dslreports logo
site
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc

spacer




how-to block ads


Search Topic:
uniqs
1844
share rss forum feed


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
reply to Kristopher

Re: [game] Dethy 3

Vote: Night


Archivis
Your Daddy
Premium
join:2001-11-26
Earth
kudos:19
reply to Kristopher
Scenario: Arch is guilty

(FAKE) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(Insane/Naive) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(Insane/Paranoid) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(Insane/Paranoid) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

There is no such scenario in which you can cleanly assign a role to each player. Therefore, I am technically legit. One of three players have to be insane and if I am mafia, then all three players cannot have good results in order for this to be true. You can assign Paranoid/Naive roles to them, but that leaves one of them to be insane, which is not possible.
---------
Scenario: Adalicia is guilty

(Sane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(FAKE) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(Sane/Paranoid) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(Insane/Paranoid) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

The above scenario is plausible. You can reduce Archivis/Kristopher to Sane/Paranoid, covering both of those roles. You can give Brom Insane and Krisnatharok Naive.
---------
Scenario: Kristopher is guilty

(Insane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(FAKE) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(Insane/Paranoid) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

No results against Kristopher means this scenario is likely, due to lack of info. Two guilties and two innocents are par when you don't investigate mafia.
----------
Scenario: Krisnatharok is guilty

(Insane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(Insane/Paranoid) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(FAKE) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(Sane/Paranoid) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

Above scenario is possible. Brom is Sane, Adalicia is Naive, Kristopher/Archivis are Insane/Paranoid.
-----------
Scenario: Brom is guilty

(Insane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(Insane/Paranoid) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(Insane/Naive) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(FAKE) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

Above scenario is possible. Archivis/Kristopher cover Insane/Paranoid. Adalicia is Sane. Krisnatharok is naive.
-----------

Therefore, only I am cleared. Everyone else is still suspect.
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK


Krisnatharok
Caveat Emptor
Premium
join:2009-02-11
Earth Orbit
kudos:12
vote night

Gonna be a busy day, not sure how much time I'll have to be lazy...


Kristopher
Tarquin
Premium
join:2002-10-11
Tyrinaria
kudos:4
reply to Archivis
said by Archivis:

Therefore, only I am cleared. Everyone else is still suspect.

Bwahahahahahahaha!

You could be right, cause I don't bother looking into this until I get two days of results, but still.
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
reply to Archivis
That made my head hurt. I blame it on just waking up.

vote: Night


Archivis
Your Daddy
Premium
join:2001-11-26
Earth
kudos:19
reply to ekster
This is a logic-based game. Even though logic cleared only me and it looks "suspect" to clear only myself, it cannot be disputed. Feel free to try though. I went through and objectively looked through everyone.

The results cannot hold up if I am mafia. There is no way to safely put everyone into a role in which that scenario holds true.

There is a scenario possible for everyone else. That is fine and normal for Day 1, so nobody needs to get all FUD'y defensive.
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK


Archivis
Your Daddy
Premium
join:2001-11-26
Earth
kudos:19
Vote: Night


ekster
Hi there
Premium
join:2010-07-16
Lachine, QC
kudos:3
reply to ekster
And night it is

Cops, send me your investigations, docs, send me your protections,
townies, do nothing.

I kid about the docs and townies, by the way, before anyone's head explodes.


ekster
Hi there
Premium
join:2010-07-16
Lachine, QC
kudos:3
Arch is dead. He was a bum.

IT IS DAY


Kristopher
Tarquin
Premium
join:2002-10-11
Tyrinaria
kudos:4
Guilty on Brom.

We'll get nothing on Arch being dead, so it'll be interesting to see who investigated him.
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
I got an innocent on Kristopher.


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
Innocent on KrisN


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
I'm going to assume that makes me Naive I guess? Or possibly Sane?


Kristopher
Tarquin
Premium
join:2002-10-11
Tyrinaria
kudos:4
2 innocents. Naive or Sane.


Kristopher
Tarquin
Premium
join:2002-10-11
Tyrinaria
kudos:4
Wait, Naive, Sane, or Insane. I'll have more once we get KrisN's result.
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
How can Ada be insane and have two Innocent's? Wouldn't that mean there would be two mafia?


Krisnatharok
Caveat Emptor
Premium
join:2009-02-11
Earth Orbit
kudos:12
reply to ekster
I got a guilty on Adalicia. That means either he or Brom is mafia, depending on whether I am sane/insane.


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
I think you're lying. Ada has to be naive now.


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
reply to Krisnatharok
It's between KrisN and myself I think. Arch and KrisT are Insane/Paranoid and Ada is Naive. Does that make sense? So lynch one of us today and the other the next day.


