ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
to Chaplain
Re: [game] Children of DuneI'm trying to find a scenario in which I can fully confirm myself, or that we can safely get results. If I investigate, i lose a protect. If I protect, I lose an investigate (until the following day). |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 1:37 pm
I don't know how to keep tmod from losing his investigation due to my hunch that they have a roleblocker on their team. GH, Assassin, RB is normal. So, even if we go No Lynch, we're at the same spot tomorrow with one less player. And it'll be one of the confirmed townies, so that's no good. I think we have to lynch today. |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
If both Arch and Tmod investigate, they'll role-block you and kill one, or role-block one and attempt to kill the other.
Either way, it's 50/50 for town and mafia.
I think we need to lynch Dez or Meng, and investigate the other tonight (maybe both Arch and Tmod investigate the survivor?). |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 1:41 pm
Which one, Dez or Men? |
|
ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
to Chaplain
Since you're calling the shots, you make the move. I still think Krisnatharok needs to go. Lynch or lose, it's a race to see who gets the other team to L1 and mafia has the advantage there. Krisnatharok just votes.
His job is to survive, so he can say all the shit he wants about helping the town. Mafia isn't going to kill a survivor because there are more valuable roles, so it's a perfect claim to last until the end. All the survivor has to do is plea it out with the town.
Even if I'm wrong and he's actually a survivor, it's still a better scenario than a town lynch. |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
to Chaplain
IDC, as Arch said, I just vote. But I am trying to win with town, by revealing my role, and attempting to logic down who is highest on town's suspect list. |
|
ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
Exodus
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 1:47 pm
Kristopher forced all to role claim. You hesitated, remember? |
|
Exodus |
Exodus
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 1:47 pm
Also, congrats on 20k posts. |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
to Exodus
said by Exodus:Kristopher forced all to role claim. You hesitated, remember? Of course I hesitated. |
|
Krisnatharok |
You can lynch me tomorrow if there's no better option, but for now I'm willing to lynch a mafia, so you may as well use my vote. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
to Exodus
I understand. If we lynch and he is the survivor, then there should only be 2 mafia, and we still have another day. If we lynch and he's mafia, we're in an even better spot. Your logic is sound. Even if you are mafia, this is the best move for the town today. Vote: KrisNIf there are 3 mafia and a survivor, I know a certain Canadian who needs to learn the 25% rule. |
|
Chaplain |
to Exodus
20K posts in 3 freaking years. Jebus. On a side note, went to the local hat shop/shoe shine. I think I'm going home with a cowboy hat today. |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
to Chaplain
very well then. Arch brought you onboard, I see.
Don't count him out, as he could be the mafia roleblocker and it was he he blocked the cop on night 1.
vote KrisN |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to Exodus
Grats on the 20k man damn have to catch up. |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
to Chaplain
I still think this puts town in a worse position tomorrow, as you can't clear both Dez and Meng. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 1:56 pm
It's the same as no lynch, essentially. It gives us the info we need. If you are indie, we know there are 2 mafia left. If you are mafia, we did good. Better than No Lynch due to the amount of info.
Tmod - Investigate Men or Dez. I'll protect you. Arch, do what you want. Don't hint at what it is going to be, though. We need some element of surprise, at least. |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
So how is a no lynch better than killing Dez or Meng? It's likely they're both mafia. |
|
|
to Chaplain
I will go along with this plan
vote: krisnatharok |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to Chaplain
said by Chaplain:It's the same as no lynch, essentially. It gives us the info we need. If you are indie, we know there are 2 mafia left. If you are mafia, we did good. Better than No Lynch due to the amount of info. I had the same reasoning in my post above. Vote: KrisN |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
to Krisnatharok
What if we get the wrong one? What if Arch is mafia with Dez, or Arch is mafia with Men. Too risky. The info from you is better. If you are the survivor, then sorry. If not, then good on us. But the info will be there for tomorrow.
