 justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY
Host: IPv6 Business Connectiv.. Home/Office setup .. Console/Handheld g.. Console Tech
1 edit | [iPhone] My 3G problem list Some of these are a big step backward from the 2g iphone ! others were there in both, some are just niggles.
1. very slow wifi vs 2g iphone on 802.11n for high latency connections (not fixed by 2.0.1)
2. Iphone frequently goes into 'super slow' typing or touch, as shown by this youtube clip: »www.youtube.com/watch?v=DL7n9Vo7mJw (not fixed by 2.0.1)
3. Certain popular web pages bog the browser down to very slow or even frozen. smh.com.au is one, finance.yahoo.com is another. The page appears but zooming may not re-render to clarity, and typing, scrolling, etc can become impossibly slow.
4. Spontaneous crashes in the browser, and non-trivial yet popular appstore apps.
5. SMS page can take 4+ seconds to appear
6. Auto-brightness appears not to work very well anymore. Under sunlight, a 50% slider does not "auto" to decent brightness, in darkness it does not "auto" to minimal screen brightness. Vs the 2g iphone, any brightness setting of 0 to 50% resulted in a big change in brightness auto on vs off [thats good]. Not so the 3g iphone where "auto" makes very little difference [thats bad].
7. Poor 3g coverage (this is a fault of my carrier). One bar only for 3g, then it falls back to gprs and there are full bars.
8. Ring volume still nothing like the most basic nokia. Too easy to cover up the little noise outlet and render the phone basically silent. Too easy to change the ringer volume accidentally and not realize it is no longer loud enough. I wish the mute slider had a selectable time out.
9. Noticeably poor battery life vs 2g
10. Can't edit a contact while on a phone call (how do you make a note of a new number?)
11. Sometimes it would be nice to stop the auto-rotation to landscape mode. eg when I look at the screen when *I* am horizontal? | |
|
  Dogfather Premium join:2007-12-26 Laguna Hills, CA | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Is there a question here or is this just a rant? | |
|
 |   bobrk You kids get offa my lawn Premium join:2000-02-02 San Jose, CA
·SONIC.NET
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by Dogfather :Is there a question here or is this just a rant? It's a "problem list." -- Iraq Coalition Deaths | bobrk | |
|
 |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY
Host: IPv6 Business Connectiv.. Home/Office setup .. Console/Handheld g.. Console Tech
| yes, the question implicit in this list is which of these problems is definitely peculiar to my phone.
In other words, if someone else has some of these I'd like to know so I can wait for another firmware update, rather than sending the phone back and asking apple to replace it.
I know #2 #4 #9 are common. #10 and #11 are UI complaints. #8 is a design issue
that still leaves #1, #3, #5, #6 as possibly just unique to my phone.. | |
|
 |  |   hyperjoe Premium join:2000-11-03 Gates Mills, OH | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list ok, if you put the phone in your underwear, does that help any? | |
|
 |  |  |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Yeah I tried that, now what? | |
|
 |  |  |  |   bobrk You kids get offa my lawn Premium join:2000-02-02 San Jose, CA | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Where's the video? | |
|
 |  |  |  |  |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list I can't help you with forum permissions here, that is off topic. | |
|
 |  |  Daemon Premium join:2003-06-29 San Francisco, CA
·Comcast
1 edit | said by justin :#10 and #11 are UI complaints. #11 is not a UI issue. It has to do with the uniformity of gravity regardless of your current body orientation  | |
|
  bobrk You kids get offa my lawn Premium join:2000-02-02 San Jose, CA
·SONIC.NET
| Here, I'll be on topic on your items 1, 3, 5 and 6:
said by justin :1. very slow wifi vs 2g iphone on 802.11n for high latency connections (not fixed by 2.0.1) My WiFi speeds are adequate and average. I don't have a n wireless to compare to, though.
3. Certain popular web pages bog the browser down to very slow or even frozen. smh.com.au is one, finance.yahoo.com is another. The page appears but zooming may not re-render to clarity, and typing, scrolling, etc can become impossibly slow.
I've noticed this. I've attributed it to a slow CPU, perhaps trying to process a lot of javascript.
5. SMS page can take 4+ seconds to appear
Yes, I've seen that.
6. Auto-brightness appears not to work very well anymore. Under sunlight, a 50% slider does not "auto" to decent brightness, in darkness it does not "auto" to minimal screen brightness. Vs the 2g iphone, any brightness setting of 0 to 50% resulted in a big change in brightness auto on vs off [thats good]. Not so the 3g iphone where "auto" makes very little difference [thats bad].
