Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
 ·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
| From the ground up!
 .GIF/thumb.jpg "18536 bytes")
VelCom - Thomson ST546v6, FW v7.4.3.2 (Limoilou, 2008-Jul-8) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "18463 bytes")
VelCom - GNet GBB2060-Xi (Limoilou, 2008-Jul-8) |
I'll cease updating my "Tweaks" thread next week
after moving to Quebec city (Limoilou), the phone
line conditions will change and this means that
future MoDem comparisons will need to be based on
new grounds as a consequence. Further confusion
can be avoided, hopefully, by launching a separate
thread where my future findings can be posted so
here it is: those are my very 1st static numbers
and they're so fresh i can't actually join speed/
latency tests because PPoE authentification works
but there's no real connectivity yet... Perhaps
i must explain... Well, VelCom was very kind to
me as they agreed to activate the DSLAM a few days
before i'm finished moving to my new appartment!
In other words, the DSLAM card is ready and VelCom
is able to access Bell's Line-Test portal for that
phone line but my DSL access still isn't providing
browsing capability - and that's totally normal or
i'd have to pay for two DSL accounts, obviously...
Honestly, i value this level of cooperation shown
by the VelCom guys as their solution garantees my
access is ready (and maybe even optimized) by the
time i'm done moving (e.g. no delays whatsoever)!
Warm salutations to Matthew and his co-workers!!!
 |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "18856 bytes")
VelCom - Bell's Portal (GNet GBB2060-Xi, 2008-Jul-16) | %20-%20Test%20Results%20.GIF "37817 bytes")
Moved to Limoilou (Quebec City) - Speed Test Results | |  - More Details .GIF/thumb.jpg "32389 bytes")
Moved to Limoilou (Quebec City) - More Details |
The transition is over: i'm now residing in Limoilou.
Consequently, i'll post my last Louiseville figures in
the next day or so (i didn't have time to sort it out),
in the appropriate old thread, of course...
N.B.:
All connections presently done via HPNA due to wiring constraints... |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
edit:
July 21st, @11:48PM
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "6472 bytes")
VelCom - GNet GBB2060-Xi Noise Curve (Limoilou) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "19040 bytes")
VelCom - Bell's Portal (GNet GBB2060-Xi, 2008-Jul-21 12h09) |
I decided to replace the D-Link HPNA modules with plain
old CAT-5 NetWork cabling for a while, it blows off the
esthetics but the whole appartment is a mess anyway...
The connection to my demarcation point isn't optimized
neither: i presently use thirty feet of twisted pairs and
then i split the signal between voice and DSL with a pair
of filters (i put no RF chokes on those). Light RF choking
is implemented on the WAN input, contrary to PSU leads
which are submitted to a generous amount of it.
There's been no cooking done here yet so it's no surprize
for me not to see any sign of a "cooking hour syndrome"
so far.
I forgot to mention that the static numbers are quite a bit stable...
Attenuation: 46.5 dB/26 dB
SNR Margins: 17 to 18.5 dB/10 dB
Power Levels: 18 dBm/11.9 dBm |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
edit:
July 22nd, @04:43PM
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "51360 bytes")
VelCom - DMT Part-1 (2008-Jul-21) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "51349 bytes")
VelCom - DMT Part-2 (2008-Jul-21) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "19017 bytes")
VelCom - Bell's Portal (Thomson ST546v6, 2008-Jul-22 0h07) | 
Distance between VelCom and my location | | %20.GIF "37426 bytes")
VelCom - Test Results (ST546v6/FW v7.4.3.2, 2008-Jul-22) | |
FirmWare v7.4.3.2) and there's also a map, for future reference...
Addendum:
Plus some speed tests. |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
edit:
July 22nd, @07:04PM
| 
ST5x6v6/FW v7.4.3.2: Random Resets launching 'DMT v7.35' | %20.GIF "34505 bytes")
'STMT' right before my old SpeedTouch was rebooted by launching 'DMT'... |
Well, lets post whatever i was able to catch: a fraction of half a two hours record...
UpStream SNR Margin & RCO seemed improved using this MoDem/FirmWare, though. |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
edit:
July 27th, @08:47AM
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "72765 bytes")
VelCom - Siemens 4200 (2008-Jul-26, RCOs @ 15 h) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "19068 bytes")
VelCom - Bell's Portal (Siemens 4200, 2008-Jul-26 15h09) | %20.GIF "37718 bytes")
VelCom - Test Results (Siemens SS4200, 2008-Jul-27) | |
Now some Siemens SpeedStream 4200 stuff, at last!
