MaynardKrebsHeave Steve, for the good of the countryPremium
|reply to MaynardKrebs |
Re: Lawful Access articles - collection
Electronic snooping bill a 'data grab': privacy advocates
...Vonn said she was most concerned that the new legislation would allow the government to obtain personal information about internet subscribers from their internet service provider without a warrant.
Police have not provided a good reason why they need that power, Vonn said. "You have to show us that the warrant process is not working." ... Vonn argued that even without the new bill, the Criminal Code allows police to obtain the information without a warrant in emergencies.
"They already have ability to request it, to get a warrant or to demand it if they have exigent circumstances," she said. "They say this is not enough? We say that's a lie."
But Ian Kerr, a professor who holds a Canada Research Chair in Ethics Law and Technology at the University of Ottawa, said the personally identifiable information that would be obtainable without a warrant could be used to get far more.
"That information is the key to unlocking much of the very information that they would require a warrant for," he said.
Stooke noted that there are provisions in the bill to ensure that police use the information properly. They will have to make written requests explaining why they need the information, and those requests will be audited multiple times a year. The results will be reported to the federal and provincial privacy commissioner, and any concerns would be reported to the provincial attorney general.
Vonn said that system won't prevent police from violating people's privacy in the first place.
"We don't want the apology after the fact. We want the ability to protect privacy at the front end," she said.