
how-to block ads
|
|
Share Topic  |
 |
|
|
 MattAll noise, no signal.Premium join:2003-07-20 Jamestown, NC kudos:12 | reply to ptrowski
Re: Key line.... said by ptrowski:"Of course while AT&T's problem might make Verizon seem like the ideal carrier, Verizon might have struggled with iPhone capacity demand as well." I think that is the biggest point of the article. I think that just about any of the big carriers would have struggled under the weight. Yes AT&T should have been more proactive but should have, could have, would have... I don't agree. The CDMA network is run by multiple carriers, so you're not limited to a single carrier who is responsible for all coverage. Add to that the fact that 3G has been deployed to a much larger area and the CDMA network as a whole in the US is just much more robust than AT&T's network. If an AT&T tower is full, you may roam onto a T-Mobile tower if there happens to be one near you, otherwise you just don't get service or get very poor service.
I don't think Verizon would have gotten off scot-free, I've seen some numbers peg the iPhone as 50% of all mobile web traffic, but I don't think they would have buckled so badly under the load as AT&T has. It's completely possible Verizon expected the load to be high and that factored into their decision to pass also. -- "What is conservatism? Is it not adherence to the old and tried, against the new and untried?" - Abraham Lincoln | |  dennismurphyPut me on hold? I'll put YOU on holdPremium join:2002-11-19 Parsippany, NJ Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
·Optimum Online
| said by Matt:I don't agree. The CDMA network is run by multiple carriers, so you're not limited to a single carrier who is responsible for all coverage. What are you talking about? Multiple carriers? Verizon Wireless owns & operates their entire network. Full stop. | |  MattAll noise, no signal.Premium join:2003-07-20 Jamestown, NC kudos:12 | said by dennismurphy:said by Matt:I don't agree. The CDMA network is run by multiple carriers, so you're not limited to a single carrier who is responsible for all coverage. What are you talking about? Multiple carriers? Verizon Wireless owns & operates their entire network. Full stop. Verizon, Sprint, Alltel, US Cellular, etc ... you can roam on all those networks. -- "What is conservatism? Is it not adherence to the old and tried, against the new and untried?" - Abraham Lincoln | |  Reviews:
·Acanac
| said by Matt:said by dennismurphy:said by Matt:I don't agree. The CDMA network is run by multiple carriers, so you're not limited to a single carrier who is responsible for all coverage. What are you talking about? Multiple carriers? Verizon Wireless owns & operates their entire network. Full stop. Verizon, Sprint, Alltel, US Cellular, etc ... you can roam on all those networks. Ya ok, so can an ATT customer roam on T-Mobile's network. But you are aware that as soon as you rooam on someone elses's network, extra charges apply, right ? It doesn't matter whether you roam on a CDMA network or an HSPA one, same principle applies.
Adi | |  | reply to Matt said by Matt:Verizon, Sprint, Alltel, US Cellular, etc... you can roam on all those networks. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think that only Verizon and Sprint have their own CDMA networks and Alltel and USC resell one of the above. -- Ask me no questions, and I'll tell you no lies... A MESSAGE to the RIAA and the MPAA: You shouldn't wound what you can't kill... | |  | reply to adisor19 There is no charge for roaming on att.
- A -- LETS GO METS! | | |
|  dennismurphyPut me on hold? I'll put YOU on holdPremium join:2002-11-19 Parsippany, NJ Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
·Optimum Online
| reply to Matt said by Matt:said by dennismurphy:said by Matt:I don't agree. The CDMA network is run by multiple carriers, so you're not limited to a single carrier who is responsible for all coverage. What are you talking about? Multiple carriers? Verizon Wireless owns & operates their entire network. Full stop. Verizon, Sprint, Alltel, US Cellular, etc ... you can roam on all those networks. Roaming agreements do not a single network make.
First and foremost, Verizon and Alltel merged ... they are now indeed one network there.
But as for Sprint, USCC and Verizon all playing together? Those are via roaming agreements. And those agreements change.
They often renegotiate those agreements. Sometimes roaming partners are added, sometimes they are dropped, and sometimes they change -- even in one region, but not another.
... and let's not forget the very small roaming partners that do still exist.
Anyone who's been around the wireless world for a long time will remember the most infamous one of all.... SUSSEX CELLULAR.
Don't assume that just because you have a CDMA phone that you can roam anywhere there is CDMA ... that's just not the case. | |  jmn1207Premium join:2000-07-19 Ashburn, VA | Sure, roaming agreement may change, but for right now, Verizon and Sprint are beating AT&T and T-Mobile when it comes to overall coverage because of these roaming agreements. This is not hypothetical. Every measurable test that I have found supports this claim. | |  Reviews:
·Acanac
| reply to FastiBook said by FastiBook:There is no charge for roaming on att. - A Sure there isn't. Keep roaming non stop on T-Mobile and see what happens with you account in a few months. You'll find that they will cancel it since it's costing them a lot in roaming fees so they're not making any $$ on you.
