how-to block ads
|
|
Uniqs:
123 |
Share Topic
 |
 |
|
|
| Why do they have to block services? Instead of blocking individual services or using some kind of deep packet inspection, is it not possible to limit hard users by their static physical addresses (MAC in the networking world)?
This is done all the time on line/wireless internet networks, and I don't think people will complain. Give people burstable traffic for quick downloads/uploads, but after some threshold start to throttle all network traffic from/to the device. Network abuse can be logged, and after repeated incidents boot the client off your service.
Maybe I'm not on the right path, seeing that as you pass from tower to tower, the rules would have to remain in place, but there has got to be some easy solution to the problem in my humble opinion. | | |
|
 george357ius ad arma spondent libertasPremium
join:2009-09-18
Hot Springs, NC
kudos:1
 ·Frontier Communi..
 ·HughesNet Satell..
·Dish Network
 ·Verizon Wireless..
| How can throttling be justified? I am currently a HughesNet subscriber and I am limited to 425mb in a given 24hr period. I am paying for 1.6mbps down, I knew Hughes had these limits when I signed up but they are my only option for decent speed. When someone is paying for a certian download speed they should have the capability of having that speed 24/7/365 it is what we are paying for! Its one thing when you know at the start its going to be limited but after you are already sibscribed then that is pretty close to bait&Switch if you ask me. Pay for Xmbps download speed get X download speed at all times, No limits at no time!!!
George
--
Spaceway III HN 9000 Pro+ Plan 1.6 Mbps Down. Acer 5000 series laptop w/AMD 64 bit Turion 1.6ghz, 1gb Ram, 90gb HD. Windows XP SP3, Ubuntu 7.10 Dual OS. FireFox 3.5 | |
| You have an easy solution. Buy a T1 if no other service is available, and getting the exact speed is that important to you. I have never heard of an ISP rate limiting on a business class connection such as a T1, DS3, OC3, etc... If the price is too high, than obviously it's not that important to you.
I hate to say it, but on wireless networks there is a need for throttling. IE theoretically max for 2.4MHz is 54Mbs, on 900MHz your limited to about 5Mbs. (these may be wrong, as you can use OFDM and other protocols to increase rates, and I don't know them all) But in any case these are physical limits in reality your only going 1/2 duplex (I don't know any phones with MIMO yet) so you'll need to half the speed and subtract some for lost packets, retransmissions, timings, etc. Divide that by the number of customers on a tower and you'll get what's available to each customer (in reality it's more of the law of averages). I don't know the exact frequencies they use, but you see the point. IMHO it's better to throttle bandwidth hogs, than to crash the tower so that no one can get service. | |
|
