|
to WeSRT4
Re: Not a right.Are you kidding me? You're saying in this country we should have to go through the difficult process of selling a home and finding another in an area where broadband is available if we want it? What a crock of $hit. |
|
wifi4milezBig Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace join:2004-08-07 New York, NY
2 recommendations |
said by matrix3D:Are you kidding me? You're saying in this country we should have to go through the difficult process of selling a home and finding another in an area where broadband is available if we want it? Yes, just as you would need to do the same if you wanted waterfront property, better schools, more convenient transportation options, proximity to grocery stores, sports stadiums, and the millions of other things people move for....... |
|
1 recommendation |
said by wifi4milez:said by matrix3D:Are you kidding me? You're saying in this country we should have to go through the difficult process of selling a home and finding another in an area where broadband is available if we want it? Yes, just as you would need to do the same if you wanted waterfront property, better schools, more convenient transportation options, proximity to grocery stores, sports stadiums, and the millions of other things people move for....... Or electricity... Oh wait. |
|
woody7 Premium Member join:2000-10-13 Torrance, CA |
to wifi4milez
And then have your kids bussed to make some school somewhere more integrated...... |
|
jjeffeoryjjeffeory join:2002-12-04 Bloomington, IN |
to wifi4milez
Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity...
Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. |
|
wifi4milezBig Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace join:2004-08-07 New York, NY |
said by jjeffeory:Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity... Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. Electricity and water are both utilities, broadband isnt. You have no more right to demand broadband be available (at a new house) than you have a right to demand a free Rolls Royce be in the driveway. |
|
jjeffeoryjjeffeory join:2002-12-04 Bloomington, IN |
Well there you go. Broadband should be a utility as well, which is my point.
Maybe in Finland, electricity and water are rights? |
|
|
tobyTroy Mcclure join:2001-11-13 Seattle, WA |
to jjeffeory
said by jjeffeory:Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity... Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. 90% of people in rural areas have wells for their water. Some do not have electricity, generate it themselves. If you want broadband, move. |
|
jjeffeoryjjeffeory join:2002-12-04 Bloomington, IN |
said by toby:said by jjeffeory:Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity... Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. 90% of people in rural areas have wells for their water. Some do not have electricity, generate it themselves. If you want broadband, move. 90%? I grew up in rural areas. Most everyone had electricity. Some of them had to pay for their own meter and poles, but the electric company was required to provide it. *Most* had running water. Yes, some had wells, but they had running water for the most part. That was a looooong time ago, though. I even knew people who had and used outhouses. Guess what? All of them now have electricity, running water, and indoor plumbing. I'm talking rural, you're talking BFE. There's a difference... |
|
Noah VailOh God please no. Premium Member join:2004-12-10 SouthAmerica 1 edit |
to wifi4milez
said by wifi4milez:Electricity and water are both utilities, broadband isnt. AFaIK, Electric and Water are utilities because someone declared them to be so. You need running water to keep a modern home sanitary. I don't think electricity is as much a health issue (medical issues excepting). I can't say why they are equated, except for political expediency. I imagine that having something exist because you say it does is an tenant of the 'Broadband is a Right' crowd. So using the utility method to entitlement is kind of a dream approach to getting what they want. They just speak their thought and *poof*! Reality is altered and Broadband now has the same social value as not being imprisoned without cause. NV edit:received notice from dept of redundancy dept. |
|
Duramax08To The Moon Premium Member join:2008-08-03 San Antonio, TX |
to toby
Im a mile away from TWC. I would rather pay them to bring their lines down to serve about 40+ houses rather then moving. They tell me my area is not ready for broadband. Till AT&T allows tethering to my iPhone or that old lady that owns acres of land dies (she gots a living will where when she dies, Developers will start building houses. Till then, she can live there), I will continue using the only reliable connection I got. Got to love that 33.6 kbps dial up. |
|
Noah VailOh God please no. Premium Member join:2004-12-10 SouthAmerica |
to jjeffeory
said by jjeffeory:90%? I grew up in rural areas. *Most* had running water. Yes, some had wells, but they had running water for the most part. That was a looooong time ago, though. I even knew people who had and used outhouses. Guess what? All of them now have electricity, running water, and indoor plumbing. My rural area didn't get city water until about 1990. This was in Fairfax County, which is right next to Washington DC. It wasn't exactly in the middle of nowhere. We had some folks without electricity and quite a few more with outhouses, including my best friend. Anyway... NV |
