Topic 'Re: 2012 Modem Poll' in forum 'Comcast HSI' - dslreports.com

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Fri, 10 Feb 2012 15:10:27 EDT

iansltx posted : 6120 here, going strong. Next purchase: the Asus "Dark Knight" router...

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Thu, 09 Feb 2012 15:29:29 EDT

bgoodbody posted : For the Arris MTA TM722G how does one tell if its an NCS org IMG?
--
- Bill

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Thu, 09 Feb 2012 14:41:09 EDT

jbob posted : I'm using a leased DPC3000. Been thinking about finally going ahead and purchasing my own modem however. I think my Cisco may have took a crap so thinking harder now. ;)

I don't keep up with the modem stuff as much as I used to. Seems I remember reading once that the Motorola SB6120 had some advantages over the newer 6121. Am I remembering that correctly?

I might go with the Zoom over the Moto.

I notice on the recommended list they show IPV6 certified modems. Is this something important to think about for future usage? The Zooms aren't on that list however the 6120 and 6121 are.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Tue, 07 Feb 2012 10:14:24 EDT

sortofageek posted : Ah, thanks for pointing that out. I trusted Amazon's search feature too much, I see.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Tue, 07 Feb 2012 10:10:58 EDT

Ripper posted : The review link you posted is for the DPC3000,not the DPC3008. Anyway, Google shows a number of online stores selling it around $90 .

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Tue, 07 Feb 2012 09:52:54 EDT

sortofageek posted : I see Amazon has that modem, but it is still rather pricey. A few reviews here.

Quick search shows a lower price at macmall, so a good shopper may be able to find it at a reasonable price.
--
Join Team Helix * I am praying for these friends .

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Tue, 07 Feb 2012 08:10:52 EDT

Ripper posted : They added the Cisco DPC3008, 8x4 D3 modem »mydeviceinfo.comcast.net/device.···=&sc=410 to the Comcast approved modem list.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Tue, 24 Jan 2012 06:35:54 EDT

owlyn posted : It depends on your market. Many markets allow you to buy one specific eMTA from Best Buy ($149), but require that Comcast installs it ($49). Not really worth it, as it would take about 28 months to recover the cost. In that time, there would probably be later (better) hardware available.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Tue, 24 Jan 2012 05:35:56 EDT

anon posted : So, from what I can find out, if you have HSI and voice thru comcast, you basically have to rent/lease their modem. Is this correct?

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Mon, 23 Jan 2012 19:10:19 EDT

IowaCowboy posted : I don't know what the difference is between IMS and NCS after the Arris TM722G options mean but I use an Arris TM722G (which I purchased for $149 at Best Buy) for both HSI and CDV.
--
All of my CPE (including my EMTA) is customer owned. The only Comcast owned equipment in my house is the CableCards in the two TiVO boxes I own.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Wed, 18 Jan 2012 11:41:22 EDT

Ripper posted : Not a surprise that the first retail DOCSIS 3.0 modem available,back in early 2009,the Motorola SB6120, is the most used modem in the poll.Still there is a very limited selection of DOCSIS 3.0 retail modems.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Mon, 16 Jan 2012 18:12:55 EDT

LMoreland posted : I am unable to tell whether I have an Arris 722G (ims) or (ncs). What is the difference?

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Mon, 16 Jan 2012 11:13:20 EDT

jkj860 posted : Cisco DPC3000 owned. Has been very stable and consistent.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Mon, 16 Jan 2012 02:12:13 EDT

pokesph posted : Mine is the Motorola SB6120

Oh look, we're winning!

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 18:20:23 EDT

plencnerb posted : Since I voted "Other", I figured I would let everyone know what Modem I do have.

according to the page that comes up when I browse to the modem config page (»192.168.100.1/), the name that it shows is below

DPC2100R2

As far as did I purchase this, or do I rent, I know we are renting it.

