dslreports logo
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc
uniqs
12
zorxd
join:2010-02-05
Quebec, QC

zorxd to ekster

Member

to ekster

Re: [VoIP] Freephoneline.ca port forwarding

Even on a softphone you shouldn't need port forwarding.

I used many SIP softphones behind a NAT without any problem.

HiVolt
Premium Member
join:2000-12-28
Toronto, ON

HiVolt

Premium Member

I was trying to help my friend over remote desktop, I had no physical access to the device. I've worked with Linksys ATA's, but not with this Grandstream branded ATA...

From what my friend was reading to me from an instruction sheet provider, it said specifically to forward those ports to the VoIP ATA's LAN IP.

I told my friend to call back if she needs more help.
zorxd
join:2010-02-05
Quebec, QC

zorxd

Member

Well the one who wrote the instruction didn't know what he is talking about. Port forwarding should only be required if you want to receive direct IP calls not from your SIP server (freephoneline in that case). Most users don't need this. I would even say that most users don't want this since you can receive spam this way (although unlikely)

I checked the voip.ms configuration guide and there is nothing about port forwarding
»wiki.voip.ms/article/Devices

Ott_Cable
@teksavvy.com

Ott_Cable

Anon

When done correctly, really only servers needs to use port forwarding to allow in packets from clients. It is not like you are the VoIP provider or anything that requires someone's client to initiate services from your ATA.

This ass backward scheme with the port forwarding is there presumably that the person has no clue how to configure the NAT support correctly and relies on the forwarding itself to push the return packets from the server to the client.

Randomly exposing ports behind a firewall is asking for trouble from a security point of view.

Most softphones would at least be smart about NAT transversal or use a STUN server to figure out the WAN address.

Davesnothere
Change is NOT Necessarily Progress
Premium Member
join:2009-06-15
Canada

Davesnothere to zorxd

Premium Member

to zorxd
said by zorxd:

Even on a softphone you shouldn't need port forwarding.

I used many SIP softphones behind a NAT without any problem.

.
Also, I still have Skype in one PC, and it never required any special router settings, IIRC.