reply to mclovin_it
Yes I found it. Allocation mode is off. Should I change it to default server, passthrough, or leave it off?
Yes, If you know the ip address of the xbox select default serverYou can also try the passthrough but after making that selection you must reboot the xbox and make sure it has a public ip addressWith either option the xbox must/should be set for a dhcp/automatic connection
I had to open nat/gaming and packet filter to get nat all the way open