site Search:


 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery






how-to block ads


 
Search Topic:
Uniqs:
11348
Share Topic
Posting?
Post a:
Post a:
Links: ·WISP Forum FAQ ·WISP Directory ·Radio Mobile
page: 1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · 6 · 7
AuthorAll Replies


Rhaas
Premium
join:2005-12-19
Bernie, MO

Lightning damage pics

Click for full size
Conduit coming into main panel - Next size KO is burned out completely and conduit is loose
Click for full size
Conduit entering bottom of main panel
Click for full size
Conduit entering side of main panel
Click for full size
4/0 coming into building - 4/0 is connected to chemical rod, bare copper runs up wall to apparent suppression unit
Click for full size
Where bare copper touched electrical conduit
Click for full size
Where bare copper touched electrical conduit
Click for full size
Conduit entering a sub panel
Click for full size
Conduit entering top of Main panel - same conduit as first picture
Click for full size
Conduit entering Sub Panel
Click for full size
Scorch marks on panel cover
Click for full size
Arc marks on inside of box
Click for full size
Suppressor?
Click for full size
Outlets where their equipment was plugged in
Click for full size
Conduit entering side of heater
Click for full size
Conduit entering side of main panel
Click for full size
Conduit entering bottom of mail panel
Click for full size
Conduits entering bottom of Main panel
Click for full size
Meter base and #8 bare copper running to 3/8" ground rod
Click for full size
Ground rod for Electrical service, phone nid is bonded here as well. To the right is the 4/0 enteringthe building.
Click for full size
One of the connections they left behind
To go along with the other thread, it just so happens our 'new' tower site has it's share of issues. You can read a little about it from a previous post: »[Tech Ops] New (to me) tower - Questions inside

I have a pretty good idea of 3 major flaws in the grounding/bonding of this site. I'll let the pictures do the talking as I believe they exacerbate one key flaw at this site.

So anyone care to take a stab as to what is wrong with this site? One of the flaws Splitpair mentioned more or less in a passing statement in the other thread.


davidg
Good Bye My Friend
Premium,MVM
join:2002-06-15
none

multiple isolated ground rods creating potential, the conduit connections were not tight nor were they properly bonded.
--
Lack of Preparation on YOUR Part does NOT Constitute an Emergency on Mine!



AMD Phreak
OSHA Safety Nazi
Premium
join:2003-12-14

reply to Rhaas
Holy hell.

Lack of single point bonding.

I can preach this all day long, bond, bond, bond.

A lot of good that fancy chemical rod is doing. You may (hard to say) have a low impedance ground there, but if everything is not bonded correctly you'll get what you see here. I have seen it first hand personally, and now others can see it as well.

EPIC FAIL.

Rhaas, you need to bond the hell out of everything. I bet the site is built using set-screw conduit couplers? If so you need to use #6 to bond EACH side of that conduit as it passes in and out of the coupler, conduits running into 4-square boxes, etc bonded before they enter the box somewhere, that electrical cabinet needs bonded, and you need to get a better utility feed SPD, again, bonded.

This all gets bonded to an internal building halo, that runs around the room, the halo is not continuous, rather, separated by a foot at the furthest point AWAY from the MGB....

There are also special methods used to route the bonding conductors.... Everything must flow back to the MGB.

ALL bonding connectors must be done using irreversible high compression crimps (CTAPS and lugs) and UL Listed conduit clamps (harger sells them).

Compression type conduit connectors and couplers are not required to be bonded across, just need to bond the main panel(s), in your case, this is NOT the case.

Also need to install an MGB, EGB, and TGB. Bond it all together, bond to the chemical rod.

Drive galvanized rods at each guy anchor, bond the guys down to the galv rod using TINNED (not bare CU) solid #2 and use only tinned split bolt hardware.

Install a building ground ring and bond that to the tower ground system, I'd need to know building dimensions to tell you how many rods to drive... It'd be better if I knew soil resistivity factors and then I could just calculate you how many rods will be required to get down to 5Ohms or less for the entire system....

