 Smith6612Premium,MVM join:2008-02-01 North Tonawanda, NY kudos:22 Reviews:
·Verizon Online DSL
·Frontier Communi..
| reply to COjosh
Re: [DSL] drop outs, connection interupted....multiple service c I wonder what is causing the drops when on ADSL2+ and I have a feeling I've asked this question a few months ago. It almost sounds like a profile configuration issue if drops are occurring while on an ADSL2+ card but not while on an ADSL card. OP also doesn't seem to be close enough to have Far End interference occur but I'm also not a line tech so I wouldn't know how far out you've seen such issues occur.
Strange. I wonder what the outcome of this issue will be. |
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T U-Verse
| The FEXT issue was experienced w/ subs generally within 4k feet or so, on VDSL2 mind you, and the ADSL2 problem seems to have been mostly less than 6.5k feet.
As far as why the ADSL2 anomoly, I really have no idea. I HAVE heard, however, that it has to do with how "hot" the SNR comes to the far-end modem. Most subs, on 3Meg, should be provisioned on an ADSL card as opposed to an ADSL2 that can provide faster sync rates and "louder" SNR values...at least that's the way I understand it, I could very well be wrong..
The OP does indeed appear to be further out than that..
Again, a shot in the dark, no more no less.. |
|
 Smith6612Premium,MVM join:2008-02-01 North Tonawanda, NY kudos:22 | Good to know. Thanks for the info! Never hurts to take a shot in the dark. |
|
 | reply to COjosh
Just want to say thanks for all of your input. It is appreciated.
Four screen shots, ATM, DSL, and 2 of ADSL , taken when it is working normally. 17 hours runtime. |
|
 | Screen shots of Pingplotter, ATM, DSL, and 1/2 screen of ADSL at point of dropping connection (Other 1/2 on next message). Connection was down 5 minutes then came back up.... |
|
 | 2nd half of ADSL screen shot when connection was down, and pingplotter when connection was restored 5 minutes later.... |
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T U-Verse
| reply to wchill09 It's not like you're taking a ton of FEC's right before, or even leading up to, when the modem goes down..weird
It also doesn't look like any of the DSL stats fluctuate AT ALL during the period of time these screen shots were taken.
To be honest, I'm stumped...There are a SOME discard packets on the ATM side but nothing too unusual..
I'm of the opinion that this isn't copper trouble at all, at least not currently.
Does the DSL light actually go out/start to flash, or are we dealing with the Internet light going out but DSL staying solid?
From all the info you provided in the screen shots it would seem to be the later.. |
|
 | said by COjosh:It's not like you're taking a ton of FEC's right before, or even leading up to, when the modem goes down..weird
It also doesn't look like any of the DSL stats fluctuate AT ALL during the period of time these screen shots were taken.
To be honest, I'm stumped...There are a SOME discard packets on the ATM side but nothing too unusual..
I'm of the opinion that this isn't copper trouble at all, at least not currently.
Does the DSL light actually go out/start to flash, or are we dealing with the Internet light going out but DSL staying solid?
From all the info you provided in the screen shots it would seem to be the later.. Yes, the DSL light stays solid green but the internet light drops out. Occasionally it will turn red but not always....just goes out. Wait about 5 minutes and it will come back up or power cycle the modem and it will come up immediately. |
|
 Smith6612Premium,MVM join:2008-02-01 North Tonawanda, NY kudos:22 Reviews:
·Verizon Online DSL
·Frontier Communi..
4 edits | Sounds like a key circuit is bouncing and failover is not going smoothly or getting a problem that is resulting in a ton of communication errors. If this is the case, a circuit should not be encountering an issue that often. Anyone nearby you seeing the same issue at all?
Some more food for thought. Before a family relative of mine moved to Cable Internet, they had Verizon DSL service that could operate at no more than 1.5Mbps/384kbps due to their line being 2.7 miles out from the remote. They were fed off of a Catena Remote Terminal with Integrated ADSL DSLAM which was fed by OC-12 fiber and demuxed to T3(or multiple T3s). This is a pretty old remote and had a fair amount of users on it, and it's age might account for the T3 connection. At random, the DSLAM would seem to stop working correctly where it would retrain every single line endlessly for up to a few hours at a time almost as if the unit was rebooting due to a fault. Phone service would continue to work without a single problem. This went on for about a year. After that was fixed, or so they say my relatives started noticing their Internet slowing down towards the night time hours. Towards the last few months of their service with Verizon being active the connection got to the point where it was nearly unusable at night, and PPP sessions would drop. I found out the circuit to the remote my relative was running through had been running at >90% capacity for a good handful of days each month. Their Ping Plotter looked just like yours too.
As on the previous page you posted some horrible ping results, I wonder if this is in fact a connectivity issue back at the DSLAM. If connectivity is having problems you won't lose sync but you will lose all connectivity that must transit back to the Central Office and isn't hosted locally by equipment at the DSL source. I don't know if you'll explicitly see ATM errors when this happens but if this is an IP DSLAM, you won't see that happen anyways due to the conversion from IP --- ATM at the DSLAM itself. |
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T U-Verse
| reply to wchill09 What Smith mentioned: "a circuit should not be encountering an issue that often. Anyone nearby you seeing the same issue at all?"
