drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to Jobbie
Re: [game] Newbie F11said by Jobbie:there was no way to make Adalicia change his mind after all. So it was GG from there. This is not true. You HAVE to make an appeal to the other towns' logic. You unvote, encourage others to do the same and then paint a clear picture of the events that transpired in the game. That's not to say that the other people have to listen, but when you step back, take emotions out of it, you'll hopefully have a clear picture. If you showed time stamps on the posts, the rushed post "SCum", etc. you'll have a compelling case. It was a fantastic game, but Mose made a HUGE mistake here and would have had it not been a newbie game. |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to drew
At least I had the sense to stay in character for my hammer vote.
"HAHA WE WIN GO MAFIA vote kristopher!!!11!"
Would have been a little harder to back off from. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
to Chaplain
said by Chaplain:said by ekster:Sorry guys.. was having lunch. A lot to reread. And there you have it. If he was scum, he would have just hammered. Booya! Heading to my meeting. I'll check by phone to see Protus hang. Haha, love you too, Kris. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to drew
said by drew:said by Jobbie:there was no way to make Adalicia change his mind after all. So it was GG from there. This is not true. You HAVE to make an appeal to the other towns' logic. You unvote, encourage others to do the same and then paint a clear picture of the events that transpired in the game. That's not to say that the other people have to listen, but when you step back, take emotions out of it, you'll hopefully have a clear picture. If you showed time stamps on the posts, the rushed post "SCum", etc. you'll have a compelling case. It was a fantastic game, but Mose made a HUGE mistake here and would have had it not been a newbie game. You are totally right i guess i didn't say anything after it, thought it was self explained after KrisT had. Learning a lot from you guys. It was a great game. |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to drew
What huge mistake? That was 0:14 away from being game. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 2:03 pm
said by Prevailer:What huge mistake? That was 0:14 away from being game. Lol it was my second bait in the game. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
to ekster
GG all. Thanks for modding drew, and get off your fucking high horse, you little dweeb. You an ignorant shit sometimes.
That said, everyone played well. I'll post more after I get back from my seminar. |
|
|
Antonica
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 2:05 pm
I hate all of you for beliving ekster. Mafia knew if there was a cop or not. My reference to Jobbie was YES I PROTECTED HIM. The ONLY people who would have known that was MAFIA :P. THey knew I protected, so why not come out and "clear" who was protected and another known townie. Mafia fake cop claim 101. sigh. I even said it was too convientent... i was hoping someone would read my posts and go back to that and figure it out Sigh. |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to Chaplain
said by Chaplain:Thanks for modding drew, and get off your fucking high horse, you little dweeb. You an ignorant shit sometimes. I look forward to hearing why you didn't back off and go logic on everyone. That's usually your MO and after Savious wrecked the game for town, I really wanted them to win. |
|
|
Antonica
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 2:06 pm
ignore spelling mistakes, in a hurry |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to Adalicia
said by Adalicia:said by drew:This is where I am really sad we don't have enough people for mentors.
That was a very, very clear mafia hammer attempt. You always, the moment you see a drive-by vote like that would end the game but didn't, want to unvote. Immediately. As in, don't post anything else just get that unvote post up as quick as possible. Experience and trial and error leads to learning. Sorry town. Bah... I want to make sure you know you played really, really well, especially as a newbie. I honestly probably would've lost as town, especially after the night before when I got a PM saying "No kill" from PM. That was an EXCELLENT move that they deserve kudos for. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
to Antonica
Actually, we didn't know a damn. Jobbie didn't die not because you protected him... he didn't die because we sent a 'no kill' order. We had no idea about a cop or a doc. I took a wild guess and claimed cop after no lynch, thinking there's going to be a cop and I'll just have to convince the rest that he's the scum and not me, or that there's a doc who will speak up and make it easy.... And your exchange with Kris made me think that you were the doc so we killed you the next night... making everything else fit in nicely. |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to drew
said by drew:said by Adalicia:said by drew:This is where I am really sad we don't have enough people for mentors.
That was a very, very clear mafia hammer attempt. You always, the moment you see a drive-by vote like that would end the game but didn't, want to unvote. Immediately. As in, don't post anything else just get that unvote post up as quick as possible. Experience and trial and error leads to learning. Sorry town. Bah... I want to make sure you know you played really, really well, especially as a newbie. I honestly probably would've lost as town, especially after the night before when I got a PM saying "No kill" from PM. That was an EXCELLENT move that they deserve kudos for. Con. I was very impressed. I've been playing for a year, and I fear you're way ahead of me already. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to ekster
Well played indeed ekster. |
|
|
to ekster
ugh |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
drew
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 2:12 pm
By the way, even Arch didn't think ekster was scum. When, after PM tried to hammer, I PMed him asking him who was scum, he replied Ada and PM.
LOLOL |
|
|
to ekster
yeah. well played. And ada didn't play great, she had a lot of "well couldn't have been this" statements that are obviously completely wrong and absolutely can't be in a game like this. |
|
Antonica |
to drew
i was the only one who thought he was full of it? |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
to drew
My first rule of playing as scum: Play it like you're town.
The rest will sort itself out by the others. |
|
ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
to drew
said by drew:By the way, even Arch didn't think ekster was scum. When, after PM tried to hammer, I PMed him asking him who was scum, he replied Ada and PM.
LOLOL I was 50/50 on the cop claim. I figured Ada wasn't being genuine after the logic was flowing his way, so it was him and PM. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to Antonica
That is why you got silenced. |
|
|
Antonica
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 2:14 pm
said by Jobbie:That is why you got silenced. it usually is you have no idea. |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
to Antonica
said by Antonica:yeah. well played. And ada didn't play great, she had a lot of "well couldn't have been this" statements that are obviously completely wrong and absolutely can't be in a game like this. Learn and apply I guess is all I can say. I have a tendency to think in absolutes, probably because in addition to being an art nerd I was a math nerd too, just more to file away for next time and mistakes to not repeat. |
|
|
Jim7 Premium Member join:2003-02-10 |
Jim7 to drew
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 2:16 pm
to drew
Sheesh The new guys did great imo. I am impressed (and humbled). I certainly could not have done as well. PM and dat der Canada dude did a bang up job. |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to Adalicia
I disagree with Ant on the number of mistakes you made, logically. The end "mistake" isn't really your fault. It's an emotional part of the game and it's a technical play that you have to have knowledge of to play correctly.
I was watching Ada's posts and analyzing it... the only thing I can say is that he went after KrisT like a blood hound and didn't let up. That, from my cheap seats, was a mistake. That being said, first game? Mad props. |
|
|
to Adalicia
you'll make mistakes.. that ironically is the only absolute :P
even though it's not a crazy game... all games are the same that you can almost never be sure of anything.... there is logic to the game and it can be sorted out, but for the most part you really can't know for sure. Look at the mafia even... they didn't know if they had a doc or cop... they guessed. |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to Adalicia
Can we get a sex confirmation? I see "Alicia" as part of the name and a kitten and theink "she". Others are referring to "he". Or we can refer to you as "it" in future games. |
|
|
to drew
it's not the number of mistakes he made, it's his thinking behind them. Like he even said, he thinks in absolutes, and you just simply can not do that. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to drew
Congrats Ada for a great game it could have gone either way after Sav's fuck up.
That is why we newbs must unite! |
|
|
Antonica
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 2:20 pm
mistakes will be made, its how you view the game that makes you a better player |
|