site Search:


 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery






how-to block ads


 
Search Topic:
Uniqs:
794
Share Topic
Post a:
Post a:
AuthorAll Replies


Matt
All noise, no signal.
Premium
join:2003-07-20
Jamestown, NC
kudos:12

1 edit

Definition of HD?

What is their definition of HD? That iTunes/Xbox 360 crap isn't even high quality 720p, with an average HD rental being between 3-6GB in total size.

One movie and you're done. Just wait until real HD streaming comes along or god forbid, 1080p content.

fiberguy
My views are my own.
Premium
join:2005-05-20
kudos:3

God forbid people actually get video over a video service and stop throwing everything at the internet.

And sure, if you DO want to get 1080p content over the internet, then you ARE using a lot of service... pay for it.

The all you can eat buffet mentality has to come to and end. You can't expect to purchase a residential line at a low price and then stuff everything possible through it.

250 gb caps, while I think they suck ESPECIALLY knowing why those caps are coming in (abusive consumers) those who cry because it's not enough to feed their personal needs is no excuse as to why more should be given.

If you want 1080p movies over the internet, then be prepared to pay for it. It's not the ISP's problem that people want to download movies over it. Maybe there is something to be said about movie rentals or purchases after all.

I'm sorry, we just disagree.



Rally
Bah Humbug
Premium
join:2000-10-27
Astoria, NY
Reviews:
·RoadRunner Cable

I'll this again and again. Stop signing up new customers, if the 'network' or 'last mile' cannot handle the traffic. For years, all the Cable CO's had due time to plan out, and upgrade all their plants. The problem was, they over-sold their own limits of their network, so we have this 'crunch' now.

So whats the cheapest way to fix this 'problem'? Cap the service, or actually put money into upgrades of plants?



pspcrazy
Anime Freak

join:2008-02-06
San Diego, CA

reply to fiberguy
Haha man your funny it seems to me like we've got another person here who works for a cable co stating junk again. Look bro no one else would say something as dumb as get stop getting content off the web, instead get it from a video service. The web is replacing all those services because it's more efficient. We are already paying for the video, why should we also pay for the connection which we already paid for?

Oh wait that's right, that's because were not getting ripped off ENOUGH yet, i mean come on 500 users per node being sold 15/2 connections with the node capacity of 38/27. Do you understand just HOW bad these overselling's are? Caps are not the solution. Even with cap's if 3 people download at max speed the node is saturated! Now that is the real problem.



BF69
Premium
join:2004-07-28
Camden, TN

reply to Matt

said by Matt:

What is their definition of HD? That iTunes/Xbox 360 crap isn't even high quality 720p, with an average HD rental being between 3-6GB in total size.

One movie and you're done. Just wait until real HD streaming comes along or god forbid, 1080p content.
Listen blu-ray streams at 40 Mbps. So HD movies streaming at blu-ray bitrates are impossible now and will be for a long time. And to be honest, are probably unnecessary. Even if you had a 40 Mbps connection name me any website that actually stream content or data that fast?


Matt
All noise, no signal.
Premium
join:2003-07-20
Jamestown, NC
kudos:12

said by BF69:

said by Matt:

What is their definition of HD? That iTunes/Xbox 360 crap isn't even high quality 720p, with an average HD rental being between 3-6GB in total size.

One movie and you're done. Just wait until real HD streaming comes along or god forbid, 1080p content.
Listen blu-ray streams at 40 Mbps. So HD movies streaming at blu-ray bitrates are impossible now and will be for a long time. And to be honest, are probably unnecessary. Even if you had a 40 Mbps connection name me any website that actually stream content or data that fast?
I meant the total download size, not streaming.

fiberguy
My views are my own.
Premium
join:2005-05-20
kudos:3

reply to pspcrazy
NO, little boy.. it's called the real world - none of what the newest generation understands.
All this "junk" as you call it is economics. I laid out very well why ISPs have to moderate traffic.

People with educations will tell you that all this "junk" is not infinite. There are real costs associated to it.. there are economics behind it that have to come to play, and there are people, like you, who sit back and bitch about paying the actual costs for the service in order to get this content off the internet.

I bet history was NOT your best subject. History will tell you that Rome was not built in a day. The internet as large as this is was also not built in a day. It's easy to arm chair quarterback and say "plan for it".. well, again, you CLEARLY do not understand what it takes to run a system of ANY size.