I think that's the nail on the head..any of your neighbors having the same problem?
Depending on how the various circuits make it back to the local aggregator and then to the POP, more people than you should be having similar issues. It IS possible that traffic out of your CO may be routed to more places than just one, yours being the circuit more impacted by the problem than the others.
I'd bet that this is a known problem and may be symptomatic of good ol' fashioned congestion... |
|
|
|
 | said by COjosh:I think that's the nail on the head..any of your neighbors having the same problem?
more people than you should be having similar issues. It IS possible that traffic out of your CO may be routed to more places than just one, yours being the circuit more impacted by the problem than the others.
I'd bet that this is a known problem and may be symptomatic of good ol' fashioned congestion... Of the numerous service calls I have had, I was fortunate to get the same tech 3 different times. He said that 42 people are fed from the box and to his knowledge they aren't having issues.....but yet my disconnects continue....The disconnects don't appear to be timely, as in regular. I've just installed the standard version of pingplotter to see if I can get a grip on frequency....Any other programs out there that will do a 24 hour timeline on connection down/uptime......? |
|
 Smith6612Premium,MVM join:2008-02-01 North Tonawanda, NY kudos:22 Reviews:
·Verizon Online DSL
·Frontier Communi..
2 edits | said by wchill09:Of the numerous service calls I have had, I was fortunate to get the same tech 3 different times. He said that 42 people are fed from the box and to his knowledge they aren't having issues.....but yet my disconnects continue....The disconnects don't appear to be timely, as in regular. I've just installed the standard version of pingplotter to see if I can get a grip on frequency....Any other programs out there that will do a 24 hour timeline on connection down/uptime......? Ideally Frontier's equipment should be able to keep track of your line completely, down to why a PPPoE session fails or why a line is dropping, and what happened to cause it along with how your circuit is built end to end. Verizon has this in place for the physical circuit aspect, which is part of how their optimization system works. They keep a history of your line's physical performance and the system calculates what would be ideal for your line based on that history, and current statistics. They should also have circuit monitoring in place for QoS and SLA purposes (not that SLA explicitly applies here, but they should be maintaining an SLA on their own gear). If your gear at least supports SNMP or some other form of monitoring there's open source software out there that is very robust for such applications, or MRTG for that matter. Your gear isn't expensive for just any reason after all. For 24 hour monitoring I wouldn't have any suggestions in this department unfortunately. |
|
 | Thanks for the info. I will see what I can find to track this. After installing the standard version of pingplotter it showed an outage from 3:46 to 3:52. The next outage was from 4:22-4:27. I want to have all of my data documented before calling support again....This screen shot is of the second outage... |
|
 | reply to COjosh said by COjosh:What Smith mentioned: "a circuit should not be encountering an issue that often. Anyone nearby you seeing the same issue at all?"
I think that's the nail on the head..any of your neighbors having the same problem?
Depending on how the various circuits make it back to the local aggregator and then to the POP, more people than you should be having similar issues. I'd bet that this is a known problem and may be symptomatic of good ol' fashioned congestion... My close neighbors are still on Sprint, which at this point I regret leaving......I did post a message earlier today on a local board asking others with their DSL experience in this geographical area and have one response back so far. Granted it could be anyone answering, stating anything so it is strictly an unscientific polling but here is the reply...
"My parents live in onondaga tompkins area and the same service and it sucks. Slow and crashes and sometimes don't work at all"
Sent from Yahoo! Mail on Android
This pretty much sums up my experience....
Thanks again for your input on this. It is valued and appreciated. |
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T U-Verse
| That second hop would be the aggregator, the third being the virtual interface at your region's POP...I think that's the way it goes...
During this screen shot of your outage, those two points are the problem.
I would say that it's a card issue on the aggregator, not the local RT. No way to tell from the outside if the problem is w/ the physical circuit or the hardware itself.
What's funny about this is that the help desk tech that you speak to on the phone should be able to see the loss of connectivity at Layer 3 and escalate the problem to the MCO...which is essentially Tier 2 or whatever you want to call it...
Has the field tech ever contacted anybody on the phone regarding your problem? I'm sure he did when he changed ports for you but I'm talking about since then. I highly doubt this is anything an FT can fix. |
|
 | Just wanted to post an update....found a program called ping tester and am trying it out. Seems to be doing a good job of keeping track of the data....I set it to ping google.com every 30 seconds so I could generate enough data to help see what was happening. Screen shot is posted above. The cumulative average for 12 hours runtime is showing 10.24% loss rate. I would think it should be near zero if the connection was up all the time....and reliable....Is my logic correct? Is the loss rate reflecting the loss of connection? Just need to understand this before calling support again....If this indicates 10% downtime of the connection is that normal/abnormal for DSL? Thanks for your input. |
|