dslreports logo
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc
uniqs
22
Kenbass
join:2007-05-10
Athol, MA

Kenbass to boaterbob

Member

to boaterbob

Re: Heat pump - inside temp 10 degrees higher than set point

First of all Rheem equipment is much worse than Carrier. Second of all, 3.5 tons for 2800SF? Wow grossly undersized. Rule of thumb if you want to be comfortable is 4-500 SF per ton. You do the math.

jrs8084
Premium Member
join:2002-03-02
Statesville, NC

jrs8084

Premium Member

said by Kenbass:

First of all Rheem equipment is much worse than Carrier. Second of all, 3.5 tons for 2800SF? Wow grossly undersized. Rule of thumb if you want to be comfortable is 4-500 SF per ton. You do the math.

Last I knew is that there are far more variables that determine proper sizing of HVAC equipment than square footage.

Ken
MVM
join:2003-06-16
Markle, IN

Ken to Kenbass

MVM

to Kenbass
said by Kenbass:

Second of all, 3.5 tons for 2800SF? Wow grossly undersized. Rule of thumb if you want to be comfortable is 4-500 SF per ton. You do the math.

All the old rules of thumb are dead. Yes in the past many installers went by that, but today it's impossible to have any simple formula to determine what the correct size system should be.

You build a 2800SF house with 2x4 walls, 3.5" of fiberglass in the wall, large windows with a low R value, and vinyl siding. I build a 2800SF house with 2x6 walls, 5.5" of spray foam in the walls, small windows with a high R value, and a brick exterior. Do you think our two houses are going to need anywhere near the same size system installed?

The only way to determine what size system you need is to take all the variables into account and then determine the correct size (manual J calculation). 3.5 tons could be grossly oversized for 2800sf under the right circumstances.