drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to ekster
Re: [game] Dethy 1Because I'm an idiot.
I've done this before too... I forget that insane doesn't mean "random result" it means "opposite result" |
|
ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
Exodus
Premium Member
2012-Feb-22 4:04 pm
Guilty on Drew. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
to Chaplain
vote drew
My vote is drew, because the results are: Krisnatharok sane/insane/paranoid drew sane/insane/paranoid/scum Jobbie naive ekster sane/insane/scum Archivis paranoid/scum (if he's a cop, he can't be sane or insane with both me and drew being the only other choices and he got a guilty on both of us)
From my perspective, the deduction works as following:
Jobbie is confirmed naive drew is either insane, paranoid or scum since he got a guilty on me Arch is either paranoid or scum Krisnatharok is either sane, insane or paranoid I have to be either sane or insane
If I'm sane, then drew is scum, which means Arch is paranoid, and Krisnatharok is insane. That works.
If I'm insane, then Arch is scum, drew is paranoid and Krisnatharok is left with sane. That doesn't work since KrisN got a guilty on Arch. |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
drew
Premium Member
2012-Feb-23 10:39 am
Well thanks, I wasn't sure who was scum between ekster and Arch but he made it pretty well clear.
Ekster CAN'T be insane and Arch scum because it leaves Kris with sane. This means he HAS to be scum.
Vote: ekster |
|
drew |
drew
Premium Member
2012-Feb-23 10:42 am
So roles are thus:
Kris: insane Arch: Paranoid Jobbie: naive drew: sane ekster: scum |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster to drew
Premium Member
2012-Feb-23 10:43 am
to drew
unvote drewFuck me. I fail at logic. I was sure the second one couldn't work for some reason. |
|
ekster |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-23 11:11 am
I was staring at the sheet for more than half an hour this morning and was sure KrisN being sane and Arch being scum didn't work. I just rechecked every possibility and I guess I just fail this time, I don't see any logical way at all of getting this.
Sorry for the screw up. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-23 11:29 am
It could be either Ekster or Drew. And going to night with no llynch is going to do nothing to help us.
So this is all about who is the sane cop. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 8:30 am
Game stalled...
I thought i had it figured out, but seems like we're left with a 33% chance, unless someone sees something else? |
|
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 1:49 pm
Must wake this game up. Dethy 4 ended. Let's end this one now. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 1:51 pm
Vote: Drew |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 2:16 pm
Arch, any insight? |
|
ekster |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 2:48 pm
Did Arch forget that he's in this game? |
|
|
Antonica
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 3:11 pm
/spec
Arch has been busy with RL |
|
ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
to Chaplain
Yes, I did forget. |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to Jobbie
|
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 3:26 pm
In my chart is either you or ekster, and you messed up your votes in 2 games which is unlikely. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 3:27 pm
How are you ruling Arch out? I tried to look at it from everyone's perspective, I didn't see that. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 3:29 pm
Got guilty on both of you and Drew so he has to be the paranoid. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 3:29 pm
Yeah, but he could also be the mafia faking it. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 3:34 pm
Problem is that we can't point anything since Drew screwed up his vote. we can go to night and see what happens. |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to ekster
said by ekster:How are you ruling Arch out? I tried to look at it from everyone's perspective, I didn't see that. By the way, my logic up top is bad. If Arch = scum, Kris can be sane since he got guilty on arch. Unvote: ekster |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-24 3:38 pm
Unvote Drew
Need to read again and see other scenarios. |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
to Chaplain
Happy monday folks. |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Feb-27 10:45 am
Right back at you, lets get this game finished! |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-27 11:29 am
Mornin' folk.
Time to end this, I guess.
Does anyone have anything at all to add, or do we just throw the dice? |
|
ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
Exodus
Premium Member
2012-Feb-27 11:30 am
I didn't realize this game was still going. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-27 2:00 pm
C'mon guys, stop avoiding the inevitable end of this game |
|
drewRadiant Premium Member join:2002-07-10 Port Orchard, WA |
drew
Premium Member
2012-Feb-27 2:03 pm
You're right.
I don't have a good read on either of you.
Vote: ekster
Why? Because we're at 50/50. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Feb-27 2:18 pm
Oh well.
vote Arch since I have a better read on drew than Arch. |
|