why aren't those three claiming?" and all three of us drew investigations in the first two nights.

Sure, I could claim Legolas; then chlen would dispute it and that guarantees my death (either you lynch me first, or you lynch him first and find out he was telling the truth, and then lynch me). With 3 mafia to 11 town there was no room for that kind of error. There was no way for us to know which roles were safe to claim until the very end, and a mistake was certain death.

I mean, if you didn't pick up on it, fine, but there was absolutely a 100% breaking strategy in this game.

chlen
Ethically Challenged
Premium Member
join:2001-01-16
Saratoga, NY

chlen to muzscman

Premium Member

to muzscman
wow, good game. A little hard to follow since it has been since freshman year of college that I read the book and have only seen the first movie, but good game none the less.

I thought it was a good combination of role claiming and strategy that led to the win.

Muz as always thank you...

I was busy as hell this week so i was not able to put anyone on the hot seat, but dez took care of that for me, thanks.

good game everyone.

Dezbend
MVM
join:2001-04-20

Dezbend to muzscman

MVM

to muzscman
muzscman, thank you for modding. I learned allot from a moderators point of view as well as having fun as a player.

chlen
Ethically Challenged
Premium Member
join:2001-01-16
Saratoga, NY

chlen to Sarah

Premium Member

to Sarah
I claimed as simple strategy. In retrospect with my limited ability I should have gotten the mafia to target me (Legolas could have been almost any role). I claimed to clear up and narrow down the field after the cop was outed and the doc was killed. I thought it was the proper thing to do.
older dog
Premium Member
join:2005-06-09

older dog to Rook008

Premium Member

to Rook008
I thought my not killing Dez was a way to argue against being mafia, but never got the chance, should have just killed him.

He voted me every turn.

Just for the record the role claims narrowed the list enough for us to make a valid guess on who was the doc

Dezbend
MVM
join:2001-04-20

Dezbend to chlen

MVM

to chlen
I blocked:

BigReds42
Older Dog
and Jim

was there only three nights?

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008

Premium Member

Yeah.
Rook008

Rook008 to older dog

Premium Member

to older dog
It's always a good idea to kill Dez if you have the chance
Then you could just say "I'm being framed!!"

Dezbend
MVM
join:2001-04-20

Dezbend

MVM

said by Rook008:

It's always a good idea to kill Dez if you have the chance
Then you could just say "I'm being framed!!"
LOL, I don't think the I'm being framed ploy ever worked for me... but it is a fun gambit!

Rook008
Miles To Go
Premium Member
join:2002-02-05
Far Rockaway, NY

Rook008

Premium Member

I don't think I've seen it work either. It would probably be fun to see it played out though.

Sarah

join:2001-01-09
New York, NY

Sarah to Dezbend

to Dezbend
I'm not sure what it says about your game play this time around, but I was so sure you were the traitor this game, Dez...