I'm dead tonight, or Arch. Pretty sure of it. Especially since I've been pushing this. |
|
Chaplain |
to Jobbie
Yeah, but it was one sentence and I didn't quite get it at first. I'm eating a BARITO right now. I will take picture. |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 1:59 pm
Official Vote Count Players needed to lynch: 5
Kristopher - 1 - Meningitis (L-4) Krisnatharok - 5 - Archivis, Kristopher, Krisnatharok, Dezbend, Jobbie (L-0)
Players not voting: Blockfire, tmodelt
NIGHTFALL |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
to Chaplain
If Arch is mafia you're dead.
gg |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 2:07 pm
Town got all happy and active all of a sudden and everything became clear. They knew what to do. Plus Krisnatharok started acting weird, and was talking in a funny voice... a voice that everyone recognized as an enemy of the Atreides.
He had become an abomination and the memories of his ancestors took over him, with Vladimir Harkonnen taking over. As [krisnatharok] failed to resist, the abomination had to be put down.
Krisnatharok Alia Atreides/Vladimir Harkonnen SurvivorYou are the survivor. You are not allowed private communications. You win by surviving. IT IS NIGHT |
|
ekster |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 3:18 pm
|
|
ExodusYour Daddy Premium Member join:2001-11-26 Earth |
Exodus
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 3:19 pm
Town awoke, so this is day, or what's going on? |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
ekster
Premium Member
2012-Mar-15 3:19 pm
Exodus - Princess Wensicia Mafia RolebockerYou are the Mafia Roleblocker. Each night you get to pick one person to block. You may communicate privately with your partners Dezbend and Jobbie You win with the Mafia. Dezbend - Scytale Mafia Day AssassinYou are the Mafia Day Assassin. You can PM the mod one person to kill during the Day. This is a one time use ability. You may communicate privately with your partners Exodus and Jobbie You win with the Mafia. Jobbie - Javid Mafia GodfatherYou are the Mafia Godfather. You send in the Night Kill orders. You show up innocent on Investigations. You may communicate privately with your partners Dezbend and Exodus You win with the Mafia. Krisnatharok Alia Atreides/Vladimir Harkonnen SurvivorYou are the survivor. You are not allowed private communications. You win by surviving. tmodelt - Duncan Idaho InvestigatorYou are the Town Investigator. You can investigate one person per night to see if they are a innocent or guilty. You are not allowed private communications. You win with the Town. Chaplain - Stilgard DocYou are the Town Doc. You can choose to protect one person each day. You cannot target yourself. You are not allowed private communications. You win with the Town. Blockgorilla - Leto Atreides II TownieYou are allowed private communications with Prevailer You win with the Town. mod note: Vengeance: If partner is killed, receives a kill that must be used during night or be lost. Prevailer - Ghanima Atreides TownieYou are allowed private communications with Blockgorilla You win with the Town. mod note: Vengeance: If partner is killed, receives a kill that must be used during night or be lost. Brom - Lady Jessica Town RoleblockerYou are the Town Roleblocker. Each night you get to pick one person to block. You are not allowed private communications. You win with the Town. DrModem - Gurney Halleck Town Night VigilanteYou are the Town Night Vigilante. You can PM the mod (anytime) one person to kill during the Night. This is a one time use ability. You are not allowed private communications. You win with the Town. Adalicia - Princess Irulan TownieYou are not allowed private communications. You win with the Town. Meningitis - Farad'n Corrino TownieYou are not allowed private communications. You win with the Town. Day 1/Night 1 No lynch tmodelt investigates Dezbend (blocked) Kristopher protects Meningitis (blocked) Brom blocks tmodelt Archivis attempts to block Antonica at first... then goes with Kristopher Mafia kills DrModem Day 2/Night 2 ProtusMose is lynched tmodelt investigates Jobbie Kristopher protects Brom (blocked) Brom blocks Jobbie Archivis kicks Kristopher in the junk, resulting in a block Mafia kills Adalicia (blocked) Blockfire kills Adalicia with vengeance Day 3/Night 3 Dezbend shoots Brom Krisnatharok is lynched tmodelt investigates Archivis (blocked) Kristopher protects tmodelt Archivis blocks tmodelt Mafia kills Kristopher Mafia wins |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
to Exodus
Someone didn't follow the 25% rule. That's what happened. |
|
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
to Exodus
Vote: Arch
^Scum |
|
eksterHi there Premium Member join:2010-07-16 Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, QC |
to Exodus
said by Exodus:Town awoke, so this is day, or what's going on? No more town! |
|