DrModemTrust Your Doctor Premium Member join:2006-10-19 USA |
to Brom
Re: [game] Dethy 20said by Brom:I got a guilty on Modem, I am Paranoid.
Vote: Modem No, you are not. And you just committed a huge logic error: you killed both of the ones in the insane/paranoid category. I am sane, Kristopher is naive. Gog and KrisN were both in the insane/paranoid category. You put yourself as third in that category, and then you killed BOTH of them. Meaning neither of them are mafia, and you are definitely, obviously, 100% mafia. If you are paranoid, then where is the sane cop? If Kristopher is the sane cop, where is the naive cop? |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:24 pm
He's calling Gogg the sane cop, as he got a guilty on you and nothing else. |
|
|
Chaplain |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:26 pm
If DrModem is Mafia: Kristopher is Naive KrisN is Insane Goggs is Sane Brom is Paranoid
If Brom is Mafia: Kristopher is Naive KrisN is Insane Modem is Sane Goggs is Paranoid
See, KrisN is always Insane cause he got a Guilty on me. He can't be Paranoid, as it doesn't work logically. So, 50/50. |
|
DrModemTrust Your Doctor Premium Member join:2006-10-19 USA |
to Chaplain
Possible, from your point of view.
However, I would have had to guess that Gog was the sane cop and decide that brom was paranoid from the get go to weave this master plan. I have the stronger case. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:34 pm
I always guess as mafia after the first round of investigations. It's all luck anyway. Your case has not become stronger. |
|
Chaplain |
to Jobbie
After re-reading, I don't think Modem as Mafia would have tried to blow his load so early in the game. I'm going with Brom as Mafia. Here's to guesses.
Vote: Brom |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:41 pm
With a loung "BANG!!!" Kristopher put a bullet into Brom's skull just to find out he was the mafia they were looking for.
COPS WIN!!
GG all and thanks for playing. |
|
DrModemTrust Your Doctor Premium Member join:2006-10-19 USA |
DrModem
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:45 pm
SEE |
|
DrModem |
to Jobbie
Gg |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
to DrModem
There is no See. I decided based on different ideas than you were trying to provide. It's not that you had to guess, but the fact that you treid to lynch Brom early. I banked on Mafia not doing that early in game. |
|
Chaplain |
to Jobbie
GG all. Thanks for hosing Balto! |
|
DrModemTrust Your Doctor Premium Member join:2006-10-19 USA |
to Chaplain
In others words my master plan would have a been a bit to masterful to believe. |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:48 pm
Pretty much. |
|
Chaplain |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:49 pm
But now it will be something people will try in the future...... |
|
Brom Premium Member join:2010-10-26 Pittsburgh, PA |
Brom
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:57 pm
Well good game. As mafia in these games my goal is just to get it to 50/50, haha. I think in my original plan I was going to kill Modem, but then he got a guilty and an innocent result so I had to adjust. Thanks for hosting Jobbie! |
|
JobbieKeep It Simple Premium Member join:2010-08-24 Mexico |
Jobbie
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 12:58 pm
It was fun watching this game be played.
GG all! |
|
KrisnatharokPC Builder, Gamer Premium Member join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit |
to Brom
Yeah, it's tough as mafia--even if you play a perfect game, it's 50/50 if the cops investigate the "right" people to leave you enough wiggle room at LoL. |
|
DrModemTrust Your Doctor Premium Member join:2006-10-19 USA |
DrModem
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 1:23 pm
This is probably the hardest game type for the mafia player |
|
ChaplainSo It Goes Premium Member join:2002-10-11 USA |
Chaplain
Premium Member
2012-Dec-13 2:18 pm
said by DrModem:This is probably the hardest game type for the mafia player Definitely. We even had to re-tool it so Mafia had a chance to win. In the past, you got investigation results from dead players. We had to remove that. Brom played it very, very well. |
|
GoggalorPsychonaut Premium Member join:2009-06-09 Your Mind! |
Goggalor
Premium Member
2012-Dec-17 12:21 pm
Damn youse, Brom, for killing me off so early! Great game, Jobto. |
|