Get someone to measure that chemical rod as well using the three-point fall of potential method. And I would still look into installing odd-angle radials, to help drag the strike away from the tower.

If we had this site presented to us, it would probably cost you are looking at around maybe $15,000 to $18,000 in labor close to that in parts.... Factor maybe $25,000, and even then I can't tell you if that is a good solid number.
--
"No job is so important, and no service is so urgent that we cannot take the time to perform our work safely."
-- AT&T, Your World, Destroyed.
--Safety One Tower Rescue Certified
--LLigetfa:"Wimax is like teenage sex. Everyone talks about doing it."



AMD Phreak
OSHA Safety Nazi
Premium
join:2003-12-14

reply to Rhaas
Oh yeah that wall heater above the one sitting on the floor, bond that too....



davidg
Good Bye My Friend
Premium,MVM
join:2002-06-15
none

said by AMD Phreak:

Oh yeah that wall heater above the one sitting on the floor, bond that too....
to add to that if it is metal in/on/near the building it needs a bond. one failure on a list i saw recently was a feaking FILE CABINET not bonded!
--
Lack of Preparation on YOUR Part does NOT Constitute an Emergency on Mine!

nevtxjustin

join:2006-04-18
Dallas, TX

said by davidg:

feaking FILE CABINET not bonded!
Stick some rack mounts in it and instant dust proof rack.


AMD Phreak
OSHA Safety Nazi
Premium
join:2003-12-14

reply to davidg
Yep. If it conducts, bond it.

Imagine "Emperor Palpatine style lighting bolts out the fingers" type of incident.

"I bonded everything in the site but somehow i have huge scorch marks on the file cabinet and everything across from the cabinet!"

*cue high-voltage transmission line humming sound*


--
"No job is so important, and no service is so urgent that we cannot take the time to perform our work safely."
-- AT&T, Your World, Destroyed.
--Safety One Tower Rescue Certified
--LLigetfa:"Wimax is like teenage sex. Everyone talks about doing it."



Rhaas
Premium
join:2005-12-19
Bernie, MO

The multiple ground rods and the grounds not being bonded/single point ground system were the two that jumped out at me quick. There are two chem rods at this site and we tried to check to see if the rods were bonded using our cable locator but since we are unable to disconnect from the chem rods we couldn't trace a thing. I hate the idea of disturbing the rods as they are obviously matured.

Heaters and AC are blown, I'll probably strip out the heaters anyway (there are two units in the building).

We talked about the compression/set screw connectors at AF. Going back through when we had our CO's inspected to RUS standards - they call for an airgap on any metalic conduit entering the main panel ie conduits are not to be bonded to the main panel but to the ground window.

Building is maybe 6'x8' or 6'x6'. Soil composition is SAND. The building & tower sit on a slight rise so I plan on using that to my advantage on installing radials ie run the radials downhill rather than uphill.

The thing that Splitpair mentioned in passing is that you'd be surprised as to what becomes conductive during a lightning strike - All those metal boxes bolted directly to the cinderblock is a no-no.

Probably the first thing I plan on doing - as much as I hate it - is to dig up around one of the chem rods and determine if they are bonded together or not. The rods IMO are too close together - maybe 15' apart.

Given the layout and the fact that the tower is ~5' from the building I will likely use a single ring to encompas both the tower and building, If I try to put seperate rings they will be too close together. I will drop probably three radials N, S and W, to the East is a gentle rise also the end of the property.

I will pop in a MGB inside the building and set two other bars, one at the base of the tower for the cables and one just inside where the cable enters the building for the suppressors.

Haven't really though about a halo too much, just due to the size of the building. By the time i get a rack and cable tray in there I more or less will have a pseudo halo anyway. The only other thing for sure that I need to bond is the metal doorway.

