Talk > Pub Games > [game] Dethy 7

reply to Jobbie

Re: [game] Dethy 7

Tmod: Jobbie/Guilty, KrisN/Guilty
Drew: Jobbie/inno
Jobbie: Tmod/guilty, Arch/guilty
KrisN: Arch/guilty, Jobbie/guilty
Arch: Tmod/inno, Drew/inno

reply to Archivis
To recap, Jobbie cannot be scum because it would make both Tmod and I the paranoid cop.

You cannot be guilty because it would make both me and Jobbie the Paranoid cop.

If Tmod is scum, roles pan out easily:

Drew is sane
Jobbie is paranoid
KrisN is insane
Arch is naive

If I am scum...

Tmod is paranoid
Drew is sane OR naive
Jobbie is insane
Arch is sane OR naive
--
If we lose this freedom of ours, history will record with the greatest astonishment, those who had the most to lose, did the least to prevent its happening.

reply to Archivis
Here's my predictions, since Tmod goofed.

Tonight...
Tmod will investigate Arch (guilty, making it up as paranoid)
Jobbie will investigate me (guilty, paranoid)
I will investigate Tmod (inno, insane)
Arch will investigate Jobbie or me (inno, naive)

Jobbie will die, since letting him survive means we have a logic conflict between Jobbie (confirmed town, confirmed Paranoid) and Tmod (claiming Paranoid).

Where Tmod messed up is investigating both me AND Jobbie and finding both of us guilty. If he went inno on either of us, he could have claimed Insane and tried to mirror that role.

However, since he is mirroring Jobbie, and Jobbie is confirmed town, Jobbie HAS to die tonight and leave it between Tmod (claiming paranoid), me (the accused scum), and Arch (naive, confirmed town).

Doing anything else means a logic lynch on Tmod.
--
If we lose this freedom of ours, history will record with the greatest astonishment, those who had the most to lose, did the least to prevent its happening.

I like where this is going.

Vote: Night

Need night votes from Arch and tmod.

reply to ekster
Sorry a little busy today
vote:Night

reply to Jobbie

Not Silent just busy.

reply to ekster
Here's what I got.

TMO GUILTY
Tmod: Jobbie/Guilty, KrisN/Guilty
Drew: Jobbie/inno (Sane)
Jobbie: Tmod/guilty, Arch/guilty (Paranoid)
KrisN: Arch/guilty, Jobbie/guilty (Insane)
Arch: Tmod/inno, Drew/inno (Naive)

Result: Possible

JOBBIE GUILTY
Tmod: Jobbie/Guilty, KrisN/Guilty (Paranoid)
Drew: Jobbie/inno (Insane/Naive)
Jobbie: Tmod/guilty, Arch/guilty
KrisN: Arch/guilty, Jobbie/guilty (Paranoid)
Arch: Tmod/inno, Drew/inno (Sane/Naive)

Result: Two forced Paranoid

KRISN GUILTY
Tmod: Jobbie/Guilty, KrisN/Guilty (Paranoid)
Drew: Jobbie/inno (Sane/Naive)
Jobbie: Tmod/guilty, Arch/guilty (Paranoid/Insane)
KrisN: Arch/guilty, Jobbie/guilty
Arch: Tmod/inno, Drew/inno (Sane/Naive)

Result: Possible

ARCH GUILTY
Fuck you, I'm not guilty.
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

I don't see how going to night saves anyone. Jobbie or myself die and then we're back to the same situation tomorrow. You two make up predictable results and it's game. If TMO is guilty, I'm confirmed naive. Jobbie dies and meh.

If Krisn is mafia, Jobbie dies and there's a 50/50 I'm Sane.
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

I am all for lynching Tmod today as from my perspective, it's me, two known towns, and him.

However, I can't prove my innocence until tomorrow, when I investigate him and get the innocent result, but at that time it's his word vs. mine.

vote tmod

It's a 50/50 shot today for both of you and tomorrow for you.
--
If we lose this freedom of ours, history will record with the greatest astonishment, those who had the most to lose, did the least to prevent its happening.

There is a slight chance in which we may be able to provide more clear results tomorrow.

Vote: Night
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

reply to Archivis
If I am mafia, and we go to night,

Tmod investigates Arch and gets guilty (paranoid)
Jobbie investigates me and gets inno (insane)
You investigate me and get either guilty (sane) or inno (naive). You wouldn't investigate Jobbie because he is known town.

If you are sane, I am screwed as I can't kill both you and Jobbie, and the survivor can out me the next day.

If you are naive, I know both you (naive) and Tmod (paranoid) can't detect affiliation and I kill Jobbie and have to sell you on killing Tmod.

But since Tmod is scum from my perspective, I have to sell you on killing him anyways, and if he is scum, you are also naive anyways.

If I am scum, I should vote night, as it's easier to convince just one of you to lynch Tmod.
--
If we lose this freedom of ours, history will record with the greatest astonishment, those who had the most to lose, did the least to prevent its happening.

reply to Archivis

Ah nevermind, you're talking about....

NIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGHT

DAY

And Arch joined drew. He was....

Do you want to ride with Batman?

reply to ekster
I got Inno on Tmod, which makes me the insane cop, and him scum.

vote tmod

I wonder what roleclaim Tmod is going to make. Jobbie will have investigated me and gotten guilty (third guilty, Paranoid), so I want to see Tmod make a Paranoid claim.

/popcorn
--
If we lose this freedom of ours, history will record with the greatest astonishment, those who had the most to lose, did the least to prevent its happening.