So really, before you come here with your snide smart ass attitude and your obvious adolescent ramblings, I mean "come one man"... I bet you were one that stomped your feet and threw a tantrum with your mom and dad when ever you didn't get your way.

You also clearly don't know ANYTHING about networking so please don't pretend an try to insult my intelligence while trying to educate me or anyone else about how networks work. I'll give you a VERY simple education - get your head out of the node.. it's not all about the node.

I think you'd get someone here that has more time or patience to give you the information you seek but it's been said here so many times, and no one cares to hear reality that most of us with the real answers don't care. People like you hear what you want to hear and believe what you want to believe... and those that have answers that you don't like "must work for the cable co's... "bro"..

If you upped all cable companies to even what Verizon is doing or even better, what Surewest HAS been doing for years already, you'd STILL have bandwidth issues.

The problem is that people like you sit back and think that networks are built over night and that if someone can think it up and throw it on the internet, that by tomorrow it should be able to handle it.

I'd love to see how your theory of not over selling nodes would work the day YOU called up and wanted service and were told "no - you can't have it.. your node is over sold" you'd be right back here whining like a baby that they need to grow their network as the answer. And, if I recall, Verizon has that very issue with DSL.



pspcrazy
Anime Freak

join:2008-02-06
San Diego, CA

Not at all when a node is oversold it's as simple as either a> build a new node so that more user's can get on or b>Get out so someone could replace you like FIOS for instance.

You seem to like odd and often false analogies. No one here is saying that the cable backbone is built in a day, but it's been many many years now and cable is still lagging behind what it could have been if it hadn't been sitting on it's butt soaking in profit's like nothing else.

You are trying to understand why people on here debate against caps? Well I'll tell you why it's because the cable companies listen when people start having the same belief that cable is becoming crap, and it's time to move onto something else. For them the customer is money, and when that money leaves their potential net revenue's you can bet they'll drop caps and figure out a better solution.

If they are having capacity issues scale down the max speed on each person's modem and don't oversell the node to that extend. DSL is going just fine with 0 capacity problems, yet cable which is supposedly better has had capacity problems for years on end.

It seems to me that your the arrogant one that needs to go to college, I'm sorry to say this but anyone that insults someone that many times in a sentence is just some child which doesn't have a proper come back.



BF69
Premium
join:2004-07-28
Camden, TN

reply to Matt

said by Matt:

said by BF69:

said by Matt:

What is their definition of HD? That iTunes/Xbox 360 crap isn't even high quality 720p, with an average HD rental being between 3-6GB in total size.

One movie and you're done. Just wait until real HD streaming comes along or god forbid, 1080p content.
Listen blu-ray streams at 40 Mbps. So HD movies streaming at blu-ray bitrates are impossible now and will be for a long time. And to be honest, are probably unnecessary. Even if you had a 40 Mbps connection name me any website that actually stream content or data that fast?
I meant the total download size, not streaming.
We the reason why blu-ray movies are 50 GB is because of the high bitrate. The HD movies from XBL and Itunes are only 4-6 Mbps. Hell even DVDs have a bitrate of 8 Mbps. So if you see HD doloads in the 50 Gb range it's because not only they are 1080p they also have a much higher bitrate. If they just made HD downloads 1080p and kept the same 4-6 Mbps bite rate they'd only be 10-12GB.

People want INSTANT media and sorry even at 1 Gbps a 50 GB HD movie would take 7 minutes to download. Not very instant in my book. So yes STREAMING is important because people don't want to have to wait to see their media. They want it to work like TV, turn it on and it's on.

fiberguy
My views are my own.
Premium
join:2005-05-20
kudos:3

1 edit

reply to pspcrazy

said by pspcrazy:

Not at all when a node is oversold it's as simple as either a> build a new node so that more user's can get on or b>Get out so someone could replace you like FIOS for instance.


No one has to "get out of the way"... they just have to build. Tell me, why haven't they? And, before you bow and wear Verizon on your shoulders, look good into their history and then ask why they didn't build fiber to the home almost a decade ago. It's clear you do not keep up with the real world, rather, you spend your time thinking about you and only you.

You seem to like odd and often false analogies. No one here is saying that the cable backbone is built in a day,
Yes they are. Are you blind? People come here daily asking why their internet isn't going from 1.5 to 1 gig right now. Not everything has to be spoken in black and white.. actions speak loudly. Oh wait.. there's one of those odd and false analogies huh? Seriously..

