 tcopePremium join:2003-05-07 Sandy, UT kudos:2 | reply to Linklist
Re: Google anti-SOPA/PIPA actions will disappear soon Exactly! As there is a lot of grey would should always error on the side of rights vs censorship. Laws already exist to prevent copyright violations... wasn't megauploads just shut down. This was done without SOPA. SOPA simply removes due process.
I don't know of anyone against copyright protection... but this is not the problem with SOPA. The issue is that it removes due process.
We live with certain evils... that is just a fact. It's the price we pay to live the way that we do. But we need to all admit this and then look at bills such as SOPA. |
|
|
|
 | said by tcope:wasn't megauploads just shut down. This was done without SOPA. SOPA simply removes due process.
I don't know of anyone against copyright protection... but this is not the problem with SOPA. The issue is that it removes due process. MegaUploads was blocked because the Entertainment industry claimed they had an infringing video on their site that contained a number of high profile artists in it. However, it was MegaUpload who produced the video and had paid the artists to appear in it. The Entertainment industry had no ownership of the video, but still had MegaUpload blocked for a day or two, and disrupted MegaUpload's business, without even validating that any copyright infringement had actually occurred, and without following legal due process.
SOPA just gives them the ability to do the same on a whim to anyone. Luckily, MegaUpload had the media connections, finances, and the clout to push back quickly. Imagine what would have happened if it had been a small video business just starting out? Such an incident would have ruined that business. |
|
 tcopePremium join:2003-05-07 Sandy, UT kudos:2 | said by jerseyjoe123:MegaUploads was blocked because the Entertainment industry claimed they had an infringing video on their site that contained a number of high profile artists in it. However, it was MegaUpload who produced the video and had paid the artists to appear in it. The Entertainment industry had no ownership of the video, but still had MegaUpload blocked for a day or two, and disrupted MegaUpload's business, without even validating that any copyright infringement had actually occurred, and without following legal due process. Not as I read... the Justice Dept indited them for hosting copywrited material to the tune of $500 million of loss revenue. This is not a "video".... this speaks of "multiple" files. |
|
 KrKHeavy Artillery For The Little GuyPremium join:2000-01-17 Tulsa, OK | reply to jerseyjoe123 MegaUpload is a legit site.
This takedown and arrest is an example of where this path is leading us.
The USA better be careful or the rest of the world will copy and pirate everything Hollywood makes as a matter of principle. -- "Fascism should more properly be called corporatism because it is the merger of state and corporate power." -- Benito Mussolini
|
|
 LinklistPremium join:2002-03-03 Longport, NJ kudos:5 1 edit | said by KrK:MegaUpload is a legit site.
Oh, give me a break. Megauoload is far from legitimate. Having SOME legit files, or even a small percentage of legit files(even 20 or 30 %) doesn't make them legit. And the pretend ignorance by site mgt of what is on their servers is so bogus.
»arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news···load.ars
But the government asserts that Megaupload merely wanted the veneer of legitimacy, while its employees knew full well that the site's main use was to distribute infringing content. Indeed, the government points to numerous internal e-mails and chat logs from employees showing that they were aware of copyrighted material on the site and even shared it with each other. Because of this, the government says that the site does not qualify for a safe harbor of the kind that protected YouTube from Viacom's $1 billion lawsuit.
For instance, the abuse tool allegedly does not remove the actual file being complained about by a rightsholder. Instead, it only removes a specific Web address linked to that filebut there might be hundreds of such addresses for popular content.
Employees also had access to analytics. One report showed that a specific linking site had produce[d] 164,214 visits to Megaupload for a download of the copyrighted CD/DVD burning software package Nero Suite 10. The software package had the suggested retail price of $99. The government's conclusion: Megaupload knew what was happening and did little to stop it. |
|
 | What the percentage of internet traffic that is totally legit? Probably only 20 or 30%. SHUT IT DOWN |
|