|
wifi4milezBig Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace join:2004-08-07 New York, NY |
to jjeffeory
said by jjeffeory:Well there you go. Broadband should be a utility as well, which is my point. Then you are entitled to move to a country (such as Finland) that regulates it as such if you feel so inclined. |
|
|
to wifi4milez
said by wifi4milez:said by jjeffeory:Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity... Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. Electricity and water are both utilities, broadband isnt. You have no more right to demand broadband be available (at a new house) than you have a right to demand a free Rolls Royce be in the driveway. Cable is a utility, so is telephone. At least that's how it's defined in my state. Why? They are regulated by the public utilities commission. |
|
Jim Kirk Premium Member join:2005-12-09 49985 |
to wifi4milez
Is that where Big Russ went? |
|
jjeffeoryjjeffeory join:2002-12-04 Bloomington, IN |
to wifi4milez
said by wifi4milez:said by jjeffeory:Well there you go. Broadband should be a utility as well, which is my point. Then you are entitled to move to a country (such as Finland) that regulates it as such if you feel so inclined. Believe me, I'm seriously thinking about it. 8-) Nah, I'll just what until it becomes one. Who are you to tell me where to go? 8-) |
|
jjeffeory
1 recommendation |
to wifi4milez
I have a right to demand whatever I want. It doesn't mean I'm going to get it, but if I have friends in the right places, I can get it done.
Frankly, just because broadband isn't classified as a utility yet doesn't mean that people shouldn't push for it to be classified as one. It's useful and very, very necessary in this day and age. Eventually, it will be considered one. Why the big push to make it NOT what it so obviously is? Are you an ISP? I forget! |
|
jjeffeory |
to Noah Vail
Progress is great! You can now get Fios over there. In DC, we still have to wait... |
|
Noah VailOh God please no. Premium Member join:2004-12-10 SouthAmerica 1 edit |
said by jjeffeory:Progress is great! You can now get Fios over there. In DC, we still have to wait... I'll have to take your word on it. I haven't been to Lorton since 1994. I drove by it once, in 2005. However, I've opted to remember it like it was, and didn't have the will to stop and visit. NV |
|
88615298 (banned) join:2004-07-28 West Tenness |
to wifi4milez
said by wifi4milez:said by jjeffeory:Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity... Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. Electricity and water are both utilities, broadband isnt. You have no more right to demand broadband be available (at a new house) than you have a right to demand a free Rolls Royce be in the driveway. You think so narrowly and in the past. We're approaching the end of the first decade of the 21st century so get with the program. Electricity and phone service were once considered "luxuries". Things change. If you think it's a luxury then do without it for a year and come back and tell us how that went but you won't because you NEED the internet. So please stop being hypocritical. |
|
Duramax08To The Moon Premium Member join:2008-08-03 San Antonio, TX |
+1
1 free internets for you. |
|
jjeffeoryjjeffeory join:2002-12-04 Bloomington, IN |
to Noah Vail
I haven't been there too recently, but I know there are tons of cable, fiber, and power lines that have gone up in Fairfax County. |
|
wifi4milezBig Russ, 1918 to 2008. Rest in Peace join:2004-08-07 New York, NY |
to 88615298
said by 88615298:said by wifi4milez:said by jjeffeory:Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity... Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. Electricity and water are both utilities, broadband isnt. You have no more right to demand broadband be available (at a new house) than you have a right to demand a free Rolls Royce be in the driveway. You think so narrowly and in the past. We're approaching the end of the first decade of the 21st century so get with the program. Electricity and phone service were once considered "luxuries". Things change. If you think it's a luxury then do without it for a year and come back and tell us how that went but you won't because you NEED the internet. So please stop being hypocritical. I never said broadband access wasnt a necessity for me. However, I would never consider moving somewhere it wasnt offered so its a moot point. I wouldnt move to a place that didnt have a lot of things I need, and everyone has different priorities. On the other hand, nobody can justify demanding broadband be available everywhere either. I like the Adirondacks, however there are places there that dont have cell phone access or broadband. If I CHOOSE to go there its my choice, if I choose to stay in NYC thats also my choice. |
|
jjeffeoryjjeffeory join:2002-12-04 Bloomington, IN 1 edit |
Well, everywhere doesn't really mean everywhere either... You don't think that there's going to be broadband "everywhere" ( sort of reminds me of unlimited meaning 5GB cap, pretty funny) in Finland do you? I'm sure there would need to be at least *some* population density or some fiber going along a road. I mean, if there's a road, there is at least power and phone lines.