I've never seen this work in the manner that I would expect it to.
I have an original iPhone running 2.0.1. -- Iraq Coalition Deaths | bobrk | |
|
 |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY
Host: IPv6 Business Connectiv.. Home/Office setup .. Console/Handheld g.. Console Tech
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list well, auto-brightness worked ok on the 2g iphone.. It was very handy for battery saving. It would sample ambient light once when the screen turns on. In a dark room it would be minimal back-light.
Now I have to set the brightness high (all the time) or i can't use it well outdoors. | |
|
  jifdo3922
@comcast.net
| Why don't they make a simple sliding door to change the battery? This is absolutely silly. This makes the device anything but mobile. A 2nd battery is so simple, yet Apple is dumb enough to think that people won't need this. They also would love to view all the private info you have on your phone when you send it in for them to replace the battery, and then send you a crusty scratched phone back which isn't the same one you sent in. | |
|
 |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list probably because a sliding door plus the thicker wrapping of the battery (to make it safe, not bendable) and all the rest of the extra bits required would either reduce the size of the battery or increase the form factor of the phone. | |
|
 |
 |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY
Host: IPv6 Business Connectiv.. Home/Office setup .. Console/Handheld g.. Console Tech
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Don't wifi routers broadcast n and b/g at the same time?
The airport says "802.11n (802.11b/g compatible)" and the other options are "802.11n" "802.11n (802.11a compatible)" "802.11n only (5ghz)"
So what would it be doing to talk to a 802.11b device like the iPhone?
And any idea how to force the airport extreme to be 802.11b only? | |
|
 |  |   Dogfather Premium join:2007-12-26 Laguna Hills, CA
·Cox HSI
·Verizon FIOS
·Cox VOIP
·ViaTalk
·RoadRunner Cable
·MegaPath
·Verizon west (ex G..
·Time Warner VOIP
3 edits | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by justin :Don't wifi routers broadcast n and b/g at the same time? The airport says "802.11n (802.11b/g compatible)" and the other options are "802.11n" "802.11n (802.11a compatible)" "802.11n only (5ghz)" So what would it be doing to talk to a 802.11b device like the iPhone? And any idea how to force the airport extreme to be 802.11b only? There is a B only option. But it shouldn't matter. The iPhone is an 802.11g capable device and should work fine with the settings you chose (2.4GHz b/g/n, 20MHz channels). I'm assuming you've tried other channels instead of letting it autoscan?
-- "Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders...All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the peacemakers for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger." -Hermann Goering 4/18/46 | |
|
 |  |  |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY
Host: IPv6 Business Connectiv.. Home/Office setup .. Console/Handheld g.. Console Tech
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by Dogfather :There is a B only option. But it shouldn't matter. The iPhone is an 802.11g capable device and should work fine with the settings you chose (2.4GHz b/g/n, 20MHz channels). I'm assuming you've tried other channels instead of letting it autoscan? I don't have those options on mine. This is airport extreme, yes?
My menu is much shorter  | |
|
 |  |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |  |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Ah! thanks. I wish those menus had a little option indicator next to them to show that they had hidden options! | |
|
 |  |  |  |  |  |   Dogfather Premium join:2007-12-26 Laguna Hills, CA | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Where's the fun in that? | |
|
 |  |   Count Zero MD2Be Premium join:2007-01-18 Warner Robins, GA | the airport software under wireless. The airport does not simulcast n and b/g. | |
|
  jrobcet
join:2003-02-16 Moscow, ID
| I don't have 802.11n, so I can't answer to that.
I'm seeing the same problems with numbers 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 10, & 11.
3g coverage in my area is excellent. Definitely no complaints there.
As for battery life, I knew the battery life would be worse than 2g, so I don't consider it to really be an issue.
I'll also add another that was supposedly fixed in 2.0.1: The contacts lag. My contacts are unusable for approx 5 seconds after being opened. It seems worse when opening them from the contacts widget from the home screen as opposed to opening them from the phone app. | |
|
 Pentaxian Premium join:2008-01-23 West Milford, NJ
| I'm disappointed with..
Battery life with 3G turned OFF!
Falsey advertised apps that you have to pay for.
Stalling - basically the iPhone sometimes takes forever to do something. Much worse since the update. Not always but it happens.