Mother nature has been less than cooperative lately
so this reconstructed 'DMT' capture shows numbers
which only cover the first seventeen hours, e.g. until
what started as a nice sunny day gave way to high
humidity, dark clouds, rain and the risk of lightnings.
All curves past 5 h PM aren't being accounted for by
the numbers but they are included anyway. The RCOs
were obtained at 15 h instead of 17 h, this parameter
does vary throughout the day but it still seems OKay.
Addendum:
Speed Tests...
Other details here: »/testhistory/1267354/b1adc |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
edit:
July 29th, @03:33AM
| %20.GIF "42983 bytes")
VelCom - ST516v6-2 (2008-Jul-28, 20h00) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "18896 bytes")
VelCom - Thomson ST516v6-2 (2008-Jul-28 00h36) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "18940 bytes")
VelCom - Thomson ST516v6-2 (2008-Jul-28 20h06) | 
6 h 'DMT' Capture - Left Part | 
6 h 'DMT' Capture - Right Part | | %20.GIF "37287 bytes")
VelCom - Test Results (ST516v6-2, FW v6.2.29.2-GE) | |
one of my Thomson SpeedTouch 516v6 on-line
anyway, it's the version which i believe to
sell with a switching-mode power supply and
a newer FirmWare (v6.2.29.2 vs v6.2.16.3).
There are two Bell Line-Test portal captures
included, one is only thirty minutes old and
the numbers added to the "ADSL-Info" section
(in light grey) reflect an 'STMT' capture i
made right after booting the MoDem. We can
see there's little variation compared to the
2nd set of records which is three hours old.
Also joined to this post you'll find one 6 h
old record to account for more variations...
Addendum:
Plus speed tests... |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
edit:
July 29th, @09:14AM
| I guess i can make two preliminary observations at this point:
1) My electrical distance is about 3.9 Kilo-meters
2) The best CRC Error immunity is probably achieved
at the expense of Relative Capacity Occupancy...
Addendum:
...and maybe even one more...
3) I may be ready to call my ISP for a profile raise! |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "46917 bytes")
VelCom - DMT (GNet GBB2060-Xi, 2008-Jul-30) |
|
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
| For the purpose of making comparisons:
%20.PNG)
Tweaks, Bicephale, 2007-Nov-30
Tweaks, Bicephale, 2008-Mar-6
%20.GIF)
Tweaks, Bicephale, 2008-Jul-7
In my present situation the DownStream RCO number
appears to be too high and the rate of "Far CRC" errors
(presently in Interleaved mode) tells me there could be
something wrong. In any case, my previous phone line
generated millions of "Near FEC" errors before and yet
both my GNet MoDems easily handled it so that's why i
think this profile setting is exageratly "conservative"...
Unfortunately, the only way to find out for sure may be
to evaluate multiple profiles until satisfaction is reached. |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "46651 bytes")
VelCom - DMT Tweak (2008-Jul-31 11h00) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "19090 bytes")
VelCom - Bell's Portal (GNet GBB2060-Xi, 2008-Jul-31 11h07) |
This 'DMT' capture was taken after the MoDem
settled for one hour, notice the discrepancy in
terms of UpStream Attenuation (caused by my
tweaking, most likely)... This sort of Spectral
Shaping implementation appears to allow a gain
of one (maybe two) dB on the DownStream SNR
Margin side and this tends to confirm an issue
with some UpStream bottleneck, IMHO... Can a
power transformer at the top of Hydro's pole
cause such a problem? I'm afraid it just might. |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "19070 bytes")
VelCom - ST546v6 FW v7.4.4.7-iA (2008-Jul-31 23h26) |
to observe that everything seems to be OKay by now!
Settle time for this capture was only about two hours,
(it's just for preliminaries), i'll post more details later... |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "19211 bytes")
VelCom - GNet GBB2060-Xi (Tweak, 2008-Aug-3 11h53) |
such as rain and lightnings have become the norm here!
Perhaps i'll be able to publish one 24 h curve tomorrow... |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
edit:
August 6th, @12:36PM
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "99359 bytes")
VelCom - GNet BB0060B (Tweak, 2008-Aug-5) |  .GIF/thumb.jpg "19224 bytes")
VelCom - Bell's portal (GNet BB0060B, 2008-Aug-5 16h26) | %20.GIF "37746 bytes")
VelCom - Test Results (GNet BB0060B, Twin PPP & Tweak) | |
changed). The tweak was to raise SNR Margins
but i'm not sure it helped my error rate (noise).
At least it was a full day without rain/lightnings!
Addendum:
Speed Tests |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
| Time for an update...
