site Search:


 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery






how-to block ads


 
Search Topic:
Share Topic
Post a:
Post a:
AuthorAll Replies

amigo_boy

join:2005-07-22
Reviews:
·magicjack.com

reply to Somnambul33t

Re: Yawn

said by Somnambul33t:

said by amigo_boy:

said by Somnambul33t:

it's certainly not the federal government b/c it's not listed anywhere in the constitution.

The federal constitution doesn't enumerate interstate highways, education, energy, wildlife or forest conservation, national park creation and operation, environmental protection, labor and occupational safety enforcement, and dozens of other things.

Would you get rid of those things?

YES

Thanks for your honesty. Most people only selectively invoke literal "enumerated powers" argument. When faced with the things I mentioned above, they backpeddle and say "that's different" (for fear of being irrelevant).

said by Somnambul33t:

interstate highways are completely constitutional: commerce clause was originally intended to grant the federal government authority to settle disputes between entities across state lines

But, now I'm detecting some backpeddling. (Chuckle.).

There were no disputes between states when interstate highways were created. They were created just because the federal government was in the best position to manage it.

The same argument could be made for consumer protections. That consolidating and standardizing protections reduces cross-state disputes and enhances commerce by making commerce more predictable.

said by Somnambul33t:

national parks should be abolished, the land sold off to private individuals/companies, ...

Education [too]. ...

the EPA [too] ...

labor laws like wage laws and OSHA [too].

Good. I'm glad to help readers contextualize your remarks on consumer protections.

It's easy to get all goose-bumply with Jingoist rhetoric. But, when people realize how that's either not consistently applied (or what it means when it is) the tingly feeling tends to go away rather quickly.

The prospect of irrelevancy has that effect on people.

Friday, 01-Jun 17:58:15 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.
Most commented news this week
Hot Topics