...but it's been many many years now and cable is still lagging behind what it could have been if it hadn't been sitting on it's butt soaking in profit's like nothing else.
And just how long does it take to build a system? You think it's just about going out to your local best buy and getting the parts to build these little nation wide networks? Do you understand economics at all? or.. is all of this just "odd" and "false" realities to you.

You are trying to understand why people on here debate against caps?
No, I'm not, actually. I know why they are. The very people that sit back and call the ISP "greedy" themselves are greedy and can't see it. People EXPECT things they shouldn't and often! You can't expect that a $20 to $40 internet connection is going to be the answer to give them all they want, more of it tomorrow, and for the smallest amount of money. This "internet" that people hold so dearly, want to turn into a utility because it's so important, is one of the LAST things they chose to pay the real money for. In case you don't know, the newer generations are lazy, en titlists, and need a much better education in how things work. I'd bet that the majority of this new generation, here, has never done a real hard days work.. would never thing of joining the military.. or any of those things that people like I, and others, have done in their life. ... but go on...

Well I'll tell you why it's because the cable companies listen when people start having the same belief that cable is becoming crap, and it's time to move onto something else.
You mean what so many people have said about the horrible phone companies for so many years? Seriously, how old are you? You are so selfish, greedy, and entitled, you're so blind.. you have NO idea what you're even talking about. You think Verizon's FiOS is perfect, too, don't you? Fiber or not, the only thing that give it it's foot up is the internet portion of the service. The rest is no different than cable offers now. Cable has been what has pushed phone to where it is, in case you hadn't noticed.. again, go on...

For them the customer is money, and when that money leaves their potential net revenue's you can bet they'll drop caps and figure out a better solution.
I feel sorry for you and what is to come in your life. You are up for some SERIOUS disappointments.

If they are having capacity issues scale down the max speed on each person's modem and don't oversell the node to that extend.
Are you serious? If they scaled back the service, you'd cry it wasn't fast enough. There has never been any surprise that cable is a shared medium, the same as Fiber is. Don't think for a moment that FiOS will be managed soon, too. Again, you clearly have no idea about running a business. You think everything is always about the consumer's best wishes. There are realities. I would NEVER expect a cable company to have, from where they came from, micro build a node down to the point of what you want which is dedicated bandwidth. There is no need to build a network to the point of guaranteed bandwidth, which is a business model. I will counter you, if people would follow their AUP/TOS agreement and not run servers wide open 24/7, then these issues wouldn't be there. Your argument of that they should build a network so people can abuse it is absurd. All I read in your message is "entitled".. and you are NOT entitled. You don't want to honor your agreement, so why should they? However, they are... they managed their network as they agreed they would, and people like you, whine.

What you also fail to know is they DO split nodes all the time. However, you can't split a node fast enough sometimes when someone else starts to abuse the network by running servers, P2P / torrents.. etc.

DSL is going just fine with 0 capacity problems, yet cable which is supposedly better has had capacity problems for years on end.
Really? Ask Verizon why they have to reject orders for new customers. Take your DSL colored glasses off for a moment and stop drinking your Kewl-ade. Please visit the DSL forums and read a little would ya?

It's totally clear you have no idea what you're talking about as it's all emotion based. You haven't brought any facts to the table, just a bunch of claims and wants. Respond all you want, but I won't reply if its based on emotion. It's not worth the time.

It seems to me that your the arrogant one that needs to go to college, I'm sorry to say this but anyone that insults someone that many times in a sentence is just some child which doesn't have a proper come back.
I've been to college, thanks. I've been to war, I run two successful businesses, and I own a couple homes. I think I've done well. However, you forgot to see where you, like so many do, have already insulted me. Don't like it when the favor is returned, do you? You can sit there and say I have no proper come back, however, I'd detailed and stated my side in return many times as I often do. You are just upset that my side doesn't fit your needs.

One can't come here and toss out a rant with no basis or facts to back it up and not expect someone to come along and challenge you on it. Wait.. you did, didn't you, with your "they need to build a new node" which they do every day, and the "cable just needs to get out of the way" argument. You should be so proud; it changed my whole view.

Wednesday, 30-May 09:23:26 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.
Most commented news this week
Hot Topics