Talk > Pub Games > [game] Dethy 18

reply to Jobbie

Re: [game] Dethy 18

reply to Jobbie
GG everyone. If I would not have investigated Arch, it would have been a 50/50 choice.
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games

reply to Archivis
Kris Mafia
Block: Naive
Gogg: Paranoid
Arch: Insane
tmodelt: Sane
Result: Possible Mafia but not actually mafia
(Arch screwed this up earlier, whether or not it was on purpose is up in the air for me)

Arch Mafia
Block: Naive
Kris: Sane
Gogg: Paranoid
tmodelt: Insane
Result: Mafia to me as I know I'm a cop

tmodelt Mafia
Block: Naive
Kris: Insane
Gogg: Paranoid
Arch: Insane - Conflicting Result
Result: tmodelt can't be mafia

So it's still a 50/50, but it's up to tmod at this point. Did I miss anything?
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games

Nope, your logic is good.

Vote: Archivis

/surrender

I should have taken you and tmodelt out since you were the Sane cop and tmodelt was the insane cop. I also shouldn't have forged a result that pigeon-holed me into sane/insane only.
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

Early game suicide because Kristopher is right and I really only have no choice but to vote for tmodelt since Kris is already confirmed and I won't be on the Internet for a few hours (days?).
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

I'm not confirmed, I don't think. I appreciate the concession, but my notes say you could have 50/50'd with me as the sane cop. We both got an innocent on tmod, I think.
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games

reply to Archivis
Kristopher kept poking at Archivis until he could not stand it anymore down took his own gun and yelled "MAFIA FOR THE WIN!!!!" and blew his brains out, he was the mafia among them"

COPS WIN
--
Judge a man by the trials of his shield, not the empty reaping of his sword.

reply to Kristopher
You were confirmed yesterday. I did the logic, I know the roles.

My statement about throwing the game yesterday still holds true. Lay off the hunches until the logic is done. If I were town, mafia would play off of it.
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

GG all and thanks for playing.

reply to Archivis
You were wrong yesterday. I'll keep my notes so we can compare when you have more time. I'll post them up here now though.

Kristopher - Guilty on Arch, Innocent on tmod
Gogg - Guilty on tmod
Archivis - Innocent on tmod, Guilty on Brom
tmod - Guilty on Kristopher, Innocent on Archivis
Brom - Innocent on Gogg, Innocent on Archivis

Automatically, we know that Block is Naive and Gogg is Paranoid. Drop them from the list.

Here, you and I both have an innocent on tmod and a guilty on another player (Mine is on you). tmod has a guilty on me, and an innocent on you. Sure, we know he's insane now, but let's make him sane for sense of argument and me mafia. That makes you insane, and me trying to fake insane to make the 50/50. You had a chance, unless I'm missing something or have an incorrect result.
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games

My notes from yesterday. Due to RL stuffs, I didn't think it through. I should have killed you.

Block: I on Gogg
Kris: I on Tmo
Gogg: G on Tmo
Arch: Inno on tmo
tmodelt: G on Kris
-=-=-
Gogg Dead
Block: I on Arch
Arch: G on Block
tmodelt: I on Arch
Kris: Null

-=-=-=-
BlocK Mafia
Kris: Naive
Gogg: Insane/Paranoid
Arch: Sane
tmodelt: Insane/Paranoid
Result: Possible Mafia

Kris Mafia
Block: Sane/Naive
Gogg: Insane/Paranoid
Arch: Conflicting Result
Result: Kris town

Arch Mafia
Block: Sane/Naive
Kris: Sane/Naive
Gogg: Paranoid
tmodelt: Insane
Result: Possible Mafia but not actually mafia

tmodelt Mafia
Block: Sane
Kris: Naive
Gogg: Paranoid
Arch: Insane
Result: Possible Mafia
--
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK

Totally ignore Block and Gogg. They were confirmed Naive and Paranoid due to the investigations up to the last day. So on this last day it's just me you and tmod, with Insane or Sane as the cop flavor for each of us.

Archivis - I on tmod, G on Brom
Kristopher - I on tmod, G on Arch
tmod - G on Kristopher, I on Arch

Looking at this, to tmod, he may have been the sane cop; with you or I being insane at a 50/50 chance. How am I wrong here?
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games

Loved tmodelt's double investigation.

He already investigate me and Arch, and if he investigated Brom, he would have gotten no result, so it didn't matter much.

No one else can look at what I have and confirm or deny I was right? Jebus....
--
Play DSLr Mafia: »Pub Games

reply to Jobbie

reply to Kristopher