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
reply to Krisnatharok
This is what I have thus far:

Krisnatharok:

Day One: Brom - Innocent
Day Two: Adalicia - Guilty

Either: Sane or Insane

Kristopher

Day One: Adalicia - Guilty
Day Two: Brom - Guilty

Either: Paranoid or Insane

Archivis

Day One: Adalicia - Guilty
Day Two: Dead

Either: Paranoid or Insane

Adalicia

Day One: Archivis - Innocent
Day Two: Krisnatharok - Innocent

Either: Naive or Sane

Brom

Day One: Krisnatharok - Guilty
Day Two: Kristopher - Innocent

Either: Sane or Insane

So..I have no idea? I think I'm naive but I dunno, I could be sane I guess?

KrisN is either Insane or Mafia, cause I know I'm a cop. Kristopher is either Paranoid or Mafia. Archivis HAD to be Paranoid or Insane, cause I know I'm a cop, which means either KrisN or KrisT is lying...once more, and I'll bet money Brom is sane.

Meaning:

KrisN = Mafia
Kristopher = Paranoid
Archivis = Insane
Adalicia = Naive
Brom = Sane
--
Lore Nerd. Role Player. Raid Leader. Healing Priest. Slightly Annoying. Also Likes Kittens.


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
I agree with this and am ready to lynch KrisN but want to wait for KrisT's input.


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
reply to Adalicia
Brom appears to agree before I typed all that out and I can't see any problem with the logic...soooo...

vote: KrisN
--
Lore Nerd. Role Player. Raid Leader. Healing Priest. Slightly Annoying. Also Likes Kittens.


Krisnatharok
Caveat Emptor
Premium
join:2009-02-11
Earth Orbit
kudos:12
reply to Brom
I'm cool with that. I'll take one for the team.


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
Ok, yeah I reviewed my logic and it seems to make sense so

Vote: KrisN


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
If KrisN is a cop it means he can only be insane.

Which means Archivis had to be Paranoid.

Which means Kristopher is Mafia, you're sane, and I'm naive.
--
Lore Nerd. Role Player. Raid Leader. Healing Priest. Slightly Annoying. Also Likes Kittens.


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
But if he was insane then you're Mafia...

What the fucking shit. This crap makes my head hurt. He has to be mafia. :S
--
Lore Nerd. Role Player. Raid Leader. Healing Priest. Slightly Annoying. Also Likes Kittens.


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
reply to Adalicia
No, because if KrisN was insane, I'd be the mafia because he got an innocent on me.


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
Yeah, but if he is insane, it doesn't jive with everything else and would point at Kristopher and you...because Archivis has to be Paranoid if KrisN is insane, which makes Kristopher...Mafia...and...you...Mafia...so...

So...KrisN has to be mafia? Right? AMIDOINITRITE?!
--
Lore Nerd. Role Player. Raid Leader. Healing Priest. Slightly Annoying. Also Likes Kittens.


Brom
Let's go Bucs

join:2010-10-26
Pittsburgh, PA
Haha, uh yeah, you're doing it right as far as I can see. I'm a noob to Dethy as well. I basically narrowed it down by KrisN's guilty on you makes him insane, but his innocent on me makes that impossible cause I know I'm a cop..so he's lying. So unless someone else screwed up their results, it has to be KrisN.


Adalicia
Om Nom Nom

join:2009-10-13
Lincoln, NE
kudos:13
Yeah, I'm going to be lazy and use Archivis' brain:

Scenario: Kristopher is guilty

(Insane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(FAKE) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(Insane/Paranoid) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

Everything jives except you and KrisN. So Kristopher can't be mafia.

---------------

Scenario: Brom is guilty

(Insane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(Insane/Paranoid) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(Insane/Naive) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(FAKE) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

This can't work because Archivis has to be Insane or Paranoid, Kristopher has to be Insane or Paranoid, and Kris would have to be Insane.

---------------

Scenario: Adalicia is guilty

(Sane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(FAKE) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(Sane/Paranoid) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(Insane/Paranoid) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

I can't be it because there obviously isn't anyone else that is naive...

---------------

Scenario: Krisnatharok is guilty

(Insane/Paranoid) Archivis: Guilty on Adalicia
(Sane/Naive) Adalicia: Innocent on Archivis
(Insane/Paranoid) Kristopher: Guilty on Adalicia
(FAKE) Krisnatharok: Innocent on Brom
(Sane/Paranoid) Brom: Guilty on Krisnatharok

This is the only one that makes sense, right?
--
Lore Nerd. Role Player. Raid Leader. Healing Priest. Slightly Annoying. Also Likes Kittens.