Oh and our cabinets in the CO's are bonded to the MGB



Rhaas
Premium
join:2005-12-19
Bernie, MO

Click for full size
Click for full size
Click for full size
Cabinet being installed.... for 6 months.. Hey it's there anyway
Click for full size
Some damage from last nights storm to the dms10
Click for full size
Front of card
Click for full size
Line card


nunya
Who is John Galt?
Premium,MVM
join:2000-12-23
O Fallon, MO
kudos:5
Reviews:
·Charter
·voip.ms

reply to Rhaas
PISS....POOR....Bonding and grounding. WOW!

Need me to come down there and fix it for ya?

Any conduit entering through an eccentric or concentric knockout hole should be independently bonded. The best way is a bonding bushing for a site like this.
--
Looks like Reverend Wright got his wish - God Damn America.
Nancy Pelosi - House Minority Leader 2010
Harry Reid - Senate Minority Leader 2010


LLigetfa

join:2006-05-15
Fort Frances, ON
kudos:1

reply to Rhaas
A lot of installers don't like those multiple size knockouts and won't use them. They prefer to drill or punch their own holes.

While the knockout provides a poor ground path, they should not be relied upon for good grounding. The reason many installers don't use the knockouts is because they fail under physical pressure, not because they fail under lightning induced current.
--
Strange as it seems, no amount of learning can cure stupidity, and formal education positively fortifies it. -- Stephen Vizinczey


cooldude9919

join:2000-05-29
Cape Girardeau, MO
kudos:5

Yea that storm was pretty rough. Our site in springfield that has service from a WISP lost the canopy backhaul tower side. Verizon lost some stuff on the same tower also.


lutful
Premium
join:2005-06-16
Ottawa, ON
Reviews:
·TekSavvy DSL

reply to Rhaas

said by Rhaas:

One of the flaws Splitpair mentioned more or less in a passing statement in the other thread.
Electricians who "stick with what they know" would like to reach equipotential holy grail if the omnipotent laws of nature did not get in the way ...

P.S. our recent discussion was about potentially fatal bonding between 2 different potection zones - nothing to do with equipotential bonding within a zone.


Splitpair
Premium
join:2000-07-29
Cow Towne
kudos:3

1 edit

reply to AMD Phreak

said by AMD Phreak:

Holy hell.

Lack of single point bonding.















You think so?

Grounding without proper bonding is a waste of time and effort and provides about as much protection as a busted condom.

Wayne
--
If you cannot fix it with a buttset and some beanies you're not a technician.


Splitpair
Premium
join:2000-07-29
Cow Towne
kudos:3

reply to lutful
Nice Googling, by the way do you happen to know a member by the name of Doc Olds?

Wayne
--
If you cannot fix it with a buttset and some beanies you're not a technician.



Splitpair
Premium
join:2000-07-29
Cow Towne
kudos:3

reply to Rhaas
Yesterday as that front with its tornados drifted through here we had a 135' monopole take a direct hit and other than a blown port on the Nokia and a matching SmartJack card no other damage to the site.

Actually if you look carefully you can see the other SmartJack's in the NCTE while thoroughly smoked and sooted up are still in sync and carrying traffic.










Gotta love proper grounding and bonding.

Wayne
--
If you cannot fix it with a buttset and some beanies you're not a technician.


Splitpair
Premium
join:2000-07-29
Cow Towne
kudos:3

reply to nunya
Also if you note carefully it appears no one took the time to clear the paint down to bare metal from the area where the conduit connectors and lockrings make contact with the cabinet.

That paint should have been removed, the metal cleaned and after the lockring is properly tightened the area greased to prevent rusting.

And as you correctly pointed out a grounding bushing should have been used with any concentric KO.

Wayne

--
If you cannot fix it with a buttset and some beanies you're not a technician.


