Talk > Pub Games > [game] Dethy 4

reply to tmodelt

Re: [game] Dethy 4

I say... tmodelt

Vote: tmodelt

I'm going to do the same. He was the last one to submit a result and Jobbie attempted to try and logic this out. tmo didnt

Vote: tmodelt
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

reply to Kristopher
wow way to give the game to mafia. Did you guys not look at the results?

reply to Archivis
I gave my logic look at the results from your investigations. DUH

DUH

Point it out for us, then.

Unvote: tmodelt

He's claiming that three guilty results on Jobbie means he HAS to be guilty. I don't see how that's possible as there are three ways it's not true.. if the three "results" come from the following roles: paranoid, insane, scum.

As tmodelt is one of the three people with a guilty "result" on Jobbie, he has a vested interest.

Playing the "tmodelt is scum" scenario out... it's logically possible.

ekster: insane/paranoid
Jobbie: naive
drew: sane
Archivis: insane/paranoid
tmodelt: scum
--
flickr | Of faith, power and glory

reply to drew
Actually... how CAN jobbie be scum?

Play the "Jobbie is scum" scenario out...

If he's scum, only three people could possibly be insane cops: ekster, Archivis and tmodelt. I can't be insane because I retrieved two innocent results and there aren't two guilty people in the game. Jobbie can't be insane because he's scum. But if the three people who have guilty results on jobbie are the only people who can be insane, how can he be scum?

Hope that makes sense...
--
flickr | Of faith, power and glory

I really believe my logic is sound on that.

Playing from that... Both the Arch = scum and tmodelt = scum options are viable.

If Arch = scum:
ekster: paranoid
jobbie: sane
drew: naive
archivis: scum
tmodelt: insane

If tmodelt = scum
ekster: insane/paranoid
jobbie: naive
drew: sane
archivis: insane/paranoid
tmodelt: scum

Does one more night get us any closer to a successful lynch for town?
--
flickr | Of faith, power and glory

I think we can go one more night is not like our chances are going to improve a whole lot.

Nope. Drew is the logical night kill.

Did you check my logic on how jobbie CAN'T be mafia?

Vote: Night

Lets see what happens.

reply to drew
Nope, you're right.

Vote: tmodelt

It was him and if I were mafia, I'm pretty sure I had an opportunity to hammer him a while ago.
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

here you go let me show you "Seasoned Vets" I am a cop
vote:Tmo

reply to Kristopher
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand tmo is dead and he was a cop. Guess who won.

GG all. That was well played by Arch, but I'm surprised you guys didn't go after him as he screwed up the percentages by incorporating Jobbie into the "suspect" list. Oh well.
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games

GG all and thanks for hosting!

trololololol

reply to Kristopher