Mark F
join:2007-08-01
Fort Wayne, IN
| reply to harley3k
Re: Yet another HD complaint thread
Like many others, I love TV, and there are plenty of HD shows I enjoy watching, such as- Cold Case, CSI Miami, NCIS, Criminal Minds, Heroes, CSI NY, Boston Legal, Lost, Shark, CSI, Without A Trace, ER, Ghost Whisperer, Moonlight, Mumb3rs, Jericho, The Unit, L&O, Jay Leno. I'm glad we have a DVR, but I wish I could record (or even watch) Stargate Atlantis and Battlestar Galactica in HD. I also like the Colts and I'm looking forward to the debut of the Lucas Oil Stadium on NBC's Sunday Night Football season premier.
But, I just got through watching a season 3 episode of Hawaii Five-0 on DVD. And now, Burke's Law is on TV. And, later I may watch some classic TV over the internet, from MSN TV, HULU, AOL, CBS, etc. So, being a big TV fan, I'm all for Verizon adding the HD and SD channels we've requested.
Yes, I understand that when some people get an HD set, they very seldom watch anything that's not HD, not even SD-only programs that they previously loved to watch.
That's why I'm glad there's something for everyone who enjoys TV, no matter how they enjoy it. Mark F. |
|
harley3k
join:2007-04-10
Flower Mound, TX
| reply to Smiles
It is pointless to say that most channels will not have 24/7 HD content, because no one ever watches one channel all the time.
The point is that if the flagship shows you watch are in HD, then that 1 or 2 hours per week that you actually watch that channel is all that matters. |
|
Smiles
join:2004-07-14
Sudbury, MA
| reply to FrackHD
CNBC HD is not irrelevant, unless you don't watch it in the first place. They use the extra real estate to pack more financial information on the screen. Definitely one of the top five channels I'm looking for.
»www.cnbc.com/id/20996011/ |
|
Ph8te
join:2004-08-24
Providence, RI
1 edit | reply to Mark F
I have to agree with you about the Golf, once you watch it in HD you wont want to watch it in SD again. The difference is almost sickening......
As far as HD programming goes, the providers are adding more and more all the time. If the content isnt available then they cant show it......Even the dreaded TBS has started to show their Prime Time shows in HD (Office, ELR, even The Family Guy looks better).......Its happening slowly, but more and more HD content will be available and will begin to filter down so that it is shown more often....For me the more HD the better... |
|
Mark F
join:2007-08-01
Fort Wayne, IN
| reply to wmcbrine
Ok, you have a point, besides an up-converting DVD player could make SD shows look better. And, maybe an HD transfer would be almost (but not quite) like "magically turning SD into HD". Which would be nice, as there are a good many shows- such as Get Smart, Mannix, Rockford Files, Space 1999, Hill Street Blues, etc.- that I'd love to see shown with near HD quality (or as close as possible).
But, I was mostly echoing what Baff said about there being a lot of SD programming out there. And, as long as people enjoy such shows, I think there always will be.
As for golf being "fast paced", I was referring to a small while ball sailing through the air, which might be easier to follow in HD.
Anyway, since I love watching HD (but not only HD), I'm for more HD, coexisting with SD, so everyone has a choice. Mark F. |
|
jchuan83388
join:2003-08-30
Camarillo, CA
| reply to matcarl
said by matcarl  :Thanks Savvy, too bad they are counting a PPV Event channel among them. I am glad that they will have HD PPV Events. As a boxing fan coming from DirecTV a couple of years back, it's been hard watching the fights in SD. I am sure that there are a bunch of MMA and even WWE fans that are looking forward to watching PPV events in HD!  |
|
wmcbrine
Touched by His Noodly Appendage
join:2002-12-30
Laurel, MD
| reply to Mark F
I'd agree with the point, but that's a bad example. That show was shot on film, surely? Which means they can do an HD transfer at some point.
