site Search:


 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery






how-to block ads


 
Search Topic:
Share Topic
Post a:
Post a:
AuthorAll Replies


skuv

@rr.com

reply to Anonymous_

Re: one of the requirements should be via fiber optic cable only

said by Anonymous_:

one of the requirements should be via fiber optic cable(to the house) only as D3 is just a shared hub and is slow should not count
A fiber optic cable isn't a direct connection to the Internet either, so it is shared at some point on the ISP's network before it gets to the Internet. Show me an ISP that has every residential connection connected directly back to their peering router with no aggregation points in between, and I'll show you a company that doesn't exist, is out of business, or will soon be out of business.

And fiber optic cable doesn't have any guarantee on the speed. The speed comes from the technology. I know plenty of fiber connections that are 10mbit. So just requiring that it be fiber optic doesn't solve anything. Especially when technology is available that makes coax and twisted pair copper go much faster than 100mbit.

10gigabitethernet over copper is available today, would you call that inferior to 10gigabitethernet over fiber just because it is using copper?


joebarnhart
Paxio evangelist

join:2005-12-15
Santa Clara, CA

said by skuv :

A fiber optic cable isn't a direct connection to the Internet either, so it is shared at some point on the ISP's network before it gets to the Internet. Show me an ISP that has every residential connection connected directly back to their peering router with no aggregation points in between,
The internet itself is "shared" by your definition. It isn't important where the switches are located, as long as the provider has adequate bandwidth to pass the aggregate traffic.

My provider, Paxio, offers speeds up to 1Gbps symmetric, and they guarantee you are not impacted by other users on their network. I have the 100M symmetric service and I have never seen any slowdown due to traffic on Paxio's network.

Paxio happens to use fiber to the home, but I agree that twisted pair or coax is perfectly acceptable for 100M users. I would point out, however, that fiber is inherently more "future proof" as WDM and other technologies currently push greater than 14Gbps on a single fiber today.

Saturday, 02-Jun 10:20:36 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.
Most commented news this week
Hot Topics