Porn Copyright Troll Sues AT&T, Comcast > You know, this should happen more often

The fair way to do it is have you pick a speed tier and a usage tier. Then the 3Mbs would not be subsidizing the expense for the faster speed or the heavy users if they are not a heavy user. Now when they do upgrades the lower tiers bill increase even when though they may not be creating more demands on the system.

The current setup worked in the past because your equipment and the content provider did not have equipment that would handle the speeds and usage you can today.

They could go to a system like the power company bill by the bit or byte.