  bjl Premium join:2002-05-02 Newport Beach, CA
| reply to Kristopher Re: [game] Crazy Game 4 - Day 5
said by Kristopher :I was going to say, "or the mafia"; since they would know how many of them there are vs the remainder. I don't know everything. Yet.... The mafia may or may not know, depends on if there is more than 1 mafia group. -- flickr gallery | photo blog (rarely updated) | play mafia! |
|
  Antonica Premium join:2002-09-02 clubs:
| I'm still betting there is 2, just from the way everthing has been said since day 1. I wanna hear what Zan has to say, but everything I keep reading, can be seen in two very different ways, and so far there's no HARD proof pushing one way or the other, so I'm torn. If anything, I'll go back to my first instincts, since I was right about Jim. We'll see. |
|
  bjl Premium join:2002-05-02 Newport Beach, CA
| reply to Antonica Just looking at the events leading up to the Day 3 lynch attempt. Antonica seemed to already be 100% sure that Jim was scum, but switched her vote to BR for a fluff reason, not even considering the growing wagon on sansri (L-2 at the time of Antonica's vote switch).
»Re: [game] Crazy Game 4 - Day 3 »Re: [game] Crazy Game 4 - Day 3 -- flickr gallery | photo blog (rarely updated) | play mafia! |
|
  Antonica Premium join:2002-09-02 clubs: | Yeah, cause no one was listening to me :P |
|
  Archivis Your Daddy Premium join:2001-11-26 Earth
·Verizon FIOS
| reply to drew Alright, here's my take on all of this. On my way to work, I was thinking that Paulg didn't sound legit (because nobody is a plain townie), but I certainly didn't expect the "hated zombie cult".
#1. It sounds like there is a cult and a mafia. #2. If Paulg is dead, is the cult dead? Read the role PM where he has followers. #3. Sansri could have possibly have been a Death Miller. "Mafia Goon"? Please. Where's his role PM at? Why is it he's the only one with a "generic role" in a Crazy Game. Chlen was a blocker, Jim was a sniper.
Just my thoughts. -- 'A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have.' -Thomas Jefferson -
|
|
  Archivis Your Daddy Premium join:2001-11-26 Earth | Oh and Zandra, who did you investigate? |
|
  bjl Premium join:2002-05-02 Newport Beach, CA
| reply to Antonica said by Antonica :Yeah, cause no one was listening to me :P That's not a good reason to change your vote. Why did you go with BR? |
|
  Antonica Premium join:2002-09-02 clubs:
| reply to Archivis Seems like the followers from the PM were just dead people... so I would assume no more followers? And if he did, they are already dead.
And yeah, so that would mean only 2 mafia left, and puts less doubt in my theory. Ugh.
Jim just didn't squeeze and pull off all that by himself. If Zan and bjl weren't in on it, then I'm going to go back to Arch. He was definately off in the beginning, that's one thing others saw too :P.
But yeah something is up with BR too, just like I said with Arch, just seems different and I have no clue what, but just seems off. |
|
  Antonica Premium join:2002-09-02 clubs: | reply to bjl answered before asked. |
|
  bjl Premium join:2002-05-02 Newport Beach, CA
| reply to Archivis said by Archivis :Alright, here's my take on all of this. On my way to work, I was thinking that Paulg didn't sound legit (because nobody is a plain townie), but I certainly didn't expect the "hated zombie cult". #1. It sounds like there is a cult and a mafia. #2. If Paulg is dead, is the cult dead? Read the role PM where he has followers. #3. Sansri could have possibly have been a Death Miller. "Mafia Goon"? Please. Where's his role PM at? Why is it he's the only one with a "generic role" in a Crazy Game. Chlen was a blocker, Jim was a sniper. Just my thoughts. Did you read the FAQ about Paulg's role? There's no cult in the traditional mafia sense.
point #3 is interesting. I've not seen the death miller used, so I don't know how the mod would show the death. -- flickr gallery | photo blog (rarely updated) | play mafia! |
|
  bjl Premium join:2002-05-02 Newport Beach, CA | reply to Antonica said by Antonica :answered before asked. where? |
|
  Antonica Premium join:2002-09-02 clubs: | right after yours. I was posting in reponse to Arch before your post came up. |
|
  bjl Premium join:2002-05-02 Newport Beach, CA
| reply to Antonica said by Antonica :Jim just didn't squeeze and pull off all that by himself. If Zan and bjl weren't in on it, then I'm going to go back to Arch. He was definately off in the beginning, that's one thing others saw too :P. But yeah something is up with BR too, just like I said with Arch, just seems different and I have no clue what, but just seems off. great deflection, btw.  -- flickr gallery | photo blog (rarely updated) | play mafia! |
|
  Kristopher Premium join:2002-10-11 Middletown, PA
·Comcast
| reply to bjl This may be key. Sans may have been a death miller, or traitor, depending on what the mods wanted to let on. Interesting. Good catch for Archivis. Definitely something to consider. -- Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games |
|
  Antonica Premium join:2002-09-02 clubs:
| reply to bjl I could go into more detail, Lemme flip threw the thousands of posts :P.
But in a short shot, he keeps posting, but isn't providing any help to anyone. Doesn't want to make a decision, doesn't want to agree with anyone, doesn't want to offer up a solution or though. |
|
  Dezbend Premium,MVM join:2001-04-20
| reply to drew death miller or not doesn't really matter since we aren't sure on the number of mafia members. I admit is does seem likely as he had no special ability, but does that info help?
I guess, if he isn't really mafia, then people "supporting" him aren't necessarily mafia... -- DSLr Mafia Member. |
|
  Antonica Premium join:2002-09-02 clubs: | reply to bjl You wish  |
|
  Archivis Your Daddy Premium join:2001-11-26 Earth
·Verizon FIOS
| reply to bjl said by bjl :Did you read the FAQ about Paulg's role? There's no cult in the traditional mafia sense. point #3 is interesting. I've not seen the death miller used, so I don't know how the mod would show the death. I did, I was just trying to understand better, is all. They even set up a forum for him, so I'm just wondering what all his role allowed him to do.
I've never seen or even heard of a Death Miller until this game. Let me ask you though, if you were a mod, how would you display it? He had no role-PM. He was just "mafia goon". It doesn't mean he's clear. Hell, it doesn't matter if he's clear. It just means something doesn't sound right. -- 'A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have.' -Thomas Jefferson -
|
|
  Rook008 Miles To Go
join:2002-02-05 Far Rockaway, NY
·PHONE POWER
·RoadRunner Cable
| reply to drew There really wasn't a "Cult" in the way we usually have a Cult because Paulg Recruited dead Mafia, who couldn't post in the thread or Vote. So the Cult doesn't seem to be a problem to dwell on.
Something's not right about Sansri's Death scene. A plain Mafia Goon doesn't really fit into a Crazy game. -- "Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin to slit throats." - H. L. Mencken
|
|
  Rook008 Miles To Go
join:2002-02-05 Far Rockaway, NY | Based on what I posted at the end of Day 4, I'm going to...
Vote: Bigreds |
|