Odd. MyDVR on Fancast showed it was scheduled to record. It was showing up in My scheduled recordings, but it was showing it the do not record symbol. Even if I hit record during the show, it would not record on the HD channel and would not show up on my recordings.
It looks like I may have fixed it now. I went into the scheduled recordings, selected it and then selected delete. Now I can record it. I wonder if I somehow set up an event to not record?