It's really dangerous to speak in terms of absolutes and *rights* in the first place. I'm really not trying to be difficult with you. I simply believe that if you live in even a rural "town" or population center, then you should be able to have electricity, water, phone, and broadband. They are modern necessities. They are utilities. It's more difficult to do out West than somewhere like the East coast. |
|
Duramax08To The Moon Premium Member join:2008-08-03 San Antonio, TX |
Duramax08
Premium Member
2009-Oct-14 10:06 pm
said by jjeffeory:Well, everywhere doesn't really mean everywhere either... You don't think that there's going to be broadband "everywhere" ( sort of reminds me of unlimited meaning 5GB cap, pretty funny) in Finland do you? I'm sure there would need to be at least *some* population density or some fiber going along a road. I mean, if there's a road, there is at least power and phone lines. It's really dangerous to speak in terms of absolutes and *rights* in the first place. I'm really not trying to be difficult with you. I simply believe that if you live in even a rural "town" or population center, then you should be able to have electricity, water, phone, and broadband. They are modern necessities. They are utilities. It's more difficult to do out West than somewhere like the East coast. I agree, they are utilities even if you dont think they are. One of the first things people do (at least the more modern people), they call for broadband. If broadband is one of the things you activate when you move into a house, It should be considered a utility. Thats just my opinion. |
|
88615298 (banned) join:2004-07-28 West Tenness |
to toby
said by toby:said by jjeffeory:Yes, just like you have to worry about having running water or electricity... Oh wait, you DON'T generally have to worry about those things when buying a home. Hmmmmmmmmm. 90% of people in rural areas have wells for their water. Some do not have electricity, generate it themselves. If you want broadband, move. yes and if all the people in rural areas took your advice you city folk would have a HUGE increase in population and then your taxes would have to go up for all the infrastructure improvements needed to support a increased population. Is that what you wanted? Um no. So before you go off giving stupid advice try thinking it all the way through to the PROPER conclusion. |
|
shimonmor Premium Member join:2000-12-30 Sedro Woolley, WA
1 recommendation |
to jjeffeory
said by jjeffeory:I'm talking rural, you're talking BFE. There's a difference... Around here, if you don't live in city limits then you are on well water. Plus there are lots of people who don't have electricity provided for them; they have their own generators (I have a gen...but just as back-up since we lose power a lot). You don't have to live in BFE to lack "utilities". Many rural areas are this way and many people want it that way. I have my own well so I don't have to worry about what's dumped into the water at the treatment plants or worry about fluoridation. Broadband, in my opinion, should not be a utility. If you really want it you can get it. If you really need it, you can get it. Too many people in this country think they have all sorts of rights. They feel the government owes them something. They feel entitled. Oh well. |
|
jjeffeoryjjeffeory join:2002-12-04 Bloomington, IN 1 edit |
Good points. I'm certainly not for big government, but I believe that if you've got the other utilities, broadband is as useful and necessary as the others in the 21st century. I see you're near Canada. I'm not surprised about the Well situation. That's still running water ( with sump pump, of course). I had a well on my property in La as well as city water. It's all running water... Electricity is a different matter. That should be available most everywhere. Telephone should also be most common in most places. |
|
|
to wifi4milez
If Finland wants to declare broadband a right that is their right, so what do you care? |
|
Noah VailOh God please no. Premium Member join:2004-12-10 SouthAmerica 1 edit |
said by Mikey12 :
If Finland wants to declare broadband a right that is their right, so what do you care? He has a right to care. So why are you questioning his right? NV |
|
|