Innacurate GPS - why bother then? | |
|
 |  |
 |  |  Pentaxian Premium join:2008-01-23 West Milford, NJ | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list if you press the little reload thing at the bottom left of the page that usually tells it to relocate you via GPS.. | |
|
 |
 |   Nezmo The name's Bond. James Bond. Premium,MVM join:2004-11-10 Coppell, TX | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Making me nervous. I just ordered one . | |
|
 |  |  Pentaxian Premium join:2008-01-23 West Milford, NJ | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Nezmo - Don't worry about it, it's still way better than the alternatives and it truly is an amazing gadget! I really doubt you'll regret it. | |
|
 |  |   pleaseworkiphone
@mchsi.com
| said by Nezmo :Making me nervous. I just ordered one  . Me too. Although this is the 2nd time I'm giving it a chance. First 2G iphone I had shown terrible WIFI reception issues. Even in the same room as two different wireless routers, the iphone would show less than full reception regardless of channel selections. iphone couldn't pick-up WIFI signal outside of the house. My pda could get a signal outside in the backyard! Night and day difference.
This will be my second attempt with the iphone. Reading this thread, I'm concerned as you are. I ordered the iphone, then justin creates this thread! | |
|
 |
 |   MarkyD Premium join:2002-08-20 Oklahoma City, OK clubs:
·Cox HSI
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list
quote: Poor 3g coverage (this is a fault of my carrier). One bar only for 3g, then it falls back to gprs and there are full bars.
I have this same issue. I just stopped turning 3g on. It's RARE for me to go somewhere and get more than 1-2 bars on 3g. I have almost a full EDGE signal everywhere I go. Is this specific to the iPhone, or does AT&T's 3g coverage just suck that bad? | |
|
 |  |   Nezmo The name's Bond. James Bond. Premium,MVM join:2004-11-10 Coppell, TX
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by MarkyD : quote: Poor 3g coverage (this is a fault of my carrier). One bar only for 3g, then it falls back to gprs and there are full bars.
I have this same issue. I just stopped turning 3g on. It's RARE for me to go somewhere and get more than 1-2 bars on 3g. I have almost a full EDGE signal everywhere I go. Is this specific to the iPhone, or does AT&T's 3g coverage just suck that bad? No idea about iPhone specifically, but 3G where I live is full strength and very reliable. Has been for a long time. -- My Gallery MySpace Formerly Nezmo  | |
|
 |  |   ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| I mentioned this on YOUR forum, yet you still went out and got the new I-Phone (2 of them if I remember), so now it does not work on 3G, again, as I pointed out on YOUR forum, AT&T has terrible 3G coverage operating on only 1 of the 4 bands, so you should take it back while you can and get the original unlocked and save a ton of money too. | |
|
 |  |  |  Pentaxian Premium join:2008-01-23 West Milford, NJ
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list I don't see how you can save money supercooldave..
The plan from ATT for the iPhone was far cheaper than anything from Verizon was.. In my case I got TWO iPhones for $139.00 per month for everything.. ONE 'the Dare' from Verizon was $150 with all the additional plans you needed to get the same functionality as the iPhone has... | |
|
 |  |  |  |   ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Not if you are getting things like unlimited text/data, do you really need these? In any case you will still have a locked phone at the end of your 2 years or with an unlocked one you can change plans if you find you don't need ALL the extra features at any time. With the "GO" phone its $25 for 3 months, 10 cents a minute, free to other AT&T phones plus $1 a day if you make a call and pay as you go (much higher) for data/text and use the WIFI free. Since you are not using the limited 3G coverage you are still getting excellent regular coverage. Everyone should work out before signing contracts what the best deal is and the restrictions. | |
|
 |  |  |  |  |   Nezmo The name's Bond. James Bond. Premium,MVM join:2004-11-10 Coppell, TX
1 edit | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by ultracooldave :
Not if you are getting things like unlimited text/data, do you really need these? In any case you will still have a locked phone at the end of your 2 years or with an unlocked one you can change plans if you find you don't need ALL the extra features at any time. With the "GO" phone its $25 for 3 months, 10 cents a minute, free to other AT&T phones plus $1 a day if you make a call and pay as you go (much higher) for data/text and use the WIFI free. Since you are not using the limited 3G coverage you are still getting excellent regular coverage. Everyone should work out before signing contracts what the best deal is and the restrictions. We're going off topic in a thread by the site owner, lol... but I'll bite for a second.