Adi | |  MattAll noise, no signal.Premium join:2003-07-20 Jamestown, NC kudos:12 1 edit | reply to jmn1207
 AT&T - Blue is 3G |  Verizon - Blue is 3G |
said by jmn1207:Sure, roaming agreement may change, but for right now, Verizon and Sprint are beating AT&T and T-Mobile when it comes to overall coverage because of these roaming agreements. This is not hypothetical. Every measurable test that I have found supports this claim. All one has to do is look at the difference in 3G coverage from the carrier's own website. -- "What is conservatism? Is it not adherence to the old and tried, against the new and untried?" - Abraham Lincoln | |  dennismurphyPut me on hold? I'll put YOU on holdPremium join:2002-11-19 Parsippany, NJ Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
·Optimum Online
| reply to jmn1207 said by jmn1207:Sure, roaming agreement may change, but for right now, Verizon and Sprint are beating AT&T and T-Mobile when it comes to overall coverage because of these roaming agreements. This is not hypothetical. Every measurable test that I have found supports this claim. I completely, totally, 100% agree. Verizon Wireless has the best coverage, nationwide, by far. On this, just about everyone agrees.
Verizon Wireless actually does very little roaming on Sprint's network. There's a few pockets of it, but for the most part, you're on the VZ network. | |  FBGuyyippee ki yayPremium join:2005-03-19 | reply to adisor19 and you think that they don't make the money back from t-mobile when their customers roam on their network? | |  NOVA_GuyObamaCare Kills AmericansPremium join:2002-03-05 | reply to adisor19 There is no charge for roaming on Sprint. (Of course, certain usage conditions apply.) | |  bemis join:2008-07-18 Reading, MA Reviews:
·Comcast
·Verizon FiOS
·Verizon Online DSL
| reply to Matt said by Matt All one has to do is look at the difference in 3G coverage from the carrier's own website. [/BQUOTE :...and now let's overlay a map of iPhone owners... Chances are pretty good that people in Wyoming are not buying mass qty's of iphones... and the ones who do probably would have as much chance buying on VZW as they did on ATT. The T's (AT& and -Mobile) have every major metro area covered w/ 3G ... it's 2G where not and frankly 9/10 times I'm using my iPhone it's on WiFi anyway. That said, yes, would be nice to have a VZW/Sprint option--I was w/ VZW until I got the iPhone and I am still w/ Sprint for my EVDO data service. | |  patcat88 join:2002-04-05 Jamaica, NY kudos:1 | reply to Matt said by Matt:Verizon, Sprint, Alltel, US Cellular, etc ... you can roam on all those networks. A. Verizon rarely if ever roams on Sprint. heres a list of never roam * MTA008B - Boston, MA-RI-VT-NH-ME * MTA001B - New York City, NY-NJ-PA-CT-VT * MTA009B - Philadelphia, PA-NJ-DE-MD * MTA002A - Los Angeles, CA-NV-AZ * MTA027B - Phoenix, AZ * MTA004A - San Francisco, CA-NV * MTA036B - Salt Lake City, UT-ID-WY-NV-OR * MTA022A - Denver, CO-WY-SD-NE-KS-UT * MTA007B - Dallas, TX-LA-AR-OK-NM * BTA027C - Austin, TX * MTA048B - Tulsa, OK-KS * MTA014D - Houston, TX-LA * BTA059A - Bryan-College Station, TX * BTA196E - Houston, TX * BTA238F - Lake Charles, LA * MTA044D - Knoxville, TN-VA-KY * BTA229E - Kingsport, TN-Johnson City, TN-Bristol, VA-TN * BTA295E - Middlesboro-Harlan, KY * MTA023D - Richmond, VA-NC * BTA324C - Norfolk-Virginia Beach-Newport News-Hampton, VA * BTA374C - Richmond-Petersburg, VA * MTA032B - Des Moines, IA-IL-MO-NE-SD-WI * MTA045B - Omaha, NE-IA-KS * MTA034A - Kansas City, MO-KS-OK * MTA019B - St. Louis, MO-IL-AR * MTA046B - Wichita, KS-OK * MTA015A - Miami, FL * MTA020A - Milwaukee, WI-MI-MN-IA * MTA003D - Chicago, IL-IN-OH-MI-WI * BTA071A - Champaign-Urbana, IL * BTA078E - Chicago, IL * BTA103E - Danville, IL * BTA225E - Kankakee, IL * BTA243E - La Salle-Peru-Ottawa-Streator, IL * BTA380A - Rockford, IL * MTA031A - Indianapolis, IN-IL * MTA035A - Buffalo, NY-PA * MTA005B - Detroit, MI-OH * MTA021A - Pittsburgh, PA-WV-OH * MTA016D - Cleveland, OH-PA * BTA084B - Cleveland-Akron, OH * MTA010A - Washington, DC-MD-VA-WV-PA ******************** * MTA018D - Cincinnati, OH-WV-VA-KY-IN * BTA035E - Beckley, WV * BTA048E - Bluefield, WV * BTA073E - Charleston, WV * BTA081C - Cincinnati, OH * BTA106C - Dayton-Springfield, OH * BTA197E - Huntington, WV-Ashland, KY * BTA259E - Logan, WV * BTA359E - Portsmouth, OH * BTA474E - Williamson, WV-Pikeville, KY ********************** * MTA038D - Columbus, OH-WV * MTA038E - Columbus, OH-WV * BTA095C - Columbus, OH ******************** * MTA011D - Atlanta, GA-SC-AL-TN * MTA039D - El Paso, TX-NM-AZ-UT-CO * BTA008B - Albuquerque, NM * BTA022A - Athens, GA * BTA024A - Atlanta, GA * BTA128E - El Paso, TX * BTA139B - Farmington, NM-Durango, CO * BTA162E - Gallup, NM * BTA244C - Las Cruces, NM * BTA386F - Roswell, NM * BTA407B - Santa Fe, NM *********************** * MTA006D - Charlotte, NC-SC-GA * BTA074A - Charlotte-Gastonia, NC * BTA141A - Fayetteville-Lumberton, NC * BTA174A - Greensboro--Winston-Salem--High Point, NC * BTA174C - Greensboro--Winston-Salem--High Point, NC * BTA368A - Raleigh-Durham, NC
Verizon does roam onto Sprint in the following * MTA030B - Portland, OR-WA-CA * MTA024B - Seattle, WA * BTA413C - Seattle-Tacoma, WA * MTA042B - Spokane, WA-OR-ID-MT-WY * MTA041B - Oklahoma City, OK * MTA017A - New Orleans, LA-MS-AL-FL * MTA033A - San Antonio, TX * BTA268C - McAllen, TX * MTA040B - Little Rock, AR-OK * MTA037D - Jacksonville, FL-GA * BTA159A - Gainesville, FL * BTA212A - Jacksonville, FL * BTA439A - Tallahassee, FL * MTA013D - Tampa, FL * BTA107A - Daytona Beach, FL * BTA239C - Lakeland-Winter Haven, FL * BTA289C - Melbourne-Titusville, FL * BTA336A - Orlando, FL * BTA336C - Orlando, FL * BTA408A - Sarasota-Bradenton, FL * BTA440A - Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater, FL * MTA026B - Louisville, KY-IL-IN
I left out some minor or duplicate areas. This list was hand made, errors exist I'm sure.
sources: »www.howardforums.com/archive/top···8-1.html »www.roamingzone.com/prl/prl_51248.shtml
But in general, Verizon almost NEVER in-market roams onto Sprint unless Verizon is a PCS/1900 only in that area (Florida was the most famous VZ-PCS only example (East Florida both 800s belong to AT&T, West Florida, one 800 belongs to Alltel (now VZW), the other belongs to AT&T).
Not to mention, to "roam" off your carrier, means having "no service" with your carrier. So if Verizon has 0 (with service) or 1 bar, the Verizon phone will not switch to Sprint or US Cellular even if Sprint or US Cellular has 5 bars at that location. Have fun with your phone never ringing or no sound when you answer it, then a drop a few seconds later.
I'm less experienced with GSM, but GSM roaming is by tower by tower (no concept of cellular area codes (AMPS/TDMA/CDMA SID/NID system)), the roam carrier's tower asks the home carrier if its OK to permit your GSM phone on such and such located roam carrier tower, home carrier can say no roam, and then your phone says no service, or returns to the home carrier tower. AT&T rarely if ever roams onto Tmobile, Tmobile roams onto AT&T only in very rural areas, forcing roaming doesn't ever work, the roam tower will reject your phone based on instructions from your home carrier when your phone attempts to log on. | |  patcat88 join:2002-04-05 Jamaica, NY kudos:1 | reply to dennismurphy said by dennismurphy:Anyone who's been around the wireless world for a long time will remember the most infamous one of all.... SUSSEX CELLULAR. Sussex Cellular, the cellphone provider run by a guy with his pickup 
All profit, if any, goes towards beer. No capital investment since 1986. | |  | reply to adisor19 Not sure what you mean exactly, but my plan has free unlimited roaming.
- A -- LETS GO METS! | |  | reply to dennismurphy "Oh" really here check this out.
