Huh? - dslreports.com

Forums » New iPhone Means Little If You're In AT&T 3G Dead Zone » Huh?


Uniqs: 494	Share Topic:	RSS topic:	toggle: flat / full normal / watch	Post a:	Post a:

« 3g coverage sucks.

pnh102 Reptiles Are Cuddly And Pretty Premium join:2002-05-02 Mount Airy, MD	Huh? Why is this a problem? Does the new iPhone only work on 3G networks and not on EDGE, GPRS or plain vanilla GSM networks? -- This isn't fair! I was only supposed to hate just ONE presidential candidate!
	permalink · 2008-07-10 13:47:22 ·

gdm Premium,MVM join:2001-06-15 Mchenry, IL clubs:	Re: Huh? No the new iphone is both 3G and Edge. Karl is just making a statement that it's really no benefit if you aren't in a 3G area.
	permalink · 2008-07-10 13:53:54 ·

ptrowski Got Helix? Premium join:2005-03-14 Putnam, CT clubs: ·VOIPo ·Metrocast Communic.. ·AT&T DSL Service ·ViaTalk	Re: Huh? said by gdm : No the new iphone is both 3G and Edge. Karl is just making a statement that it's really no benefit if you aren't in a 3G area. Exactly. I have 3g coverage at the office, but not at my house. Not a problem as I would use wifi at the house anyways.
	permalink · 2008-07-10 13:56:08 ·

Dust_er

join:2002-11-16
San Marcos, CA

Re: Huh?

said by ptrowski

said by gdm

:

No the new iphone is both 3G and Edge. Karl is just making a statement that it's really no benefit if you aren't in a 3G area.

Exactly. I have 3g coverage at the office, but not at my house. Not a problem as I would use wifi at the house anyways.

You mean if you have a cell phone that supports WiFi, you can use your phone through the Wifi network @ your house? even when there's zero bars for the cell at your house?
--
-LonG-

permalink · 2008-07-12 12:55:03 · Print ·

ptrowski
Got Helix?
Premium
join:2005-03-14
Putnam, CT
clubs:

·VOIPo

·Metrocast Communic..

·AT&T DSL Service

·ViaTalk

Re: Huh?

said by Dust_er

said by ptrowski

said by gdm

:

No the new iphone is both 3G and Edge. Karl is just making a statement that it's really no benefit if you aren't in a 3G area.

Exactly. I have 3g coverage at the office, but not at my house. Not a problem as I would use wifi at the house anyways.

You mean if you have a cell phone that supports WiFi, you can use your phone through the Wifi network @ your house? even when there's zero bars for the cell at your house?

No, I was thinking wifi for the internet speeds.

permalink · 2008-07-12 12:58:30 · Print ·

Dust_er join:2002-11-16 San Marcos, CA	Re: Huh? I see. Also do you think my previous statement is possible or exists?
	permalink · 2008-07-12 13:04:16 ·

ptrowski Got Helix? Premium join:2005-03-14 Putnam, CT clubs: ·VOIPo ·Metrocast Communic.. ·AT&T DSL Service ·ViaTalk	Re: Huh? said by Dust_er : I see. Also do you think my previous statement is possible or exists? How about T-Mobile's new service? »https://support.t-mobile.com/knowbase/ro···450.htm?
	permalink · 2008-07-12 13:24:24 ·

Count Zero MD2Be Premium join:2007-01-18 Warner Robins, GA	Considering you can't get an EDGE data plan in those areas....
	permalink · 2008-07-10 14:18:42 ·

wifi4milez
Big Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace

join:2004-08-07
New York, NY

·Verizon FIOS

·Sprint Mobile Broa..

·RoadRunner Cable

·BroadVoice

Re: Huh?

said by Count Zero

:

Considering you can't get an EDGE data plan in those areas....

Thats incorrect. Now that they have finally shut down their last few TDMA sites, you can get EDGE data anywhere in the country (that ATT services of course).
--
If history teaches us anything, it teaches that simple-minded appeasement or wishful thinking about our adversaries is folly.
-Ronald Reagan-

permalink · 2008-07-10 14:27:21 · Print ·

Count Zero MD2Be Premium join:2007-01-18 Warner Robins, GA	Re: Huh? No you can't sign up for the CHEAPER EDGE only data plan... that's what I meant.
	permalink · 2008-07-10 15:04:47 ·

wifi4milez Big Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace join:2004-08-07 New York, NY	Re: Huh? Thats not entirely true. If you have an older phone (even an older iphone) with the unlimited EDGE plan you can simply swap out your SIM. The real question is, why would you buy the new iphone if not to take advantage of 3g?
	permalink · 2008-07-10 18:53:19 ·

Count Zero
MD2Be
Premium
join:2007-01-18
Warner Robins, GA

·AT&T DSL Service

·Cox HSI

Re: Huh?

Has that been tested? Because iPhones are actually quite picky about what SIM is inside of them. Even swapping SIMs between my iPhone and my wife's iPhone (so we could keep our numbers but swap capacities) I had to re-activate both of them through iTunes... additinoally you'd have to buy one of the no-contract iPhone 3Gs for like $500-600 to do that because if you buy the iPhone 3G at the discounted price you need to sign a 2 year contract and upgrade to the new 3G data plan.

permalink · 2008-07-10 18:56:39 ·

wifi4milez Big Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace join:2004-08-07 New York, NY	Re: Huh? I have never heard of anyone having issues swapping ATT sims between iphones. I would agree that you would need to buy one of the no contract iphones however, unless of course you found a used one available online.
	permalink · 2008-07-10 19:00:24 ·

Count Zero
MD2Be
Premium
join:2007-01-18
Warner Robins, GA

·AT&T DSL Service

·Cox HSI

Re: Huh?

