AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
to Chaplain
Re: [game] Newbie F11said by Chaplain:Your posts are what we call WIFOM. Wine In Front Of Me. We're supposed to believe your scenario because you state it, but it could be that it happened another way. Why would she protect anyone, if she didn't know who they were? But she did protect someone each night. That's what a doc does, with or without information. And your last line is classic. I didn't try hard. I just announced a meta game so that it was out there.
You should not use meta game to determine a lynch. I never voted for you once. I just pointed out that new games usually pits one newbie as mafia, and one as town. My first game was also Arch's first game. He was Town, and I was mafia. I had a mentor, plus my partner. He had a mentor. We won. (could have been the other way around, but we still won)
Other newbie games I've seen go the same way. So, metagame was that one of you two were town, and the other mafia. Is it fact? No. But it's out there, so I said it. Especially after Savious turned out town. First off, despite the fact that it was a random day one vote, you did in fact vote for me. See: » Re: [game] Newbie F11So there is the first slip. Mistake? Maybe, or you're just starting to lose your edge. Secondly, just because your first game did something like that doesn't mean this one did. There are no mentors in this game and roles and variant were chosen at random. Third, now you're pushing to whack the cop even though we have no reason to believe him to not be a cop. He cleared Antonica, who was the doctor, he cleared Jobbie, who I believe Antonica cleared and who I believed the mafia targeted during the no kill night, and I know I'm town. His cop claim seems legit to me which leaves the two people that he didn't clear, you and PM. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:16 pm
Fine. I'll vote PM if you do. |
|
Chaplain |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:17 pm
Absolutely down with that. You say it has to be me and PM. Then we test it. If you're willing to vote off PM, since you know he's mafia, then let's do it. |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
to Chaplain
I'm voting you.
vote: Kristopher
If I'm wrong, we lose. I don't have anything to really go by other than I KNOW I'm town and you've felt funny all bloody game.
No one else has to jump in on it, think for yourself, but unless some startling revelation comes to light, which I'm highly doubtful, I'm placing my vote here and I'm leaving it here. |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to Chaplain
said by Chaplain:Absolutely down with that. You say it has to be me and PM. Then we test it. If you're willing to vote off PM, since you know he's mafia, then let's do it. You're going to bet the entire game on the FUD Factory? Jeez. |
|
Prevailer |
to Adalicia
Easy, Francis. You're awfully jumpy. Put that thing down before you hurt someone. |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
Nope, I said my peace. Take it however you want. My vote stays where it is. I specifically said I want everyone else to vote how they like, to think for themselves and I mean it.
I did my thinking, I've said what I've said, I know I'm town, I believe Jobbie to be town, I don't have a reason to disbelieve the cop claim, but even then I'm taking the safe road.
Kristopher is scum. I think you're scum too but he is still the common denominator. Hence the reason I won't vote for you but I will vote for him. Legit or not, he is scum. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:27 pm
Avoiding the point. If I am scum, then so is Protus. You said so yourself, so why not vote Protus? It's tough when you're called upon to vote your partner, isn't it?
I'm also not hammered yet. That means a) you're right, I'm scum; or b) you're scum. Either way, form ekster's point of view, one of us is scum. Making Protus the other scum by default. So, sure way to get mafia, is to vote Protus. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to Adalicia
Lets spice things up:
Vote: KrisT
If i am wrong this was an awesome game and props to Drew for putting it together.
Who is going to put the hammer on this? |
|
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:28 pm
@Protus: Let me requote this for you. said by Chaplain:I'm also not hammered yet. That means a) you're right, I'm scum; or b) you're scum. Either way, form ekster's point of view, one of us is scum. Making Protus the other scum by default. So, sure way to get mafia, is to vote Protus. |
|
Chaplain |
to Jobbie
said by Jobbie:Lets spice things up:
Vote: KrisT
If i am wrong this was an awesome game and props to Drew for putting it together.
Who is going to put the hammer on this? Jobbie NOOOOOO! You are going to lose the game! |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:29 pm
Unvote |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to Chaplain
I was typing while you posted that. SCum.
Vote: Kristopher |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:29 pm
ooh shutup you are messing up with the fun! |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:29 pm
said by Chaplain:@Protus: Let me requote this for you. said by Chaplain:I'm also not hammered yet. That means a) you're right, I'm scum; or b) you're scum. Either way, form ekster's point of view, one of us is scum. Making Protus the other scum by default. So, sure way to get mafia, is to vote Protus. Just unvote and read through my post to see the logic. It's a logic trap, and mafia fell right in it. Come on guys.... |
|
Chaplain |
to Jobbie
That was fucking close, Jobbie!!!! Vote: ProtusNice try Protus. GG. |
|
|
Chaplain |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:34 pm
said by Chaplain:I'm also not hammered yet. That means a) you're right, I'm scum; or b) you're scum. Either way, form ekster's point of view, one of us is scum. Making Protus the other scum by default. So, sure way to get mafia, is to vote Protus. Once more. It's so simple. We win. ekster can see it from his POV. |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
to Chaplain
Trying so very hard to get PM nailed, kind of makes me think that he isn't mafia and the eskter is, which if that is the case, brilliant play, regardless I know bloody well I'm town and I still believe you're scum. My vote stays. |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to Chaplain
Repeating a false statement over and over doesn't make it true. I am town. You're trying to ringlead everyone into a lynch with the sole logic of "Either I'm mafia with protus or you're mafia with protus, so let's just vote him. herpa derpa" |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
to Chaplain
said by Chaplain:Once more. It's so simple. We win. ekster can see it from his POV. We as in you and ekster because you're Mafia? |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:37 pm
said by Adalicia:said by Chaplain:Once more. It's so simple. We win. ekster can see it from his POV. We as in you and ekster because you're Mafia? Keep diggin, bro. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to Adalicia
Vote: PM
Stop....!!!!! |
|
Jobbie |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:38 pm
HAMMER TIME!!!!
wtb ekster. |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
You'll have to get him because I'm not throwing the hammer down on anyone but Kristopher at this point. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:39 pm
Best way to end the game.
I miss being Rick Astler. |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
I'm sure it was a role you would never want to give up and I highly doubt you let anyone down. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
to Adalicia
If ekster is scum, then Protus is his partner, Ad. That's why this scenario works so well for town. At least from my point of view. Any way I look at it, Protus is proven scum. And ekster isn't gone. He would have hammered me by now. |
|
AdaliciaOm Nom Nom join:2009-10-13 Lincoln, NE |
Of course Protus is his partner if he is scum, because that conveniently excuses you from being scum. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-8 1:44 pm
said by Adalicia:Of course Protus is his partner if he is scum, because that conveniently excuses you from being scum. If you're town (highly doubtful), then you are avoiding logic for emotion. My call for protus was because you were sure it was me and protus. You didn't rise to the challenge I gave you. If you were sure, you would have. Now you say it must be me and ekster. I'm not buying it. |
|
PrevailerFreeze a poopy. Premium Member join:2001-10-03 Your Mom |
to Chaplain
This little mexican standoff throws my "Adalicias and Kristopher" theory out the window, but at least proves half of it. You're scum, and you're busted. I suppose ekster has to be your other half, though. Ekster cleared jobbie, so it can't be you and jobbie, since that would mean ekster's clean.
Kristopher and ekster are mafia. Hammer on me incoming when ekster gets back. |
|