--
09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0 |
|
srickard
join:2003-12-02
Sachse, TX
1 edit | reply to Mark F
"But, many people on here are into very fast paced action (more than the average viewer is), which they would like to watch in HD- hockey, tennis, golf, etc- which may be easier to follow in HD."
Golf is fast paced action??  |
|
Mark F
join:2007-08-01
Fort Wayne, IN
| reply to Hajman
If one person wants a channel for just one show, then another person wants a different channel for just one show, on and on, that makes little sense. It seems that if you took all these shows and put them all on one channel, you'd have plenty of time leftover. But, maybe the purpose of having channels with just a couple of "must watch" shows, is to keep those channels alive and people tuning in untill more HD programming is available.
But, as Baff said, many channels will never be SD. And, one of the reasons we have FIOS is that they offer channels that Comcast doesn't, many with lots of SD- Boomerang is one that comes to mind. Having an HD set hasn't made me forsake some of my favorite SD shows. According to the TV Shows On DVD website, older shows on DVD are quite popular, as well.
But, many people on here are into very fast paced action (more than the average viewer is), which they would like to watch in HD- hockey, tennis, golf, etc- which may be easier to follow in HD.
So, the more HD the merrier. But, as Baff said, you can't magically turn SD into HD. And there are a lot of shows in SD that will always be popular (see link). Hopefully there's room for all popular shows, no matter when they were made. Mark F.
»www.tvshowsondvd.net/graphics/ne···inal.jpg |
|
Hajman
join:2001-12-17
Phoenixville, PA
| reply to Hound
said by Hound :Most HD cable channels are built around one HD program. People generally want an HD channel to watch one program. Maybe you are right but I can't say that I agree with your assertion. If you are right, I guess I think that business model (building an entire channel around one HD program) and mind set (wanting an HD channel for one program) is odd and not sustainable. |
|
Hound
join:2006-03-08
Princeton, NJ
| reply to Hajman
Most HD cable channels are built around one HD program.
People generally want an HD channel to watch one program.
We will take TBS for an example. A lot of people only want
TBS for baseball playoffs and Sunday afternoon baseball.
A lot of people only want Sci Fi for Battlestar Galactica.
Other people want USA for wrestling or Versus for ice hockey. They do not care if the rest of the programming is stretch o vision. If you have time to watch the stretch o vision or talk about it, you have too much time on your hands.
I have Directv and Dish Network as well as Fios, so I already have all these channels. And I only watch the HD programming that I want to watch. I did not miss the baseball playoffs in HD last year or the hockey season in HD on Versus or MLB EI in HD.
It is exciting to get the HD. I understand why folks are
frustrated. I could not wait. |
|
Hajman
join:2001-12-17
Phoenixville, PA
| reply to afiggatt
Thanks for the corrections - I thought there would be some. However, I think you just backed up my point. Of all the channels slated to be added, very few (maybe 3/4 - USA, Sci-Fi, Versus/Golf and mahybe TBS) are in the "I need to have it in HD now and if I don't I'm going to be mad" category. |
|
afiggatt
join:2007-07-12
Sterling, VA
| reply to Hajman
said by Hajman :HD Irrelevant: ESPNews, CNN, Weather Channel, CNBC Filled with Stretch-O-Vision: Animal Planet, TBS, The History Channel, The Learning Channel, USA, Lifetime, Bravo, SCI FI Extra subscription channels for which a HD channel already exists: Showtime West, Cinemax West, HBO West Channels I know nothing about: MOJO, The Science Channel, Starz Edge, Starz Comed, Starz Kids and Family, Outdoor Channel, Smithsonian Perhaps some of my classifications are wrong, but beyond Versus / Golf, baseball playoffs on TBS and very little original programming on Sci Fi (like BSG - that I don't watch) and other channels, I don't get why people are so amped about adding HD channels NOW. You are more than a little off-base here. USA-HD, Sci-Fi HD are not stretch-o-vision channels. Both of them have gotten praise for a fair amount of true HD. TBS-HD started showing some real HD programming other than baseball at the beginning of April; however it is a stretch-o-vision channel.
