Search:  

 
 
   All ForumsHot TopicsGallery






how-to block ads


 
Forums » Tech and Talk » OS and Software » All Things Unix » Is it time to give ATI another look?
Search Topic:
Share Topic:
RSS topic:
toggle:
flat / full
normal / watch
Posting:
Post a:
Post a:
RHEL Upgrade »
« OpenOffice Base + Oracle  
AuthorAll Replies


Joe Blow

@cableone.net

reply to alamarco
Re: Is it time to give ATI another look?

said by alamarco See Profile :

said by Joe Blow :

said by alamarco See Profile :

My experience with older cards and the ATi fglrx have been good. Currently with my laptop and the Radeon Xpress 200M the drivers install painlessly and most options work in xorg.conf.

From the comments here, it seems the drivers are problematic with newer cards.
I have a HP Pavilion with a Turion and the 200M card. It's been very problematic. I tried for several iterations of ATI's drivers to try to get them to work and I'd get a black screen and the cpu would go into a race condition. It would lock up the system and overheat the cpu within a minute or so if I didn't hit the power button. Even after they finally--it took them more than a year--got that problem fixed installing the drivers meant I couldn't get to a console. It took ATI more than two years to get their drivers to work from the time I first tried them. Once they at least worked they still consume approximately 3 times the cpu resources the open source drivers do when playing a video.

I've had the laptop 3 years and been playing with the drivers for that entire amount time and I still can't say ATI's drivers for the 200M are worth anything. They are more of a resource hog and won't work with Compiz. I just don't see how that's acceptable performance from a driver.
They do work with Compiz. When I tried Ubuntu they worked perfectly fine with no lag what so ever. The latest drivers even support AIGX (spelling) so there is no need for XGL (unless I'm mistaken).

The black screen bug had a solution, so even though ATi didn't fix it promptly I don't call this an important bug. Right now the drivers work near 100% for the Radeon Xpress 200M. The only problem, that which you have mentioned, is with going back to the console. It doesn't crash, as you can still type to startx again, but you can't see anything. If you use a login manager such as KDM or GDM it isn't even an issue as they will restart X themselves.
The 200M only works in some hardware configurations with Compiz. It does not work in mine. I've spent days researching and implementing every fix I could find and I've never gotten it to work.

It's like the BCM43xx module. My laptop has the 4318 Broadcom wireless chip and do you think I can use the open source module? Not a chance. It crashes my wireless router, it gets even worse reception than the card does using ndiswrapper, and I can't use any kind of security with it.

Hmmmm.... The black screen bug would overheat the cpu and my laptop would shut down the overheat sensors, it made my laptop completely unusable, and it took ATI well over a year to fix it. And you call that an unimportant bug? I'd hate to see your idea of an important bug. If an overheat sensor would have failed it would have turned my laptop into a boat anchor. I call that a pretty major bug.
Forums » Tech and Talk » OS and Software » All Things UnixRHEL Upgrade »
« OpenOffice Base + Oracle  


Thursday, 04-Dec 17:55:02 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 9 years online! © 1999-2008 dslreports.com.
page compression OFF
Most commented news this week
· [125] AT&T Metered Billing Trial Hits Second Market
· [96] UDP BitTorrent Will Destroy The Interwebs!
· [94] Exclusive Screens Of Comcast's New Bandwidth Meter
· [90] EFF Challenges Telecom Immunity
· [79] Firefox Extension Leads Amazon Customers To Pirated Alternatives
· [76] AT&T Cutting 12,000 Jobs
· [63] Apple: Who Believes Our Ads Anyway?
· [62] Comcast Tries To Slow Verizon's Philly Entry
· [60] Comcast To Offer Bandwidth Use Tracker In January
· [53] T-Mobile Invisible Caps Return
Most people now reading
· Adventures in Bell... a Teksavvy production... [TekSavvy]
· NO Access to sportsline.com on Fios, but on cable works fine.. [Verizon Fiber Optics]
· Coalition Government Possible? [TekSavvy]
· Level 80 PVP gear info? [World of Warcraft]
· Internet Video Trial Sign Up [Verizon FIOS TV]
· Whats wrong here? [Automotive]
· [Rant] People bitching about Best Buy [Rants, Raves, & Praise]
· Garage Door Track Pulled Off Wall? [Home Repair & Improvement]
· [WotLK] WotLK Instance Order? [World of Warcraft]
· Trash pickup / single day dumpster rental [Home Repair & Improvement]