no, whats REALLY criminal is holding closed door meetings with the govt. in order to get the legislation passed that favors outdated business models while attempting to quash the fair use clause as if the public has no stake in the outcome. Also, I'll be damned if I have to pay taxes so large media companies can use various US govt. agencies (or have new ones created) as their copyright police and the courts as a revenue stream. The companies need to look long and hard at how peoples media consumption has changed and figure out how to monetize it. Trying to lock up or guilt millions of people around the globe into paying is utterly moronic no matter what one thinks is "ethical" or not.