What if you don't care what the best deal is? Not everyone is hell-bent on getting the cheapest option by doing without features etc. You seem to be assuming everyone thinks the same way as yourself. -- My Gallery MySpace Formerly Nezmo  | |
|
 |  |  |  |  |  |  Pentaxian Premium join:2008-01-23 West Milford, NJ
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list The 'Go' phone? Isn't that a basic, does nothing sort of phone? You pay in advance? The iPhone is leagues above it in functionality and I must admit.. When I was a Verizon customer I used my crappy LG flip phone for one thing and one thing only.. Making phone calls.. Now that I have a phone that has all this functionality, it is making my life easier. I actually am getting more done while being mobil and not to mention my laptop has gotten a major break from usage. And to answer your question, YES, I need data. And why would one buy a data capable phone and only use it for making phone calls? If you're goig to do that save yourself some serious cash and simply buy a standard cell phone that does nothing else but make phone calls. | |
|
 |  |  |
 jfoj
join:2005-05-06 Mclean, VA
| Lenmar Power Port, see link below
»www.lenmar.com/Web/ProductSummar···enmarsku
I purchased this for my daughters iTouch and seems to work quit well. Probably thinner than the iPhone and about the side of a playing card. Probably the same battery the iPhone and iTouch us in a different case?
What's nice about this kit is you can charge your iPhone/iTouch in the car or at home with the purchase of this one kit.
jfoj | |
|
  ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| ALL of these issues with the new I-Phone had been already been addressed by me in these forums. My suggestion- buy the original I-Phone (still completely cool) used on ebay with V2.0 installed, unlocked/jailbroken. You will save at least $4000 (over 2 years) over going with the ridiculous AT&T contract and at the end of 2 years you will still have a great valuable phone. Forget the 3G, you can get a used original for about $300 and have a choice of providers. | |
|
 Alan Premium join:2001-01-28 Atlantic Beach, FL
| Yeah, my phone seems to slow down over time. A fresh reboot seems to speed it back up.
The browser does seem to crash a lot. I'll be reading something and all the sudden the browser shuts down. It's pretty annoying.
As a side note, I wish the quicklink icons at the top of the DSLReports' page were a bit larger so I could easily select one without extra zooming. | |
|
  Onebox
@shawcable.net
| I have a 3G from Rogers for about 2 weeks now. I had a 2G from (*cough*) AT&T before that was obviously cracked to run on Rogers in Canada.
The 3G with 2.0 seemed to have some issues with "stickyness" during application start etc., but 2.0.1 has, for me at least, fixed all of those.
I read reports that people have issues finding wireless networks etc, but I never had any. The phone finds the same wireless sources as the MacBook Pro, which is already more that the Vista Laptop of my friend finds...
When connected to WiFi, running AppStore's SpeedTest ( free ), I get 730 Kb down and 265 Kb, which is exactly what the MacBook Pro get's from the same wireless router.
@ Justin: Is yours hacked, pwnaged or otherwise modded?
The batterylife is about the same as the 2G, as long as I remember to turn off the GPS and 3G when I don't need them.
Come on now, people.. everybody wants 3G but does not want to accept that those chips are HOGS when it comes to battery life. Turn the shit off when you don't need it. | |
|
 |   justin Australian join:1999-05-28 Brooklyn, NY | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by Onebox :
@ Justin: Is yours hacked, pwnaged or otherwise modded?
No, my 2g iphone was (and really apart from not being 3g, is so far a better device), but my 3g is mint. | |
|
  ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| again "Everyone should work out before signing contracts what the best deal is and the restrictions" The topic is- 3G problems, if you don't get 3G in many places what is the use for the new I-Phone? You are going to find even in a place like NYC there are many areas you will not even get service! What is the use of any phone thats unreliable even in NYC? I want to make it clear I am not blaming APPLE its AT&T's terrible 3G, do you really want to sign a contract worth thousands of dollars over 2 years for this? At least you can turn off the 3G, so whats wrong with the original I-Phone at a great price/no contract? It will then do just about everything the new one will and you will even be able to make calls everywhere and change plans immediately without much penalty. | |
|
 |   Nezmo The name's Bond. James Bond. Premium,MVM join:2004-11-10 Coppell, TX
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by ultracooldave :
again "Everyone should work out before signing contracts what the best deal is and the restrictions" The topic is- 3G problems, if you don't get 3G in many places what is the use for the new I-Phone? You are going to find even in a place like NYC there are many areas you will not even get service! What is the use of any phone thats unreliable even in NYC? I want to make it clear I am not blaming APPLE its AT&T's terrible 3G, do you really want to sign a contract worth thousands of dollars over 2 years for this? At least you can turn off the 3G, so whats wrong with the original I-Phone at a great price/no contract? It will then do just about everything the new one will and you will even be able to make calls everywhere and change plans immediately without much penalty. Well, at least for myself, 3G is never a problem in my vicinity and I'm already an AT&T customer and the data plan is the same as my current smartphone. I don't see the problem. Now, if the iPhone has problems holding on to 3G signals for me, I will have to assume it's the phone and it will go back. -- My Gallery MySpace Formerly Nezmo  | |
