| reply to hopeflicker
Re: Whats the problem? I dunthinkso  |
|
 hopeflickerCapitalism breeds greedPremium
join:2003-04-03
Long Beach, CA
kudos:1 | umm, yes. when you view any youtube page, you are downloading copyright content. Youtube is full of copyright content. |
|
| Now you're just talking out of your |
|
|
|
hopeflickerCapitalism breeds greedPremium
join:2003-04-03
Long Beach, CA
kudos:1 | said by ninjatutle:Now you're just talking out of your You are in denial.
Have you ever watch a music video at Youtube?
Have you ever watch a home made video with music in it?
Have you ever watch a trailer there?
if so, you too are a thief.
And i'll assume you saw the mickey mouse image.
--
There is no love untouched by hate
No unity without discord
There is no courage without fear
There is no peace without a war
There is no wisdom without regret
No admiration without scorn
|
|
 MattAll noise, no signal.Premium
join:2003-07-20
Jamestown, NC
kudos:12 | said by hopeflicker:said by ninjatutle:Now you're just talking out of your You are in denial. Have you ever watch a music video at Youtube? Have you ever watch a home made video with music in it? Have you ever watch a trailer there? if so, you too are a thief. And i'll assume you saw the mickey mouse image. YouTube hosts the material, not you. That is why THEY receive the DMCA Takedown notice. With a torrent file, no one hosts the content, so they go after the users who actually download the file.
Also, copyright infringement has to be willful. I had no idea that Mickey Mouse image was there and I could easily prove in a court of law that I never intended to download it. You, on the other hand, would be the one in trouble, not DSLReports or anyone else who viewed it. |
|
hopeflickerCapitalism breeds greedPremium
join:2003-04-03
Long Beach, CA
kudos:1 | said by Matt:said by hopeflicker:said by ninjatutle:Now you're just talking out of your You are in denial. Have you ever watch a music video at Youtube? Have you ever watch a home made video with music in it? Have you ever watch a trailer there? if so, you too are a thief. And i'll assume you saw the mickey mouse image. YouTube hosts the material, not you. That is why THEY receive the DMCA Takedown notice. With a torrent file, no one hosts the content, so they go after the users who actually download the file. Also, copyright infringement has to be willful. I had no idea that Mickey Mouse image was there and I could easily prove in a court of law that I never intended to download it. You, on the other hand, would be the one in trouble, not DSLReports or anyone else who viewed it. yes, youtube does host, but once you visit the site you are downloading copyright material. Yes, you are not intentionally doing it but you are. And you definitely are if you watch the videos.
If Justin fails to remove the image, then yes, DSLr is hosting pirated content.
My point: Copyrighted content is everywhere on the net, it's in your IM's, your email, your favorite forum/blog etc.
Where do you draw the line if you are talking sides with the **AA's?
You say im a thief if i download the DVD screener of the new Batman but you have no problem if i download a Mickey Mouse png file.
Where does it end?
--
There is no love untouched by hate
No unity without discord
There is no courage without fear
There is no peace without a war
There is no wisdom without regret
No admiration without scorn
|
|