I'm not kidding, both of the phones had to be re-activated when I swapped the SIMs out. I was not expecting that, but at least I wasn't changed any bogus fees for doing so.

The cost of buying the out-of-contract iPhone to avoid having to pay for the 3G data plan would way more than offset the savings of the higher monthly charges... so really the point is you can't buy an iPhone tomorrow if you live in a non-3G area and not get boned. I just saw that where I live isn't 3G... and isn't even close to anywhere 3G either! I am GLAD I wasn't seriously considering upgrading tomorrow!

permalink · 2008-07-10 19:03:14 · Print ·

wifi4milez
Big Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace

join:2004-08-07
New York, NY

·Verizon FIOS

·Sprint Mobile Broa..

·RoadRunner Cable

·BroadVoice

Re: Huh?

said by Count Zero

:

I'm not kidding, both of the phones had to be re-activated when I swapped the SIMs out. I was not expecting that, but at least I wasn't changed any bogus fees for doing so.

I have never experienced anything like that, and I have used US SIMs in phones all around the world (and the other way around as well). I supposed ATT could have put some strange software lock in their iphones, but this is the first I have heard of such a statement.
--
If history teaches us anything, it teaches that simple-minded appeasement or wishful thinking about our adversaries is folly.
-Ronald Reagan-

permalink · 2008-07-11 11:34:53 · Print ·

SSidlov
Other Things On My Mind
Premium
join:2000-03-03
Pompton Lakes, NJ

·Optimum Online

·Cingular Wireless

If you were buying a iPhone or other 3G phone, the ATT people would have no problem giving you a 3G sim. I went from a EDGE phone to a 3G phone (I'm not smug enough and didn't have the $30 required data plan to qualify for a upgrade to an iPhone) and I had to change my old sim for a new one to get HSDPA speeds on the phone.. Though I have heard of people just going in to swap sims (and you need a 3G sim for HSDPA connectivity, I understand) the sim and the IMEI from the phone (whatever kind it is) have to be linked by ATT to give you service.

permalink · 2008-07-11 09:01:52 · Print ·

wifi4milez
Big Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace

join:2004-08-07
New York, NY

·Verizon FIOS

·Sprint Mobile Broa..

·RoadRunner Cable

·BroadVoice

Re: Huh?

said by SSidlov

:

If you were buying a iPhone or other 3G phone, the ATT people would have no problem giving you a 3G sim. I went from a EDGE phone to a 3G phone (I'm not smug enough and didn't have the $30 required data plan to qualify for a upgrade to an iPhone) and I had to change my old sim for a new one to get HSDPA speeds on the phone.. Though I have heard of people just going in to swap sims (and you need a 3G sim for HSDPA connectivity, I understand) the sim and the IMEI from the phone (whatever kind it is) have to be linked by ATT to give you service.

Having used GSM phones for well over a decade, I have never heard of a different type of SIM being needed to access 3G. Its the radio in the phone that accesses the network, not the SIM. Now I have no experience with the iPhone personally, but unless they are using a revolutionary new technology a SIM is a SIM and will work in any phone (locked phones not being applicable of course).
--
If history teaches us anything, it teaches that simple-minded appeasement or wishful thinking about our adversaries is folly.
-Ronald Reagan-

permalink · 2008-07-11 11:32:54 · Print ·

SSidlov
Other Things On My Mind
Premium
join:2000-03-03
Pompton Lakes, NJ

·Optimum Online

·Cingular Wireless

1 edit

Re: Huh?

I just went from a Siemens phone to a SE phone. The Siemens was EDGE and the SE is 3G. My old card was a 64K card. They made me change sims. The new card has 3G configuration options on it, there is a option in the phone to 'load configuration' from it. But I suspect that it's only the predefined networking passwords, etc.

however, a quick search turned this up: »wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Carriers/ATT it seems some sim cards won't work or have limted functions.

I have a 'blazing fireball 3G' now.

(I've also had ATT prior to Cingular's purchase when they just started issuing sims...and phones like the dual TDMA/GSM S46 were popular.)

permalink · 2008-07-14 17:00:53 · Print ·

ReVeLaTeD Premium join:2001-11-10 San Diego, CA	said by Count Zero : Even swapping SIMs between my iPhone and my wife's iPhone (so we could keep our numbers but swap capacities) I had to re-activate both of them through iTunes... Slightly off topic...but this is unbelievable. To use a phone, you have "activate" it through a music software. Instead of other non-Apple phones where you just buy the phone and slap your SIM right in.
	permalink · 2008-07-11 11:44:37 · Print ·

Big Brother @qwest.net	quote: Why is this a problem? Does the new iPhone only work on 3G networks and not on EDGE, GPRS or plain vanilla GSM networks? This is a problem because AT&T and Apple are trying to convince people to toss their old iPhone and buy the new "faster" iPhone in droves. For a large % of people this new phone won't give any significant improvement over their current phone(s)
	permalink · 2008-07-10 13:57:40 ·

Pictor Guy join:2004-06-21 Sammamish, WA	Re: Huh? The same can be said for most smart phones. Why call out the iPhone? And a bonus (for some) might be lower initial price on the new phone and longer battery life. Although personally I would rather pay more upfront and have a lower TCO.
	permalink · 2008-07-10 23:07:38 ·

your comment..

Forums » New iPhone Means Little If You're In AT&T 3G Dead Zone

« 3g coverage sucks.


Sunday, 06-Dec 05:02:33	Terms of Use \| Privacy Policy \| Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo \| feedback \| contact over 10 years online! © 1999-2009 dslreports.com.republican-creole page compression OFF