 EdrickI aspire to tell the story of a lifetimePremium join:2004-09-11 Woburn, MA | Belden For In Wall Serial Im doing some home theater stuff and was wondering what you might reccomend for running in wall for serial rs232 to a TV / projector and extron controller. Which has a phonix screw down terminal. Is there a point to running a 9 conductor cable or should I just find a single pair with sheild? What do you recommend from belden |
|
 tschmidtPremium,MVM join:2000-11-12 Milford, NH kudos:5 Reviews:
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Hollis Hosting
| I'd check to see if all 9 conductors are being used, most likely not.
Rather then running cable dedicated for RS232, I'd run cat rated cable (4-pair 8-conductors) and use an adapter to convert it to DB-9 or DB-25. Then in a few years when all but us old timers have never heard of RS232 the cabling will still be useful for high speed networking.
/tom |
|
 ArthurSWatch Those Blinking LightsPremium join:2000-10-28 Hamilton, ON | reply to Edrick Are you sure you need *all* nine conductors for serial communication? The vast majority of RS232 control in AV applications only use 3 conductors, a few use 5 or 6, and very rarely anything beyond that. That said, CAT5 or CAT6 cable is perfectly fine for this kind of application, I use a RJ-45 to DB-9 adapter on each end. |
|
 EdrickI aspire to tell the story of a lifetimePremium join:2004-09-11 Woburn, MA | reply to Edrick That's what I'm wondering most applications I've seen just have TX / RX and a shield. So I wasn't sure if there was a specific cable that would be best. As far as running a datacable, it's not being run back to a central point where there will be a network switch and data will already be there. So I'm just wondering what recommendation AV installers have used. I don't see RS232 going anywhere anytime fast in pro-av installs. -- Edrick Smith Independent Film & Broadcast Producer »edricksmith.com |
|
 alkizmo join:2007-06-25 Pierrefonds, QC | What information is the RS232 bringing to the projector? Because I thought projectors use RGB through VGA cables (Component signal)
»www.instructables.com/id/Make-yo···5-cable/
Otherwise, ya, find out what pins you need, because CAT5 or better, CAT6, can do the job, as long as you don't need more pairs  |
|
 ThinkdiffPremium,MVM join:2001-08-07 Bronx, NY kudos:4 | reply to Edrick For all the Extron installs I've done, we've only used 3-conductor cable (Tx/Rx/Gnd). You'll still get turn on/turn off, power state, lamp hours, etc. No need for a full serial cable. -- University of Southern California - Fight On! |
|
|
|
 ArthurSWatch Those Blinking LightsPremium join:2000-10-28 Hamilton, ON | reply to Edrick On all my AV installs, serial communication is done using either standard CAT5e cable or if it's a simple Common, TX, RX, then Belden 9451 is acceptable. My preference is CAT5e cable so that when it's time to upgrade, you have an option to go ethernet for control. |
|
 EdrickI aspire to tell the story of a lifetimePremium join:2004-09-11 Woburn, MA | Perfect, that's what I figured was i'd just need three conductor. I'll also entertain running Cat for certain installs. When running cat what's the serial distance?
I take it you're just using those plastic serial to RJ45 adapters? |
|
 ArthurSWatch Those Blinking LightsPremium join:2000-10-28 Hamilton, ON | said by Edrick:Perfect, that's what I figured was i'd just need three conductor. I'll also entertain running Cat for certain installs. When running cat what's the serial distance?
I take it you're just using those plastic serial to RJ45 adapters? I've run serial data hundreds of feet over CAT5, however it's best to slow the baud rate down the further you go! For a typical home theatre cable distance, you should have no problem whatsoever running it over CAT5e at full baud rates. If you have some Belden 8451 or 9451 to spare, then great, use it. If you're having to purchase it new, you might find buying CAT5e to be much more cost effective, economies of scale working in your favour. |
|
 EdrickI aspire to tell the story of a lifetimePremium join:2004-09-11 Woburn, MA | I've got both 8451 and 9451, one thing I'm confused about what is the actual difference between the two models? |
|
 ArthurSWatch Those Blinking LightsPremium join:2000-10-28 Hamilton, ON | Both are identical in electrical spec, but the 9451 has the foil shield bonded to the outer jacket of the cable, so that when you strip it off, the foil is stripped off with it. A real time saver when you're terminating hundreds of cables (I know).
The 8451 is the older brother, but after stripping off the outer jacket, you'd often have to get a pair of nippy cutters to cut back what remained of the foil shield, and then you really needed to put a heatshrink tube to prevent any foil shield leftovers from shorting out with other cables or the connector shell. You could get away from having to put a heatshrink tube on the 9451, but I do it anyway out of habit and proper workmanship. |
|
 EdrickI aspire to tell the story of a lifetimePremium join:2004-09-11 Woburn, MA | Interesting, I suppose I just over looked that fact, but now it seems obvious. I'm still learning about proper cable termination. I've noticed some people when they make XLR cables for example shrinktube the cable jacket, the ground and then over the pins.
What do you do, what do you consider proper? |
|
 ArthurSWatch Those Blinking LightsPremium join:2000-10-28 Hamilton, ON | said by Edrick:Interesting, I suppose I just over looked that fact, but now it seems obvious. I'm still learning about proper cable termination. I've noticed some people when they make XLR cables for example shrinktube the cable jacket, the ground and then over the pins.
What do you do, what do you consider proper? I just do a clear heatshrink or tubing on the drain wire, then one larger black heat shrink on the cable jacket. I don't bother with heatshrink on the individual pins, since it's difficult to see any possible problems with the soldering job when I open up the connector if they are covered, if something has broken loose, I want to see it quickly instead of having to do surgery on the wiring job. Besides, I prefer twisting the conductors for pins 2&3 as much as reasonable within the connector, which will not allow heat shrink to fit on those individual pins. So essentially what I do is prep the cable with the above mentioned heat shrink, then solder pins 2&3, then twist the wire pair a couple turns, then solder the shield drain to pin 1. |
|
 SmokChsrWho let the magic smoke out?Premium join:2006-03-17 Saint Augustine, FL Reviews:
·Clearwire Wireless
| reply to ArthurS said by ArthurS:Both are identical in electrical spec, but the 9451 has the foil shield bonded to the outer jacket of the cable, so that when you strip it off, the foil is stripped off with it. A real time saver when you're terminating hundreds of cables (I know).
I can't say how much I hate Belden 8451! Many years ago I moved to Gepco 6180 and haven't bought any Belden audio cable since.
On a complex studio build using Belden would add days to the construction time. Gepco D61801EZGF is my wire of choice to go to any stereo equipment. Also threw out the old mainstay Switchcraft connectors for Neutric.
For the OP as long as you don't need any handshaking audio cable works just fine for serial data. But you should probably test it to make sure everything is happy with 3 wires before you install. |
|
 ArthurSWatch Those Blinking LightsPremium join:2000-10-28 Hamilton, ON | said by SmokChsr:I can't say how much I hate Belden 8451! Many years ago I moved to Gepco 6180 and haven't bought any Belden audio cable since. Indeed, I hated working with the 8451 as well, the 9451 fixed the issue of installation efficiency, and I don't allow the 8451 on my projects anymore. Their brilliance line of cable is fantastic as well. Ditto on Neutrik connectors! |
|