|
 |  |   ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list Actually CNET is reporting that there "may" be a problem with the new phone 3G circuit-I find this hard to believe., I had assumed that all the problem is with AT&T (see this sites home page), in any case who really needs it with WIFI everywhere? If you have a strong 3G signal everywhere you take the phone and have a very heavy need for data/text the new phone/contract may be the best for you but watch out for the heat generated, lets wait and see what an independent tester like consumer reports has to say regarding extremely heavy/data/3G usage on the new phone/battery, an original I-Phone unlocked/jailbroken is a bargain for $300.(and I would bet its still worth $300 a year or 2 from now) | |
|
  Seandhi Seeing From a New Level Premium join:2003-04-19 Humble, TX
1 edit | I just got my iPhone on Friday; I updated immediately to 2.0.1. Overall I am pleased with it (I am typing this message on it... And the keyboard is sluggish), but I am having many of the same issues that you are having. Sometimes it seems like wifi is just as fast as my 3g connection. I had the 8525 and the Tilt before I got this phone, both were 3g, and I could go a day and a half with moderate usage. I have to charge this one half way through the day. I am going to turn off gps and wifi tomorrow to see if that helps... They were huge battery killers on my Tilt.
Edit: My keyboard is sluggish, but nowhere near as bad as that video... -- You're an enlightened cat, and I dig that. | |
|
  onebadmofo Repost These Nuts In Your Mouth. Premium join:2002-03-30 Reading, PA | Looking to get an iPhone in November. I just wanna follow this thread to find out more about it. -- Photoshop these nuts in your mouth.
| |
|
  ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| It seems I was wrong blaming AT&T for the 3G problems, reports from all over the world are showing even in strong 3G areas the new I-Phone is operating at 1/4 speed or not at all. The hardware chipset is blamed rather than software making it impossible to fix if true. Apple at the moment is "collecting reports". If you just bought one you may want to take it back if possible. | |
|
 |  Pentaxian Premium join:2008-01-23 West Milford, NJ
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list said by ultracooldave :
Apple at the moment is "collecting reports". Can you show us proof of this?
said by ultracooldave :
If you just bought one you may want to take it back if possible. And do what? Get the same problematic yet kickass phone again?
Now - If there is a problem, I expect a new phone. Though, I haven't seen any evidence of needing a new phone yet, only early adoption issues.. The best advice at this point is.. If you're a weenie, return it ASAP and run like hell from anything containing APPLE.. The rest, sit back and relax while the worlds leading techno gadget company rocks out the fix... | |
|
  onebadmofo Repost These Nuts In Your Mouth. Premium join:2002-03-30 Reading, PA | Looks like my November wait is looking better and better. -- Photoshop these nuts in your mouth.
| |
|
  Boz
@swbell.net
| My 3G iPhone works great. Nothing annoys me that much.
Supposedly 90% of the problems people are having are solved with a soft reset (hold down sleep and home for 15 seconds until the apple logo appears, then the screen goes blank, then appears again).
I was told by an Apple tech guy that the way the phones and software are right now it's mandatory to turn off or soft reset the phones at least once every five days.
No big deal. This is still the coolest phone out there. | |
|
 |   ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list "Soft re-set" may help, (re-starting win ME every day- I had no problems with it) BUT worldwide with many 3G providers these phones are not working properly! Unfortunately, due to the very extreme competition for all new gadgets you simply cannot test properly out in the real world- I warned of this before the phone was even released, the effects of extreme data usage and heat on the phone/battery are also unknown at present. I also had a solution- get a used unlocked/jailbroken original I-Phone on ebay for $300 avoiding the contract as well. They have been out long enough for you to know where you stand with it. | |
|
  Boz
@swbell.net | $300 my booty. I just sold my original two 16GB iPhones for $500 each on eBay.
The lowest I've seen one go for at end of auction is $390. | |
|
 |   ultracooldave
@verizon.net | Re: [iPhone] My 3G problem list I was talking 8Gig, maybe the price has already gone up with my posts! Who wouldn't want to save thousands (in most cases) over the stupid contract and get a great phone that actually works? | |
|
  ultracooldave
@verizon.net
| I don't need to show proof, its all rumors but it is all over the internet if you bothered to look. With this much smoke there is likely to be fire. problems are being reported all over the world with many 3G providers. If the 3G works for you or you don't need it there is no problem, except finding the money for that expensive contract. | |
|
 |
|
 |