Network: Robust Network and Security A Better Network Means Better Business The AT&T Network The AT&T Network covers over 300 million people and is growing, creating a solid platform to deliver services and solutions. For mobility it offers the nation's fastest 3G network and with the deployment of 7.2Mbps markets, the nation's fastest network is getting faster!
Our network is built on the worldwide GSM standardthe most widely deployed network standard in the world with 89% share, or over 3.6 billion subscribers worldwide. GSM provides:
Economies of scalewider range and lower cost of solutions and devices Global compatibilitymore international roaming potential Ease of integration with emerging/new standards like LTE (Long Term Evolution) AT&T is spending over 19 billion dollars in 2009, 5 billion each year for the past five years on the mobility network. Here's what AT&T is doing to improve voice and data communication for 2009:
Nearly 2,000 additional 3G cell sites Over 20 new major metro markets for 3G Announcement of 6 major markets for faster 3G speeds/7.2Mbps, including: Charlotte, Chicago, Dallas, Houston, and Los Angeles and Miami A national deployment of 850MHz spectrum for 3G to provide improved in-building penetration and overall improved coverage Plans to test and deploy the next generation of wireless standardsLTE (Long Term Evolution) promising faster speeds, but still in the GSM standards as our 2G and 3G technology
Fastest 3G in the Nation Built on the global standard for wireless, the AT&T 3G network delivers the high speed and coverage your business needs to keep work flowing when you're on the road. High Speed Packet Access (HSPA) provides for fast speed for our mobility customers over earlier 3G/UMTS releases. Using 7.2Mbps, customers with capable LaptopConnect products or phones, like the iPhone 3G S, can experience the 7.2 speeds in coverage areas.
With the enhanced 3G network, you'll enjoy even better mobile broadband access to email, Internet and other applications.
Available in most major metropolitan areas, providing typical download speeds of 700 Kbps to 1.7 Mbps and typical upload speeds of 500 Kbps to 1.2 Mbps on compatible devices for our current 3G network* Additional faster speeds available for 7.2 capable devices, depending on network conditions and availability** The only 3G technology that supports simultaneous voice and data with one device - your work doesn't stop when you need to talk Wireless service is available in select metropolitan markets Supported by AT&T Communication Manager software for LaptopConnect products
Wi-Fi another option for wireless users AT&T has the largest Wi-Fi network managed directly by a national wireless carrier. We offer over 25,000 U.S. hotspots at no additional charge to your AT&T data plan***; including locations such as: Starbucks stores, Barnes and Noble stores, airports and participating McDonalds restaurants. AT&T mobility data plan subscribers can easily switch to Wi-Fi through AT&T Connection Manager software, designed for LaptopConnect and enjoy the advantages of being connected while enjoying a cup of coffee or waiting for a flight.
In addition, AT&T offers 100,000 Wi-Fi locations in over 75 countries that can be accessed. Additional data charges may apply.
Enhanced Security and Connectivity Options Whether wireless or wired, network security is a primary concern for businesses. Today's increasingly sophisticated security threats make implementing superior wireless security even more of a necessity. Network-to-network connectivity provides performance, security and reliability necessary to enable wireless applications. AT&T provides you with a range of connectivity options and can assist in designing an end-to-end security solution. For more information visit »developer.att.com.
Check out our Business Center to see all that AT&T can offer your business.
Speed and uninterrupted use of the service are not guaranteed. Coverage not available everywherevisit the AT&T coverage viewer for details. Service defaults to national EDGE/GPRS network, where available, if AT&T 3G network is not available.
*Referenced speeds require an HSDPA 3.6Mbps/HSUPA capable device with Receive Diversity and/or Equalizer. AT&T is deploying HSUPA throughout the 3G footprint, HSUPA may not currently be available in all 3G areas. BroadbandConnect speed claims based on our network tests without compression using 3MB data files for download and 2MB data files for upload. 3G devices not enabled with HSUPA support typical upload speeds of 220-320Kbps based on our network tests without compression using 500KB data files for upload. Actual throughput speed varies.
**7.2Mbps speeds have yet to be evaluated.
***Some data plans may not include free access to the AT&T Wi-Fi hotspot network. | |  dddane join:2002-01-10 Chicago, IL 1 edit | reply to adisor19 said by adisor19:Ya ok, so can an ATT customer roam on T-Mobile's network. that's only true in certain markets... they can control roaming and lock you out of it. i've been an ATT customer for 8 years and have never been able to roam on t-mobile... and i've had probably 12 different model phones (mostly various blackberry devices). and i travel prett etxensively | |  AVDRespice, Adspice, ProspicePremium join:2003-02-06 Onion, NJ | reply to adisor19 said by adisor19:Ya ok, so can an ATT customer roam on T-Mobile's network. What T-Mobile network??? -- standard disclaimers apply. | |
|