CNN-HD - all the studio programming out of New York is in HD which would nice for watching the primary returns tonight. CNN specials have been in HD. Weather Channel is starting up their new all HD studio at the beginning of June - just in time for hurricane season but just a coincidence I'm sure  .
Smithsonian is all HD. Very repetitive, but it is HD. Mojo is all HD; used to be InHD1.
yes, not everything on the missing HD channels will be HD. But a lot of the new programs people want to watch will be. People are getting frustrated because their local cable company has added some of the more useful HD channels, but nothing so far from Verizon. So rumor, speculation, and unsubstantiated posts rule the day. |
|
Baff
join:2007-12-05
Murrieta, CA
 ·Verizon FIOS
1 edit | reply to Hajman
Hajman, I am most interested in Sci-Fi, USA and Bravo. Sci-Fi channel does not stretch, though they do show some SD content. Sci-Fi is currently airing the final season of Battlestar Galactica which is definitely in HD. I'm sure some of the other shows I watch are in HD too.
I don't know about the stretching habits of USA or Bravo, but if even 1 of the shows I watch on those channels are in non-stretched HD, then I want those HD channels as soon as possible. Seems pretty simple to me. It's not like waiting is going to make any of these channels become 100% non-stretched HD faster. In fact, many channels will never be 100% HD. They can't magically make shows that were filmed in SD become HD. |
|
darcilicious
Cyber Librarian
Premium
join:2001-01-02
Forest Grove, OR
·Verizon FIOS
| reply to Hajman
Original programming on USA/SciFi that I think is available in HD or in 16:9 aspect ratio / widescreen at least: Monk, Eureka, Psych, BSG (I do watch it), Burn Notice (I think), Star Trek: Enterprise, Stargate Atlantis, L&O: CI, In Plain Sight (I'm assuming) and more that I can't think of at the moment.
And of course, that list will grow over time. I'd rather get the HD channels now and watch that list than be on the sidelines any longer for the above shows. |
|
Hajman
join:2001-12-17
Phoenixville, PA | reply to jankm
But ESPNews is just highlights and super annoying talking heads speaking ESPNonics. For me at least, I'll rarely watch it and don't really care if it is HD. |
|
jankm
join:2005-08-16
Lansdale, PA | reply to Hajman
ESPNews HD is on ESPN2HD in the mornings and its excellent. The picture is always HD because they have set up the on-screen graphics that way. Most highlights are now HD so ESPNews is in HD almost all the time. |
|
Hajman
join:2001-12-17
Phoenixville, PA
| reply to FrackHD
Question for all the posters to this thread - why the clamor for adding all the HD channels ASAP? Won't a ton of the content on the HD channels to be added still be in SD or stretch 'o vision.
Here is how I see it:
HD Irrelevant: ESPNews, CNN, Weather Channel, CNBC
Filled with Stretch-O-Vision: Animal Planet, TBS, The History Channel, The Learning Channel, USA, Lifetime, Bravo, SCI FI
Extra subscription channels for which a HD channel already exists: Showtime West, Cinemax West, HBO West
Sports: Big Ten Network, Versus / Golf
Channels I know nothing about: MOJO, The Science Channel, Starz Edge, Starz Comed, Starz Kids and Family, Outdoor Channel, Smithsonian
Perhaps some of my classifications are wrong, but beyond Versus / Golf, baseball playoffs on TBS and very little original programming on Sci Fi (like BSG - that I don't watch) and other channels, I don't get why people are so amped about adding HD channels NOW. |
|
Baff
join:2007-12-05
Murrieta, CA
1 edit | reply to FrackHD
The only HD channel I care about that isn't on the list is BBC America HD. They have been advertising that it is going to launch soon, but they haven't given a date yet (as far as I know). |
|
matcarl
join:2007-03-09
Franklin Square, NY | reply to Max1
Starz Kids & Family |
|