Javik
Premium
join:2006-10-02
Gilman, WI

reply to Splitpair

said by Splitpair:

Yesterday as that front with its tornados drifted through here we had a 135' monopole take a direct hit and other than a blown port on the Nokia and a matching SmartJack card no other damage to the site.
It is more than grounding and bonding that protected this hardware. Each of those 5 - pin colored square things around the sides are gas discharge tube arresters (GDT), which divert any lightning overcurrent to the grounding system.

They are like neon lamps and normally don't do anything with low network voltages, but the gas instantly conducts surge current to ground, and they are able to survive multiple surges without failure.

As far as I know GDT's are standard lightning protection equipment for telco hardware. I believe if the GDT fails during a strike, the circuit is interrupted but the equipment usually survives, and the GDT is something like $5 - $10 to replace.

Being in a keyed 5-pin case with a handle on top, they are quick to replace to bring the equipment back online.

========

Random google search for a manufacturer of them:

2420 Series - 5-Pin Gas Discharge Tube (GDT) Protector
»www.bourns.org/data/global/pdfs/2420.pdf

Impulse Life Characteristics (Tip and Ring to Ground Simultaneously)
10 A, 10/1000 microseconds -- >3000 operations
100 A, 10/1000 microseconds -- >300 operations
300 A, 10/1000 microseconds -- >100 operations
500 A, 10/1000 microseconds -- >400 operations
2,000 A, 10/250 microseconds -- >25 operations
5,000 A, 20/100 microseconds -- >2 operations
20,000 A, 8/20 microseconds -- >1 operation


.
--
CenturyLink remote pedestal: RUBY, 10 miles west of Gilman, WI
»Rural Century Telephone remote terminal unit
»Name of this pole-mount outdoor telco canister?

Javik
Premium
join:2006-10-02
Gilman, WI

reply to Rhaas
..... reading that GDT manufacturer PDF further, it seems the two little dots you see on the top of each GDT are test points.

So, after a major surge event the site technician can go down the row and test each GDT with a meter and probes to see if it is still good, without having to physically pull it out and possibly interrupt the customer datalines.

=====================

Although used mainly for telco hardware I believe these are also effective for coax lines.... (googling) ah yes here we go...

Coaxial Protection - Gas Tubes
»www.citel.us/coaxial_types_gas_tubes.html

=====================

If I am to do anything with my shoestring WISP, I am going to have GDTs protecting all the customer and tower equipment, in addition to bonding and grounding.

.
--
CenturyLink remote pedestal: RUBY, 10 miles west of Gilman, WI
»Rural Century Telephone remote terminal unit
»Name of this pole-mount outdoor telco canister?



Splitpair
Premium
join:2000-07-29
Cow Towne
kudos:3

1 edit

reply to Javik

said by Javik:

It is more than grounding and bonding that protected this hardware. Each of those 5 - pin colored square things around the sides are gas discharge tube arresters (GDT), which divert any lightning overcurrent to the grounding system.
Negative on that, there are no “gas” protectors used there, on the left side of the NCTE you will notice a red protector with an H on the top. That is a solid state (hybrid) protector, below that are some blue ones which are the same type of protector only made by ONEAC. Internally these protectors use a combination of a MOV stack and thyristor’s for primary protection mode with a fuse link crowbar to ground for power cross protection.

On the right you will notice yellow protectors and those are ONEAC low voltage protectors 5-12 volt breakdown to match the DS1 (6 volt) signal level , also on the right are grey protectors and those are dummy coils which provide no protection at all they merely jump tip and ring from the NCTE to the RJx jack.

We don’t use “gas” protectors on circuits as their response time is too slow, by the time the protector fires over the electronics is toasted.

In the end what saved the majority of the equipment is the fact that the tower, the radios and the telco MGB are all tied back to the station MGB by a common bond which bypasses the majority of the current around not through the equipment to earth.

Wayne
--
If you cannot fix it with a buttset and some beanies you're not a technician.
page: 1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · 6 · 7

Saturday, 02-Jun 16:52:28 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.
Most commented news this week
Hot Topics