dslreports logo
site
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc

spacer




how-to block ads


Search Topic:
uniqs
12
share rss forum feed
« Never!
This is a sub-selection from BDE is still around?


RARPSL

join:1999-12-08
Suffern, NY
reply to Vadork

Re: BDE is still around?

said by Vadork:

The pirate bay carries a number of Child Porn website rips. All of which are based in Europe and Russia. Dress girls up in erotic clothing, swimsuits etc... Then they show off the private parts through the clothing. Here in Illinois, our supreme court ruled It's child porn by showing the genitalia of a minor through clothing intentionally.
A question and some comments.

Are the models actually underage or 18+ and DRESSING in Children's Clothing? If they are 18+ then it is (possibly) porn (depending on your definition of Porn) but not CHILD Porn.

Second, your Supreme Court seems to be defining Porn as Pictures showing Nudity and not just Sexual Activities. Thus a "baby on a rug picture" is Child Porn since the baby is not clothed even when s/he is on her/his stomach instead of back (where the genitalia is exposed not hidden).

Vadork

join:2005-09-01
Winnebago, IL

When I say Underage I mean UNDERAGE! Were talking 12 year old girls. Even younger than 10 on some sites. I'll try and hunt down the ruling to be more specific as to the ruling. But these sites don't even use models 16 or up.



RARPSL

join:1999-12-08
Suffern, NY

said by Vadork:

When I say Underage I mean UNDERAGE! Were talking 12 year old girls. Even younger than 10 on some sites. I'll try and hunt down the ruling to be more specific as to the ruling. But these sites don't even use models 16 or up.
This is, IMO, a case of the Judge trying to do a Long Arm application of his local standards. Sites that are located out of his jurisdiction are a gray area if the content is legal in location of the site (and especially if it is a non-US site). For example, in certain areas of the Middle East it is supposedly illegal to have pictures of the a woman whose face is not covered (no matter what clothing she is wearing/not-wearing).