--Brian
--
============================
--Brian Plencner

E-Mail: CoasterBrian72Cancer@gmail.com
Note: Kill Cancer to Reply via e-mail

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 17:20:17 EDT

owlyn posted :

said by owlyn:

But the list is not 100% correct. I know of at least one Comcast supplied (and therefor approved) modem that is not on the list- the one I have. There could be others. I wonder what the additional letters after the Arris model numbers mean. For example, I have a TM602G/CT. The TM602G is the main part of the model number, but I wonder if the additional letters "CT" have an relevant meaning. A quick Google search suggests that they might:

»forums.comcast.com/t5/Connectivi···p/949273

After reviewing the list on the Comcast site, I determined that when there is no designation after the "G" on Arris modems, it is an NCS, so I was able to vote- TM602G-NCS.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 16:54:40 EDT

Alcohol posted : Rocking the SB6120 and don't plan to change for years... Or atleast until i've recovered my full cost of the modem from saving $7/mo to comcast (14 months).

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 16:44:20 EDT

BiggA posted : I wouldn't suggest buying one new, but ours has worked since 2003, and will probably keep going for a while, so no need to replace it unless our node gets congested (highly unlikely in this neck of the woods).

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 12:41:38 EDT

tshirt posted :

said by BiggA:

Not much love for the SB5100. :( Most of them must have died by now lol.

Not at all I still have my working 6 year old 5100 on the 'reserve' shelf, but I listed the modem I currently use.
even though 5100's are still fairly useful, I wouldn't recommend shopping for any older modem, but if offered for free/very cheap, it's a great budget choice.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 12:16:38 EDT

fuziwuzi posted : I have a SB5100 that I purchased back in 2005. It still works just fine. I have the standard 12/2 service so I don't see any point in "upgrading" to a newer D3 modem when this one still works without any problem. Over the years Comcast has attempted twice to claim my modem as theirs, so I've kept the receipt of my purchase just in case.
--
Teabaggers: Destroying America is Priority #1

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 10:45:38 EDT

BiggA posted : Not much love for the SB5100. :( Most of them must have died by now lol.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 10:34:30 EDT

Johkal posted : Doing a bit of research, it may appear that the "CT" is a Comcast only version of the TM602G. Therefore, all TM602Gs leased by Comast are "CT" versions. On the Arris site, they do not list a "CT" version; only "G". Doing a search here on BBR, yields that the 'CT" description only shows up on the Comcast forum. The standard "G" version shows up for other cable providers.

Arris site for ref: »www.arrisi.com/support/guides/600_series.asp

This should be a good start for you if you feel inclined to investigate this further. ;)
--
In God we trust; all others bring data!

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 10:23:22 EDT

sortofageek posted : Just for information, you can't add to a poll list without breaking the poll. So, Johkal would need to start over every time someone wants a modem added.

I think he did well to go with the current list Comcast provided and I suspect he knew there are others in use.

A search of this forum on "TM602" only got 36 hits before this post, so it doesn't seem often mentioned here.

See ---> »/nsearch?q=TM6···95494573

Hopefully, anyone other than you who is using it will reply to one of your posts in this topic so we get an idea how it compares to those in the poll?

I added a link to your first post in this topic to the bottom of the original post.

--
Join Team Helix * I am praying for these friends .

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sun, 15 Jan 2012 09:58:35 EDT

owlyn posted : But the list is not 100% correct. I know of at least one Comcast supplied (and therefor approved) modem that is not on the list- the one I have. There could be others. I wonder what the additional letters after the Arris model numbers mean. For example, I have a TM602G/CT. The TM602G is the main part of the model number, but I wonder if the additional letters "CT" have an relevant meaning. A quick Google search suggests that they might:

»forums.comcast.com/t5/Connectivi···p/949273

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 23:29:55 EDT

jaynick posted : Great Poll Johkal , I voted the Cisco DPC3000 as that is what I am using although I do see the Zoom 5341J is gaining in popularity with good reviews.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 20:34:59 EDT

cooperaaaron posted : Motorola 6120, own, NO issues with this modem at any time since I bought it.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 19:14:13 EDT

mustang50 posted : Zoom 5341J. own. I had a sb6120,but it was damaged when I tripped over the cable... :huh:. Both deliver about the same on speed tests, but the Zoom is 8x4. I only get 4x1 now, but I'm ready when Comcast is... :p

Just my 2 cents...My old sb5100 would only get about half the upload as the D3 modems
...and during peak hrs it would really slow down from congestion...So IMHO any D3 modem with bonded channels works better than any D2 on an upgraded system....

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 18:22:26 EDT

Bach posted : I voted for SB6120, but just realized I've got the SB5120. mea culpa.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 17:50:54 EDT

Johkal posted : Just to address a few questions:
If anyone voting would like to post additional info. such as whether their modem is own or leased, if it's D2 or D3 capable, price of modem, etc., feel free to add a comment.

