Give it up, already!
These idiots just need to realize that their plan isn't going to work. I'm all for having competition, but they decided to try to start this venture on the cheap, and when that fell apart, now they want to get bailed out. Well guys, you screwed up, but it's not too late to go out and find a useful slice of spectrum to buy. Oh, you have no money left because you squandered it all on your schemes and gyrations? Oh well...
My mom had many pieces of advice, and one of them was that, when you try to do something on the cheap, you usually end up paying more in the long run. I guess these guys never received that advice or didn't bother to listen.
Mullica Hill, NJ
They seem to forget that not all business ventures can be a success.
[65 Arcanist]Filan(High Elf) Zone: Broadband Reports
That, and I think they feel that they're connected enough that someone will go to bat for them and pull the right strings. This whole scenario is very similar to that of Northpoint, which was run by some folks with DC connections who wanted to build a terrestrial TV/data network that would have interfered with DBS service. Even after independent testing confirmed that the interference was real and that there was no way to mitigate it, they still kept flailing around and spending political capital trying to get the FCC to give them permission to build it in spite of the test results.
NorthPoint? I thought NorthPoint was a CLEC ISP that went bankrupt, later split up and then shut down by the ILECs?
I think that was another company, as the name is familiar in my distant memory. But this was a different company. What they wanted to do was to build transmission sites that would operate on the same frequencies used by DBS. They proposed to make this work by placing the sites north of the towns they wanted to serve, so, since dishes generally point south or southwest, they'd be pointed away from the transmitters in most cases, and I suppose the transmitters were going to be directional, only transmitting toward the south to protect dish owners located north of them. As soon as this news came out, many people worried that this scheme would interfere with DBS, which prompted Northpoint to announce some sort of dish retrofit kit that was supposed to prevent it. Still, people were worried that this solution wouldn't work, so the FCC arranged for a third party organization to do testing to determine if there would be interference. The testing found that, although interference could be reduced, it couldn't be eliminated, and it would effectively wipe out satellite reception for some people. Northpoint's reaction was that the testing was biased, and there were rumors that they were trying to call in favors to get the FCC to disregard the test results and let them proceed anyway. Apparently, that strategy didn't work, and the company faded away.
Ahhh... I didn't realize there was another NorthPoint.
»en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MVDDS_dispute (Northpoint Technology)
»en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NorthPoint···ications (my first association as well)