Here is an approximation of the phone line's spectral response
while it's still not completely optimized... Areas where colours
are fully saturated represent high probability levels. Take note
that my samples were taken at random intervals between July
31, August 1st, August 2, August 11, August 12 and August
13 via either a Thomson SpeedTouch 546v6 (FW v7.4.3.2-AA)
or my newer Thomson SpeedTouch 516v6 (FW v6.2.29.2-GE). |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
| %20.GIF "23059 bytes")
VelCom - Thomson ST516v6-2 (2008-Aug-16 19h) | %20.GIF "30532 bytes")
VelCom - Thomson ST516v6-2 (2008-Aug-16 21h) |
I thought that the 1st set of samples was bad
news enough but i find the 2nd one devastating.
Take note that the vetical scale numbers must
be multiplied by ten. Also, the 2nd capture has
two scale versions included in order to make the
transitions more obvious: it's just like flipping a
switch, actually!... In my opinion, this is noise
of industrial origin and Bell would never manage
to clean my phone line even if they wanted to!
I really doubt my little tricks will work this time.
 |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
| %20.GIF "42638 bytes")
VelCom - Thomson ST546v6 (2008-Aug-17 19h) | %20.GIF "41637 bytes")
VelCom - Thomson ST546v6 (2008-Aug-17 21h) |
I used a different MoDem with a variant of the
FirmWare installed on my newer ST516. Sunday
has been dry (which was a rare event lately) so
maybe it may explain the lower peek magnitudes.
Hummm... I guess i should keep track of the RH
factor too! Humidity would hardly account for
the steep noise burst transitions, nonetheless.
Today's 1st sample shows that it was taken only
23 minutes after rebooting the DSL unit and the
2nd one is a reminder that it's not possible to
refresh 'STMT' until the testing is complete (yet
is IS possible to generate multiple captures)...
If i had refreshed 'STMT' before creating those
captures then the "DSL-Link Utime" fields would
read as "2:23:36" and "4:24:17", respectively.
This ambiguity is avoided by taking screenshots
before the test cycle is over since the [Refresh
Data] button happens to be greyed-out then. |
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
| %20.GIF "7808 bytes")
VelCom - ST546v6 Static Numbers (2008-Aug-17) |
This is to confirm with numbers that the 1st two hours (and a half) were noisier...
That's also a reminder: it's OKay to click the [Modem Statistic] button (top left)!
|
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
|  .GIF/thumb.jpg "78349 bytes")
VelCom - Siemens SS4200 (2008-Aug-20 20h) |
This set of curves demonstrates how misleading it
might be to trust the SNRM curve alone - imagine if
using "static" numbers only!... I don't recall what's
the exact timing but i sure remember that i turned
on the 3 fans (Intec's XBox 360 'Air Cooler', item#
G8648C) late after midnight. That's a "green" device
(environmentally friendly) using a small switching-
mode power supply and it was found at Zellers, it's
installed right below my MoDem (or in front of it for
the old GNet) since i arrived here in Quebec city. I
suspect there's noise comming from the fans, their
PSU or both so it's something i must investigate!...
But right now, my point is this: the SNR Margin data
which was captured at 20 h simply didn't allow me to
foresee what would happen in the next few minutes:
SNRM was 5 dB for the most part of the day and it
was even lower during the period between midnight
and 5h30, actually. Yet, a major disruption occured
after 20 h which even twenty hours worth of curves
couldn't help to predict, nonetheless! Put shortly, a
24 h set of curves is nice to have but it's even nicer
to collect many of those so that a pattern emerges.
Back to the SNR Margins, we'd find it most impractical
to watch the numbers every fifteen minutes so that's
why i prefer 'STMT' over 'DMT' if using a SpeedTouch:
the curves are much more informative than a pair of
numbers which may be great for a SpeedStream 4200
while the very same figures appear to be dangerously
marginal (at best!) for a typical SpeedTouch 5x6v6...
By the way, looking at SNR Margins one can't tell when
i turned off my fans but it seems the CRC curve helps.
So, i invite the readers to draw their own conclusions!
|
|
Bicephale
join:2005-09-24
·TekSavvy Solutions..
·Velcom
| %20.GIF "42965 bytes")
VelCom - ST516v6-2 (2008-Aug-22 17 h) | %20.GIF "59359 bytes")
VelCom - ST516v6-2 (2008-Aug-22 19 h) | %20.GIF "63929 bytes")
VelCom - ST516v6-2 (2008-Aug-22 21 h) | %20.GIF "49765 bytes")
VelCom - ST516v6-2 (2008-Aug-22 23 h) |
|
|
%20.GIF "4144 bytes")