When deciding what modems to include in this Poll, there were many I could have added like EOLs, less common variations of models, etc.. but I chose to use Comcast's list of approved modems. With their list, it will assure that the modem you can lease or purchase is supported by Comcast.
--
In God we trust; all others bring data!

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 17:04:44 EDT

hclarkjr posted : i have a moto sb6121 that i own

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 16:16:36 EDT

KevTech posted : Average cost per modem might help people too since the Zoom is for the most part a lot cheaper than either of the surfboards.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 15:45:28 EDT

Johkal posted :

said by quatrix:

The distinction between "lease" and "own" is an important one. While it appears the the majority have DOCSIS 3 modems, I'd be surprised if the majority own DOCSIS 3 modems.

Looking at the results so far, the top 3 modems which are D3 modems are available for purchase. (i.e. SB6120, SB6121 & 5341J). Know that if someone inquiring about new modems was to use this Poll as simple tool, it would be irrelevant whether they were leasing or buying. They see what Comcast customers on this forum are using, inquire about their top choices, find out if it's available for lease or purchase & then make their decision.
--
In God we trust; all others bring data!

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 15:36:16 EDT

KevTech posted : I get much better signals with the 5341J then I did with the 5341 or the 6120.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 15:20:53 EDT

EG posted :

said by quatrix:

I'd be surprised if the majority own DOCSIS 3 modems since they're still overpriced and unnecessary.

Same old opinion of yours, same old opinion of mine; ;)

There are benefits to be had by using a D3 capable modem on an upgraded to D3 system such as increased connection reliability due to the multiple bonded channel redundancy and failover capability. There are also increased capacity/reduced congestion benefits which result in increased reliability of receiving one's provisioned speeds especially during times of peak usage/demand. Higher Powerboost assisted speeds have been noted as well. It's a win win for both the provider and the subscriber.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 15:20:23 EDT

Johkal posted :

said by owlyn:

Well, my Comcast-supplied modem is not on the list. It is an Arris 602G/CT, so I didn't vote.

"If you don't see your modem, choose "Other" ;)

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 15:19:50 EDT

owlyn posted :

said by quatrix:

The distinction between "lease" and "own" is an important one. While it appears the the majority have DOCSIS 3 modems, I'd be surprised if the majority own DOCSIS 3 modems since they're still overpriced and unnecessary.

Good point. Mine is leased, and is DOCSIS 2, as I only have 15/2.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 13:51:33 EDT

quatrix posted : The distinction between "lease" and "own" is an important one. While it appears the the majority have DOCSIS 3 modems, I'd be surprised if the majority own DOCSIS 3 modems since they're still overpriced and unnecessary.

Arris 602G/CT

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 13:03:46 EDT

owlyn posted : Well, my Comcast-supplied modem is not on the list. It is an Arris 602G/CT, so I didn't vote.

Mod Edit: See also ---> »Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 12:23:45 EDT

EG posted : Good poll Johkal ! A perfect way to start the new year ! :)

My selection is in. 5341J

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 11:53:21 EDT
Johkal posted : That was my thought also. The older Polls did ask for "Best" by opinion; but with so much subjectivity, it was a source of debate with no definitive resolution. ;)

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 11:49:27 EDT
sortofageek posted : I think the concept of trying to gauge "use" rather than "best" is a good idea.

That way, when someone with limited experience comes to the conclusion of "since I saw 12 complaints about xxx modem on this forum, therefore it must be inferior," we can keep it in perspective when we can see that particular modem currently has the largest percentage of use.
--
Join Team Helix * I am praying for these friends .

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 11:33:27 EDT
tshirt posted : Not unusual, people can be curious about the result, even if they don't have a specific recomendation or experince with D3 & ComCast.
I could only recommend the 6120, because that's the only one I have extend experience with, but the 6121 should be similar and I'm definatly watching reviews and views of people with the 8 channel down modems for a future purchase.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 11:30:44 EDT
Johkal posted : It's cool! ;) The modem polls started years back just for curiosity. Even with a small sample size of participants, it has given a descent overview of what's being used out there.

Re: 2012 Modem Poll

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 10:25:47 EDT
Ripper posted : Over 200 views,and only a little over 50 votes,same with my last years modem poll.