 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | reply to whfsdude
Re: [IPv6] Seeing two different LAN side ranges I've still got the tab open. Here's the tech info page. |
|
 NetDogPremium,VIP join:2002-03-04 Parker, CO kudos:4 1 edit | reply to JoelC707 Ping me if you need any help on this thread.. working on some other router vendor issues right now taking up a lot of my time. |
|
|
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | Thanks! I've been burning a bunch of DVDs for a friend that's supposed to come over later today so that's been taking up all my time today. I'm going to try upgrading the firewall soon (probably this evening). If that doesn't solve it, I've got existing plans to take my network down for some local server maintenance over the weekend and will lump a rebuild of the firewall from scratch into that  |
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | OK, pfSense is now at the Dec 26 12:02:01 EST release. I have yet another IPv6 subnet again. The console still shows the old "19" address I had last (though I'm sure if I do something to make it refresh it will update). The dashboard and SSH show 2601:0:ac00:5c::1 for LAN side. My PC on the other hand, even after a reboot and release/renew is hanging on to the old "19" addresses for dear life.
So how do I get it to actually let go of the old addresses and pick up the new ones? Is it supposed to change this often? |
|
 graysonfPremium,MVM join:1999-07-16 Fort Lauderdale, FL | What OS is your PC? |
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | Windows 7 x64. I see now there's release6 and renew6 but those (like regular release/renew) only appear to work for DHCP and not RA assigned addresses. I also just tried disabling/enabling the adapter with no luck. |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC Reviews:
·T-Mobile US
| reply to JoelC707 I'm on a mobile device at the moment so I will keep this short.
Your PD prefix should remain constant unless the DUID changes or you move to a different CMTS (unlikely). The DUID is based off the MAC address of the primary interface unless manually specified. So it's likely pfsense's internals did something and the DUID changed.
Keep in mind the DUID is usually a per OS thing (not per nic).
OT-protip: Windows admins, change DUID if you image as you don't want multiple DUIDs that are the same on the network. |
|
 graysonfPremium,MVM join:1999-07-16 Fort Lauderdale, FL | reply to JoelC707 7x64 here too, among others.
I would reset the Windows 7 IPv6 configuration to see if that helps.
From a command prompt with admin privileges:
netsh interface ipv6 reset
Then run ipconfig /all and post the results.
Windows has what are called Temporary IPv6 addresses which change with every reboot or restart of the network. I find them annoying because they are the source address of your connection. I prefer a more static IPv6 address. See here if you want to disable that:
»blackundertone.wordpress.com/201···dresses/ |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC Reviews:
·T-Mobile US
| reply to JoelC707 said by JoelC707:Windows 7 x64. I see now there's release6 and renew6 but those (like regular release/renew) only appear to work for DHCP and not RA assigned addresses. I also just tried disabling/enabling the adapter with no luck. The address should depref. and then depreciate when enough time has passed after not receiving an RA. I don't know much about the Windows stack but I assume that would be once it can no longer reach the router. (Max time would be AdvDefaultLifetime)
If you are still getting RAs for that prefix, you have a problem. I recommend Wireshark. |
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | reply to whfsdude No idea how I would change the DUID (though I can certainly look it up), and even so I can't see why it would change. I am spoofing the WAN MAC to maintain my original IPv4 address after I changed hardware for the firewall a while ago. Maybe somehow the real MAC is coming though but even still, there's only one real and one spoofed MAC so I should theoretically only see two different PD prefixes? This makes the fourth PD prefix I've seen in just two days. |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC Reviews:
·T-Mobile US
| reply to graysonf said by graysonf:Windows has what are called Temporary IPv6 addresses which change with every reboot or restart of the network. I find them annoying because they are the source address of your connection. I prefer a more static IPv6 address. See here if you want to disable that: RFC 4941. Enabled by default on OS X as well. Technically you can still use the SLAAC address but traffic will be sourced via PE generated address unless an established incoming connection on SLAAC is made. |
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | reply to whfsdude I've run the ipv6 reset commands and also disabled the temp address generation and it wants a reboot. Be right back... |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC Reviews:
·T-Mobile US
| reply to JoelC707 said by JoelC707:No idea how I would change the DUID (though I can certainly look it up), and even so I can't see why it would change. I am spoofing the WAN MAC to maintain my original IPv4 address after I changed hardware for the firewall a while ago. Maybe somehow the real MAC is coming though but even still, there's only one real and one spoofed MAC so I should theoretically only see two different PD prefixes? This makes the fourth PD prefix I've seen in just two days. Or pfsense lost, gained, changed an interface and is using that interface to base the DUID. Wish you could specify a static DUID (for dhcp6.conf) in the pfsense interface. |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC | reply to JoelC707 »forum.pfsense.org/index.php?topic=54210.0 |
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | reply to whfsdude Still have a "19" address on my desktop.
Given the Bellsouth circuit is PPPoE, doesn't pfSense "transform" or something that interface or something? After all it's "name" is "pppoe0" now, not xl0 like the actual adapter is. Maybe it's basing it off that instead?
I've run Wireshark before but it's been a while. I believe pfSense has support for mirroring an interface for packet capture and so should my switches. If you want me to capture anything let me know what you want captured, from where (what ports mirrored, if any) and what you want me to "do" while it is capturing. |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC | reply to JoelC707 You only have 'DHCP6' set on the 'Comcast/WAN' int, correct?
You should be getting only one /64 on the LAN. |
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | Yeah, DHCP6, PD 64. LAN is tracking WAN and ID is 0.
I'm only getting one /64 at a time. My desktop is actually the only place I've ever seen two different subnets show up at the same time. |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC Reviews:
·T-Mobile US
| reply to JoelC707 Probably not that helpful at all on my part but the screenshot you provided of the interfaces looks good.
I really think the next course of action is grab some pcaps via the web interface when you're trying to browse/access v6. Packet captures from both the WAN and LAN ints would be super helpful.
Ideally you can put them on »www.cloudshark.org/ if you don't mind a few prying eyes. |
|
 JoelC707Premium join:2002-07-09 West Point, GA kudos:5 | Given my desktop still has the "19" address, I can't do anything useful with v6 (and I checked other machines on my network, all still have the 19 addresses). Still, I did try to ping6 google.com while the two captures were running (it of course failed).
WAN side capture: »www.cloudshark.org/captures/81dbe0c66cb1 LAN side capture: »www.cloudshark.org/captures/da873c9319a1
Also uploaded raw capture files.
Edit: just realized I had it limited to 100 packets. Want me to recapture with no limit? |
|
 whfsdudePremium join:2003-04-05 Washington, DC Reviews:
·T-Mobile US
| reply to JoelC707 I see the problem (oh how pcaps make things easier)! See the RA, notice it has the different prefix "19" on the 48th nibble. It's coming from the LAN int so clearly there is a config not showing in the pfsense GUI that needs to be blown away.
»willscorner.net/t/ra.png |
|